3 ms·
Could you please elaborate on what you see as being patented then? I agree a patent on a gear does not allow others to use the same gear, but said gear would n
by pedalpete 16y ago
Could you please elaborate on what you see as being patented then?
I agree a patent on a gear does not allow others to use the same gear, but said gear would need to have a uniquely defining quality which differentiates it from the other gears already in existence.
- epistasis 16y agoI'm not going to go trawling through patents (I'm superstitious), but based on only the figures in the linked article, there's at least a password protected file-system and the interface for accessing it. And going on the text, there's going to be something about the security implementation as well that's in the patent. This sounds very similar to DropBox, but this is just a high-level description. It's extremely unlikely that they could describe their system in sufficient detail without distinguishing it from DropBox in some way. There's a tendency to hear the title of a patent and think that it covers all systems that could possibly be described by that particular title. This is not the case! Also, there's a tendency to hear about a patent and think that because your system does something similar, it would be infringing against a patent, but that also is not necessarily the case. The patent system can be abused horribly, but not every instance of a patent is an instance of abuse, and each patent should be evaluated on its own merits rather than the abuses of others.
- psykotic 16y ago> Also, there's a tendency to hear about a patent and think that because your system does something similar, it would be infringing against a patent, but that also is not necessarily the case. Right. You can often dodge patent claims by doing just one little thing in a different way. When you see a very specific claim, it means the patent lawyer was forced to write it that way by the examiner. A patent application starts out as generic as possible and becomes increasingly specific in response to push-back. Of course, non-infringement is no guarantee against getting dragged into a costly legal battle.
- deleted 16y ago[deleted]