5 ms·
as the article points out the game was in particular desgigned to show the economic effects of private land rent, hence the original title 'the landlord's game'
by Barrin92 7y ago
as the article points out the game was in particular desgigned to show the economic effects of private land rent, hence the original title 'the landlord's game', and that is in fact a zero sum game as they aren't making any more of it.
And in particular on tech websites like these people vastly overstate how non 'zero-sum' economic activity actually is mostly because tech has been in a bubble of highly anomalous growth. (A lot of it ironically arguably not real productivity growth but rent collection through platforms and market power).
In many ways the tech startups of today look more like digital landlords than innovators whose disruption is primarily taking over the market from a host of competitors rather than improving process efficiency. If we were living in Fordist times and the assembly line and other innovations delivered 6-7% growth annually, then we could rave on about non-zero sum economies. Total factor productivity growth these days is relatively non-existent.
- xixixao 7y agoI think that’s a super narrow view of tech development. Many menial jobs are being replaced by tech, and if that’s not increasing productivity than I don’t know what Ford’s assembly lines did...
- Barrin92 7y agoI don't think it's true that many jobs are being replaced by tech. Restaurant workers, store clerks, nurses, assistances, even warehouse workers and so on are stable. Go through a list of the jobs in the US that employ most workers and none in the top 30 have been created in the last 20 years. Many economists have pointed this out. If the 'rapid innovation' that a lot of tech entrepreneurs talk about was happening (and they have an incentive to oversell it), we would see high unemployment (as people are being replaced) together with high productivity and high GDP growth. We see no such thing. The Andrew Yang robot horror scenario is nowhere in the data. By historical measures, the technological progress of the 1940s to late 1970s vastly outpaces today.
- xvedejas 7y agoI understand that land is finite, but you'll need to explain further how tech is at all similar, or else I'm not sure it's a good metaphor. Monopolistic platforms aren't great, and I'm also no fan of competitive inefficiency, but how is any of this like land? It sounds like you're implying it becomes impossible at some point to make more tech?
- BurningFrog 7y agoAnd yet we are 30x richer per person in a 10x bigger population since the Industrial Revolution started. That is 300x more than a zero sum model would predict.
- loaiw1 7y ago"We"? What is being counted here, the average income and wealth? Of course people are better off with food and iPhones, but in many major European cities people with middle class incomes share apartments that were literally single family worker apartments around 1900. In terms of living space, the quality of life for the middle class is worse than 100 years ago.
- LoSboccacc 7y ago> In terms of living space, the quality of life for the middle class is worse than 100 years ago. most urbanites of today don't own a chicken, let alone a cow, in 800's standard they're worse off than serfs.
- GreenJelloShot 7y agoIn 1900, the average life expectancy for an American man was 48.3 Today, the average life expectancy for Americans is 78.7
- dlp211 7y agoThat is mostly, but not completely, due to infant mortality rates.
- solotronics 7y agoThere are exponentially more people today. In 1850 there were 23 million people in America, today there are 330 million. There was a 15x increase in population, with more than that in the city centers. Texas had a population of 212k in 1850 and 29 million today. How can you compare the size of a house or land ownership then to today?
- bobobooey 7y agoshut it down boys, everything's already been made.
- hirundo 7y agoI just drove from Seattle to Albuquerque, through vast tracts of empty land. Land is politically, not physically scarce. That's even true right around major metropoli, let alone the hinterlands. And even that doesn't count unused potential square footage along the vertical axis. The truly constraining axis isn't x, y or z, but NIMBY.
- StillBored 7y agoEmpty land because its rainfall is insufficient to grow traditional crops. Worse, the water table in much of it is quite deep and the groundwater opportunities are scarce (and becoming more so). Compare with the US east coast where its pretty much impossible to throw a rock these days an not hit someone's house. Even in the rural areas people are frequently on plots of land that wouldn't support them without intensive industrialized farming. Check out the "field lab" video's for a now ten year video blog posting of the hardships of attempting to live off the land in the arid SW us. Somewhere along the way he started saying "i'm just not someone who can grow crops". But in reality, its more a case of he can't grow crops because they don't survive 100F summers, or seasons without a lot of rainfal. If the weeds are having a hard time growing, your potato's/whatever are probably not going to be doing well. edit: just to point out the redundancy, if you go read the newspapers in any of the major cities in the SW what you will frequently read about is water woes. Overwhelmingly those cities ability to supply water at the projected population growth rates are questionable.
- smegger001 7y agoYeah CGP Grey had a god video about federal land ownership the majorty of land in western states is federal land. https://youtu.be/LruaD7XhQ50 https://youtu.be/LruaD7XhQ50 Its kind of ridiculous. how little control states have over the land within their own boarders.
- WalterBright 7y ago> that is in fact a zero sum game Not at all. Putting a 10 story building on a lot is multiplying the area by 10.
- pslw71 7y agoAnd the proceeds still go to the landowner. The times that high rise buildings had cheap rents are long gone. So what is the point? Get out of your bubble and see how poor people are. Typical Caltech brat.
- WalterBright 7y ago> And the proceeds still go to the landowner. You can buy property and multiply its value by 10 by putting a 10 story building on it, and even sell floors on it. It happens all the time. It is simply not a fixed supply. > Typical Caltech brat LOL. My opinions on markets were quite atypical for Caltech students in the 1970s. They're likely even less typical today. Setting aside opinions, I've been in business and associated with business entrepreneurs ever since Caltech. Consistently, those with positive outlooks and willingness to take action have done very well. Those with negative views and a victim mentality have all done poorly.
- viklove 7y ago> You can buy property Most people can't afford to buy property. That's sort of the crux of this discussion. Half of Americans live paycheck to paycheck and about the same amount have less than $10k in the bank. > I've been in business and associated with business entrepreneurs ever since Caltech. Consistently, those with positive outlooks and willingness to take action have done very well. Yes, people who have money can easily acquire more money. Most people don't start out with money though, so it's rather selfish to judge the world solely from this perspective.
- WalterBright 7y ago> That's sort of the crux of this discussion. This discussion is about property being zero-sum. It isn't zero sum. > Most people don't start out with money though There are endless businesses one can start with no money.