5 ms·
Could have used the aqueduct as a telegraph as early as 7th century BCE - put a written message in the equivalent of a rubber duck, drop it in. A spotter on the
by JoeAltmaier 7y ago
Could have used the aqueduct as a telegraph as early as 7th century BCE - put a written message in the equivalent of a rubber duck, drop it in. A spotter on the other end dips it out and delivers the message. How could no one have thought of that?
- athenot 7y agoMaybe they wanted to send messages from one hilltop to another, where there was no aqueduct. Also the system described may be low bandwidth but it's also low latency. Would be useful to relay messages of a security/defense nature.
- 0898 7y agoCould not much the same effect have been achieved by pulling on a piece of string?
- rtkwe 7y agoYou'd have to make a very long piece of string and avoid it snagging, getting cut, or breaking under it's own weight. Also along that distance there's going to be a lot of slack in the system so you'd have to take that up too.
- tgarv 7y agoThat would only give you one-directional communication, while the hilltop-to-hilltop systems described in the article would work both ways.
- JoeAltmaier 7y agoStill one-directional communications is useful. Think ordering by mail from Sears.
- krilly 7y agoI was just about to ask HN to come up with some communication devices using only ancient technology. Although your rubber duck system would require less manpower than a system of signal fires, it would be MUCH slower, and probably even slower than the chains of horse riders that delivered messages Pony Express-style across the Roman Empire. In an emergency, a message could be transferred over 100 miles a day. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cursus_publicus https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cursus_publicus
- JoeAltmaier 7y agoI imagine it would be useful for some information. Crop reports etc for helping predict market fluctuations. All aqueducts lead to the city after all! Where the markets are. Anyway its nearly free, and the infrastructure was always in place. I'm just surprised it didn't get used.
- JoeAltmaier 7y agoOh! And for your ancient-networking subject, I submit: * grow trees in rows; cut them in ascii sequences (a stump is a 0). Visible for miles! * scratch dated messages in turtles' shells; sample shells continuously and collate * spread gossip where the subject is a code e.g. marital infidelity means one thing, sexual preference another. Collect gossip and reconstruct. Use political topics for ack and nack. * Grow crops each year to encode the message: corn is a 1, soybeans a 0. Study crop market reports. Caution: baud rate is low and noise level high, recommend using ECC * Become a fashion icon. Adjust skirt lengths microscopically and seasonally to encode multiple bits! A plus: observation and measurement has side benefits Let me know if any of these suit your purposes. I release them to the public domain.
- rtkwe 7y agoFriendly reminder that the code block style is basically unreadable on mobile (and not so great on desktop either) because it doesn't wordwrap.
- JoeAltmaier 7y ago