3 ms·
Your comment comes from a perspective of having been abused. While I respect your struggle, stressed analysis is not good when trying to foresee where the next
by mindslight 7y ago
Your comment comes from a perspective of having been abused. While I respect your struggle, stressed analysis is not good when trying to foresee where the next source of abuse will come from.
The commercial surveillance industry is not currently engaging in abuse on the scale the government has previously committed, but the government is not presently doing so either! Yet we are rightly concerned with setups that make such things possible - for example I presume you don't just chuckle at white supremacy protestors for being on the wrong side of history, but view them as a threat that could gain momentum any time.
The commercial surveillance industry is currently poised with a more invasive scope into everyone's personal life than a government could ever have, operates autocratically, and actively resists the desires of its targets to opt out (eg Do Not Track). That last bit puts them deeper into the domain of wielding governmental power than a straightforward monopoly. Trusting the people controlling these companies to be benevolent is a setup for failure.
> You realize that you want to give the government more power
I don't see something like the GDPR as giving the government more power, but rather just shifting it around. Government and corporate power are merging regardless (hence this thread), and it's better to have the result under democratic control than fully autocratic. The real solution is of course for people to shift to using software that they control (and hence can actually represent them), but unfortunately that seems a long ways off, or at least unevenly distributed.
- scarface74 7y agoYou realize that the government is trying to get the right to have backdoors to allow for surveillance. As far as what the government is presently doing. The “war on drugs” is presently more focused on minorities while drugs are treated as a “disease” in rural America. Presently, my son had four or five keys on his key ring that looked alike and he fumbled through them trying to get in our house. I made him a different color key so the overzealous neighbors who look at him strangely wouldn’t harass him (or call the police) for breaking into his own house. So yeah, I have a good reason to be worried about the government wanting more power to surveil people and to have a back door for encryption.
- mindslight 7y agoYes, I do realize. I do not think this is a good thing. I think the government is currently doing plenty of terrible things. It has done bad things to me personally. The magnitude of those bad things would have been from three times to infinitely worse if I were Black. You keep repeating these assertions as if we're not on the same page. We are on the same page here. Where we diverge is that you're taking this indictment, and extrapolating it to an indictment of all government regulation. I'm actually predisposed to this point of view as well, with regulatory capture and all, but the fact of the matter is that the synergy of government and corporate power is going to happen regardless of which rights we attempt to obtain for us individuals. And so we might as well try to reserve an ability to opt out of commercial surveillance as part of their bargain. Commercial surveillance eventually feeds right into that same government which has abused you and your family, while being much more agile than blunt government programs. As far as I'm aware, there is no law which requires Experian, Lexisnexis, etc to pass their surveillance data to all levels of government, including the local cops that you're rightly worried about. They do so because it is profitable, and because power generally coalesces.