6 ms·
Study says Uber and Lyft generate 70% more pollution than the trips they replace
- mdorazio 7y agoWorth noting this is on top of creating more traffic [1] and arguably decreasing usage of public transit. Ridesharing has a lot of benefits, but it's also got quite a few negative externalities that should maybe be priced into rides somehow. In theory fuel taxes would take care of this naturally, but in the US they really don't. [1] https://www.theverge.com/2019/8/6/20756945/uber-lyft-tnc-vmt-traffic-congestion-study-fehr-peers https://www.theverge.com/2019/8/6/20756945/uber-lyft-tnc-vmt...
- magicroot75 7y agoAll this is really saying is that people are using it because it's convenient. Don't blame Uber and Lyft for filling a void that public transit has been unable to fill. Congratulate them for improving the productivity and efficiency of our economy so that we can have the disposable income to tackle long term questions like pollution.
- seibelj 7y agoSo? Flying in a plane pollutes way more than bicycling cross country, that doesn’t mean we should outlaw it. Taking an Uber has a price, and if people are paying for it then it has value.
- throwaway1777 7y agoThe price doesn’t include externalities like pollution.
- masonic 7y agoOr added traffic (which increases pollution by all other vehicles).
- tonyedgecombe 7y agoOr whether the alternative to Uber might be owning a car and hence taking a lot more journeys.
- rahimnathwani 7y agoIf you want "better climate and congestion outcomes", then it seems silly to focus specifically on taxi and taxi-like services. You need the political will to tax the externalities you care about, e.g. - if you use taxes to triple the price of gas, then there's more incentive to cycle instead of driving - if you charge vehicles for using congested roads, and the charge is proportional to the vehicle's footprint, then buses become much more attractive than cars Optionally, you can use the additional tax revenue to subsidise buses or whatever.
- satyrnein 7y agoFrom the article: > Lyft rolled out a multimillion-dollar investment to become a completely carbon-neutral transportation service through the purchase of carbon offsets If this is true, Lyft has already priced in the climate externality, and there's really nothing to complain about there.
- rahimnathwani 7y agoExcept: - the price of carbon offsets may not be high enough (particularly if you care about types of pollution other than CO2, and/or you believe that pollution near/at population centres is more damaging than pollution elsewhere) - carbon offsets do nothing to address the other issue (congestion)
- satyrnein 7y agoFor carbon specifically, isn't the price correct by definition if they reached carbon neutrality? To decrease congestion (as well as localized pollution like smog), my ideal solution would be a floating per-minute rate (based on congestion levels at that instant) for square feet of road uses. (I'd probably do the same for street parking.) Since that sounds challenging and involves possibly dystopian levels of surveillance, I'd settle for more traditional congestion pricing .
- masonic 7y ago
- WheelsAtLarge 7y agoI think it's all about the shitty public transportation system. I live in one of the biggest cities in the world yet I can't get across town, about 10 miles, in less than 1 hour and that's 1 line. If I need to take more than 2 lines that's an easy 2 hours one way. If you try that on the weekend that's going to take 3 plus hours simply because the city's transportation system reduces the number of buses running. It sux. Lyft and Uber are just filling a need. The first thing the cities need to do is fix the public transportation system. We can then criticize Lyft and Uber.
- glouwbug 7y agoAh, Toronto? Our street car system is called TTC. It stands for Take The Car
- cauterize 7y agoI’ll take a little more pollution over attending a drunk driving funeral
- contingencies 7y agoI tend to disagree but would be open to agreeing with better data. What about the cars that aren't purchased, upgraded or discarded? The land that isn't given over to parking? The waiting areas that aren't required at public transit stops? The dynamic pricing that encourages people to commute out of popular hours therefore smoothing traffic for everyone? This study is too simplistic to take at face value. PS. If it were easier to get halfway decent bikes around in most cities I would just cycle everywhere. The last bike shop I went in to in Sydney wanted AUD$3-10K (USD$3-7K) for a road bike: before extras.