5 ms·
If you want "better climate and congestion outcomes", then it seems silly to focus specifically on taxi and taxi-like services. You need the political will to
by rahimnathwani 7y ago
If you want "better climate and congestion outcomes", then it seems silly to focus specifically on taxi and taxi-like services.
You need the political will to tax the externalities you care about, e.g.
- if you use taxes to triple the price of gas, then there's more incentive to cycle instead of driving
- if you charge vehicles for using congested roads, and the charge is proportional to the vehicle's footprint, then buses become much more attractive than cars
Optionally, you can use the additional tax revenue to subsidise buses or whatever.
- satyrnein 7y agoFrom the article: > Lyft rolled out a multimillion-dollar investment to become a completely carbon-neutral transportation service through the purchase of carbon offsets If this is true, Lyft has already priced in the climate externality, and there's really nothing to complain about there.
- rahimnathwani 7y agoExcept: - the price of carbon offsets may not be high enough (particularly if you care about types of pollution other than CO2, and/or you believe that pollution near/at population centres is more damaging than pollution elsewhere) - carbon offsets do nothing to address the other issue (congestion)
- satyrnein 7y agoFor carbon specifically, isn't the price correct by definition if they reached carbon neutrality? To decrease congestion (as well as localized pollution like smog), my ideal solution would be a floating per-minute rate (based on congestion levels at that instant) for square feet of road uses. (I'd probably do the same for street parking.) Since that sounds challenging and involves possibly dystopian levels of surveillance, I'd settle for more traditional congestion pricing .
- masonic 7y agoif they reached carbon neutrality? But there's no standard or oversight for claiming "we bought credit for X tons of CO2". Example: there are stewards of old-growth forests who are selling carbon credits based on "if we cut these down, X carbon would be released", even if they cannot do so anyway by law or deed. The Headwaters forest in CA is one. Unless you know the exact basis for claimed credits, it essentially breaks down to a media/P.R. bribe.
- rahimnathwani 7y agoOn your first point: you're presuming they reached carbon neutrality. But that is a claim that's been made, not something that has been proven. It's possible that the design, operation and monitoring of the market for voluntary carbon offsets means that the purchase of a carbon offset today results in the desired reduction of CO2 emissions today or in the next few days/weeks. But I don't know enough to trust that to be true. Do you? EDIT: the above is a theoretical point. masonic included an example in a sibling comment. On your second point: - we can measure road usage using cameras at a much more granular level than that used by traditional congestion pricing schemes - the traditional scheme with which I'm most familiar (London) has a flat fee for the whole day; so, once a vehicle has entered the zone once in the day, there is no incentive to limit distance. And vehicle-miles (not # vehicles) is what causes congestion. So I wouldn't want to settle for that type of design.
- satyrnein 7y agoI don't know any more than I quoted, which I accompanied with "if this is true..." I don't think the London style congestion pricing is ideal, but what would be better?
- rahimnathwani 7y ago"I don't think the London style congestion pricing is ideal, but what would be better?" The infrastructure for the London Congestion Zone includes cameras at every entry/exit point. So the operators of the scheme can trivially know which vehicles are within the zone at any point in time. The size of each vehicle is known to the DVLA. With these pieces of information, it would be easy to implement a charge based on the amount of time spent in the zone, and the footprint of the vehicle. The above may not be optimal, but it could be done with data that is already being collected. No need for additional infrastructure, except for changing some signage.
- blackflame7000 7y agoTaxes shouldn't be a means of controlling behavior in a free society. Pass a law or leave it alone. Taxes make it so only the rich can have certain privileges the rest can't.
- rahimnathwani 7y agoMany people believe that: - markets are an efficient way to allocate resources between competing ends - many activities cause negative externalities (costs that are borne by neighbours/society in general, and not by the entity that benefits from the activity) For people who believe the above, taxes on externalities (e.g. a price paid per unit of pollution generated) are a way to improve the overall outcome for society by ensuring that, e.g. polluting activities are only undertaken if the added value exceeds the cost to society. "Taxes make it so only the rich can have certain privileges the rest can't." In the children's book 'The Lorax', a man becomes rich and, in the process, destroys a local habitat for fish and other wildlife. If his polluting activities had been taxed: - he may have produced less - he may have been incentivised to find less polluting methods to make his products - he may have done the same, but the government could have used the taxes on finding a new habitat for the fish/whatever In the story, the man and his family became rich. It was the ordinary people and animals that lost out.
- blackflame7000 7y agoThe cost to society is pretty much incalculable due to black markets and who is to say your vices shouldn't be taxed over mine? > In the children's book 'The Lorax', a man becomes rich and, in the process, destroys a local habitat for fish and other wildlife. If his polluting activities had been taxed Did you seriously just cite a fictional book as evidence to your point?
- rahimnathwani 7y ago"The cost to society is pretty much incalculable" Even if we cannot put precise figures on externalities, that doesn't mean we can't improve market efficiency and societal outcomes by taxing them based on reasonable estimates. "and who is to say your vices shouldn't be taxed over mine?" I'm not talking about taxing vices (e.g. taxes on activities that do self-harm). I'm talking about taxing externalities. "Did you seriously just cite a fictional book as evidence to your point?" I didn't cite it as evidence. I used the context from the book as an example of a situation where taxes could help drive better outcomes.