5 ms·
And yet we are 30x richer per person in a 10x bigger population since the Industrial Revolution started. That is 300x more than a zero sum model would predict.
by BurningFrog 7y ago
And yet we are 30x richer per person in a 10x bigger population since the Industrial Revolution started.
That is 300x more than a zero sum model would predict.
- loaiw1 7y ago"We"? What is being counted here, the average income and wealth? Of course people are better off with food and iPhones, but in many major European cities people with middle class incomes share apartments that were literally single family worker apartments around 1900. In terms of living space, the quality of life for the middle class is worse than 100 years ago.
- LoSboccacc 7y ago> In terms of living space, the quality of life for the middle class is worse than 100 years ago. most urbanites of today don't own a chicken, let alone a cow, in 800's standard they're worse off than serfs.
- GreenJelloShot 7y agoIn 1900, the average life expectancy for an American man was 48.3 Today, the average life expectancy for Americans is 78.7
- dlp211 7y agoThat is mostly, but not completely, due to infant mortality rates.
- solotronics 7y agoThere are exponentially more people today. In 1850 there were 23 million people in America, today there are 330 million. There was a 15x increase in population, with more than that in the city centers. Texas had a population of 212k in 1850 and 29 million today. How can you compare the size of a house or land ownership then to today?
- justizin 7y ago> Texas had a population of 212k in 1850 and 29 million today. How can you compare the size of a house or land ownership then to today? You are pinning your argument on houses in _TEXAS_ having gotten smaller? lol bc if anything they have gotten larger.
- solotronics 7y agoAt that time land was given away via grants in Texas to anyone who would live there by the hundreds of acres. Comparing that situation to land (housing) prices in a major city today is nonsensical.
- notJim 7y agoIndeed, the marxist argument is that the productivity gains of the industrial revolution would allow unprecedented human freedom, if not for their capture by the small class of people who own the means of production. The labor movement has played an enormous role in ensuring the working class gets a fairer share, via the 40-hour work week, collective bargaining, etc. We may see another example of this if Andrew Yang and other folks bullish on automation are correct. The few people who own the AI systems that replace truck drivers will get fabulously wealthy, while the large mass of workers will get nothing. In the past ~50 years in the US, labor has been on the back foot, and productivity gains have gone almost exclusively to the wealthy, rather than the working class.
- chrisco255 7y agoI'm not holding my breath on self-driving semi trucks anytime soon. They will be the last type of vehicle to be automated. It takes a lot of skill to drive an 18 wheeler from warehouse to distribution center to warehouse. They are extremely dangerous machines if not handled properly and can easily kill dozens of people if a miscalculation occurs. In the meantime, you could make the same argument about farming equipment in the 19th and 20th centuries. Yeah 90% of the population used to be farmers, and yeah the equipment automated away most of that labor, but did the former farmers and laborers lose out or did they gain, by access to the same technology... either via personal automobiles or via cheaper, more reliable supply chains of abundant food. Likewise, if and when transportation is automated, people will gain from their time saved in traffic. They will gain from cheaper costs of transportation overall which will reduce price of goods at retail. They will gain from the availability of 24/7 cheap, reliable, on-demand transportation. And no, real wages are at all time highs in the United States, with the median household income hitting $63K in 2018.
- monocasa 7y agoThey're testing self driving trucks on I-70 outside of Denver specifically to test them in the worst conditions. They're not coming, they're already here. The issue though, isn't that a specific job is going away, but instead the whole class of "human as control theory implementation" is going away. That's way more disruptive. Like, people instead becoming control software for guillotines level disruptive. > And no, real wages are at all time highs in the United States, with the median household income hitting $63K in 2018. "Real wages" mean inflation and CPI adjusted so you can actually compare them in a meaningful way. They have indeed been stagnant for median wage earners since the seventies.
- krtong 7y agoThe industrial revolution wasn't created by Capitalism, you can say it was created by proto-Capitalism, or just Mercantilism. The Industrial Revolution in almost every country was spurred on by massive government subsidies and nationalized infrastructural projects, not by anything laissez faire. Even in America where the railroads are all privatized, most of those were built during the Civil War when we nationalized the railroads and telegraphs, paid for them with taxes, used them for the war effort, and then gave them all back. Then even before that, the first factories in the U.S. were government subsidized projects called the S.U.M. in Paterson, NJ. We also have to consider how many of us come from the poorer side of the the human ancestral tree. Not many. Seems to me that each generation comes predominantly from the wealthier quartile of the last generation, so you may be biased towards thinking everything is working out, because the chance of you progenating from someone who was devastated by the great depression is unlikely -- Sort of like how the Bubonic plague kick-started the Renaissance. Half the population dies, the other half kept all their stuff and boom, economic progress from a plague -- So let's not be to hasty to believe that just because a system is leading toward prosperity just because we're alive and we have lots of stuff. And definitely don't think that we know what we're doing and it's working because literally anything would lead to more people being alive and having lots of stuff. A super volcano eruption would lead to an unpopulated, profitable and fertile region for the surviving group of people to acquire and multiply.