3 ms·
I mean, could be interesting in resolving some nature vs nurture questions. Pick a famous scientist (Einstein? Hawkings?) clone them, and watch. Does this pe
by cogman10 7y ago
I mean, could be interesting in resolving some nature vs nurture questions.
Pick a famous scientist (Einstein? Hawkings?) clone them, and watch.
Does this person rise to the top of their field? Are they even interested in physics? How much of intelligence ends up being your genes vs your environment?
Probably not a good enough reason to clone though :)
- petschge 7y agoYou can do that with twin studies.
- cogman10 7y agoA little bit. There's just a much smaller sample size to draw from. The ideal candidates for these sort of studies would be monozygotic twins (3 in 1000 births) who are adopted by different parents. You can draw a few conclusions from that, but it's a pretty small sample pool. The other somewhat unique thing you'd get here is how much prenatal nutrition matters.
- saghm 7y agoOne type of study I heard about is comparing a large group of pairs of identical twins to a large group of fraternal twins (with each pair being raised together in the same household). The idea is that all the pairs from both groups experienced the same nurture (same parents, location, schooling, etc. at the same time), but one group has nearly identical genes with their twins, while the other merely has varying degrees of similar. If some measured effect is more commonly shared by the identical twins than the fraternal, it's likely due to the genetics rather than environmental factors. I never took any biology-related courses beyond high school, so I don't have any sort of knowledge to tell if this would actually work in practice, but the idea seems interesting to me.
- JohnJamesRambo 7y agoWould Stephen Hawking get ALS again? It seems the disease made him really concentrate his efforts on his studies and research more, it’s a strange thought experiment. Is it ethical to condemn another person to a life locked in ALS to get the greatness that was Stephen Hawking’s contributions to science? Surely not. I wonder what Stephen would say. Identical twin studies show that ALS seems to definitely have an environmental trigger affecting methylation of genes. My best guess is you get a Stephen Hawking twin that gets to enjoy a life of boating and walking and doesn’t contribute as much to science. Clone Beethoven and you get a talented kid that makes some SoundCloud songs and may have a small OxyContin problem. I think environment and random chance is far more important than we realize.
- dumbfounder 7y agoIf you are really interested in this you need to watch the documentary Three Identical Strangers. It's amazing.
- bena 7y agoI mean, we have this. Identical twins are essentially natural clones.