3 ms·
Nuclear is not going to happen in time and other technologies that are completely uncontroversial are already running circles around it for the past decade in t
by jillesvangurp 7y ago
Nuclear is not going to happen in time and other technologies that are completely uncontroversial are already running circles around it for the past decade in terms of cost and growth (which would be negative for nuclear). I don't expect meaningful results to come from nuclear investments in the next decades. This would be the same period of time most modern countries will cross the 50-100% covered by renewable energy mark. Much of the current deployed nuclear capacity might actually end up being retired in the same period because most of it is already on the edge of it's economic life and replacements are controversial from a cost perspective (never mind the safety). The status quo is that nuclear plants are multi billion $ projects that take decades to plan and realize and that have very dubious economics.
100% renewable everywhere is not going to happen everywhere in the next two decades; but there are plenty of countries shooting for that on a 15-20 year time line. In 20 years, most of the remaining countries will be actively planning to catch up in a hurry or simply end up importing excess energy from more clued in places at a premium. Even approved plans for nuclear plants (of which there are preciously few) would probably take longer to realize; and lets face it, mostly these plans reside in some drawer gathering dust.
Nuclear is not a solution short term (< 20 years) or mid term (< 40 years) and long term (>40 years) it will have to be cost competitive with vastly cheaper than today renewables. Which is a different way of saying the winter olympics will be organized in hell regularly.
Nuclear security alone makes it a non starter from a cost point of view. Any nuclear reactor requires 24x7 security to prevent people from depopulating their local area with a bit of explosives. Micro reactors make excellent dirty bombs and with tens of thousands of them around it's more a question of when than if somebody manages to do this. The resulting security requirements alone makes them impractical, even if they would be able to compete with the renewable solutions that will be common in a few decades. These are likely to be vastly cheaper than what we have today. The main question is how many orders of magnitude cheaper things can get before people stop caring about the price. Below a certain price, using excess renewable energy to synthesize all sorts of fuels will also become vastly cheaper than refining oil no matter how inefficient that is from an energy point of view (and it's actually not that bad). Ironically, refining oil requires a lot of energy, which comes from ... renewables. That's why Texas leads everyone else with solar and wind deployments.
- Beltiras 7y ago1 $/watt capital costs and 2.5c/kWhr for 4th gen nuclear. Solar needs to be a heck of a lot cheaper to compete with that. All you need for 4th gen to appeal to regulators is one country starting it and showing success. Indonesia will test it out. Depending on success of failure, other countries will follow suit.
- jillesvangurp 7y agoSolar bids already already dip way below that regularly for several years. By the time any of this is built, << 1c per kwh should be the norm. That only requires a 2x cost reduction which is nothing considering cost trends over the last decade with solar. Think orders of magnitude here.