2 ms·
I stopped reading at "socialist utopia Bernie Sanders is selling". It's too much for my poor European point of view, using my capitalist Chinese phone to read y
by speedgoose 7y ago
I stopped reading at "socialist utopia Bernie Sanders is selling". It's too much for my poor European point of view, using my capitalist Chinese phone to read your comment and write my answer.
- robomartin 7y agoYour poor European point of view does not seem to understand what socialism is and has done to the world. I mean, wasn't the USSR and what happened to Germany enough to teach everyone a lesson? My poor South American eyes have seen and lived this reality. And it's ugly. I have family living through it right now. This isn't to say that capitalism is perfect, nothing ever is. Yet we know what socialism has brought to humanity and it's evil. Capitalism, as imperfect as it is, has elevated more people out of poverty than any other economic and social system in the world. China is a perfect example of this, again, as imperfect as it is, they were able to elevate themselves from an agrarian society just fifty years ago due to capitalism. Nothing else could have achieved such an incredible change so quickly. Suggested reading: "The Gulag Archipelago" by Aleksandr Solzhenitsyn It's one thing to talk about socialism without every having had to live in it (as Sanders, Cortez, Warren, etc. do). It's a very different thing to have to bathe in the reality of it. Even worse, they want us to live in socialism while they are isolated from it and not subject to what it is they want to institute. Which, BTW, is typical of every single socialist regimen in the history of humanity. The ruling party live like kings and the people starve to death. All these US university students supporting someone like Sanders have no idea how their lives would be negatively affected if the brainwashing they were subjected to was the reality they had to live in day after day.
- speedgoose 7y agoWhat did happen to Germany? Are you thinking about the national socialism from the Nazi party? If you don't live in USA, why are you bringing their politics in the debate?
- robomartin 7y agoEast and West Germany. If that doesn't expose the horror that socialism can bring to a population I don't know how else to explain it. If one were to make a list of all of the advances in humanity across a range of fields of study, one would be very hard pressed to match the accomplishments of capitalism-rooted systems with what came out of the entire human history of socialist-based systems. One list is a thousand kilometers long and the other, by comparison, a post-it note. I truly don't understand how anyone can defend such ideology given the overwhelming evidence against it. The countries usually held-up as examples of "good" socialism are not socialist nations at all. The way I would characterize them is that they are capitalist nations with good to excellent social programs. And, guess, what, there's nothing wrong with that at all. But let's not call them socialism, because they are not. Socialism leads to horror and suffering. Norway, as an example, is not a socialist nation. Even better, they could not have the programs they enjoy were it not for the oil industry they intelligently use to fund aspects of their society. Bernie and company love to grab examples like Denmark and pretend they apply one-to-one to the US. We are not Denmark and Denmark is not the US. You can't do that. You can't point at the educational system in Finland and propose we do the same in the US, it won't work. We are different, the cultures are different, it's a different reality. The simplest examples of this is what happened in Japan during Fukushima and today in China with COVID-19. If a disaster like Fukushima or Wuhan happened in the US you would, more than likely, have looting and all kinds of criminal activity by people taking advantage of the situation. That is a cultural difference that is almost insurmountable. And so, if someone proposed bringing Japanese style policing into the US because "look at how well Fukushima worked out" they would be, well, insane, completely disconnected from reality. That is what Sanders and company are doing with Socialism and when they compare the US to other nations. We are not the same. We are better at a few things and worse at others. We can always improve, but let's not pretend there's some magical pill that will make everything better instantly, that's not real.
- speedgoose 7y agoYou didn't listen well in the history class, am I wrong ?