3 ms·
This group is mostly made of the mentally ill, drug addicts, or most likely an individual suffering from both problems. I'm the author of the piece. I was home
by DoreenMichele 7y ago
This group is mostly made of the mentally ill, drug addicts, or most likely an individual suffering from both problems.
I'm the author of the piece. I was homeless with my adult sons for nearly six years. None of us has a mental health diagnosis and none of us does drugs or drinks. We are all tea-totallers.
I'm really tired of the "junkies and crazies" meme about homelessness. I don't think it's accurate. It's just another way we throw our hands up and claim "It can't be solved, and not because I don't care."
I think we need to solve our health care issues in the US. Medical issues contribute to chronic homelessness.
I think other special needs, such as being ADHD, contribute. ADHD isn't a mental health diagnosis of the "he's just insane and can't be made to behave" variety. But such issues do create inherent challenges to regular employment.
I have inherent challenges to regular employment. I began doing freelance writing online while homeless and that helped me get back into housing eventually.
My blogging mostly doesn't pay my bills. I occasionally get tips and I have a little Patreon support, but I've been told for years "Get a real job. Writing just doesn't pay, you slacker you." and it's like "Writing is something I can do without it creating high medical bills and making me unable to work at all. I do it well enough to sometimes hit the front page of Hacker News. Why the hell shouldn't this be a means to support myself?"
And I think some portion of it is I'm a woman and I'm poor and those are contributing factors. People don't want to admit sexism and classism influence which websites they are willing to support financially.
But, regardless of all that crazy making stuff, doing what I could do helped me improve things:
https://streetlifesolutions.blogspot.com/2019/03/a-twist-on-spoon-theory.html https://streetlifesolutions.blogspot.com/2019/03/a-twist-on-...
Anyway, it's probably time for me to walk away and not reply to too much stuff here. A lot of it will likely end up being personally offensive to me, but I didn't want to just let this remark pass without some push back. I'm so tired of the "junkies and crazies" meme. The data I'm familiar with says it's not true.
- j8014 7y agoI worked in HMIS for years and the chronic homeless are almost ALWAYS "mentally ill, drug addicts, or most likely an individual suffering from both problems." Additionally, you make a choice to support yourself however you want but "Why the hell shouldn't this be a means to support myself?" is nothing more than entitlement and wishful thinking. There are a bunch of other things that I do that make money, make sense for me, but dont pay the bills, so I adult and find work that does support me.
- prostheticvamp 7y agoI’ve worked enough EDs that this strikes me as quite true (about drugs and mental dx), but it’s not clear which way causality runs. Homelessness is not a condition in any way conducive to maintaining mental health. I’d be hard pressed to intentionally design something more effective at damaging the psyche. I agree with the entitlement comment as well. “Doing this thing works for me” is not the same as “doing this thing is valuable to anyone else”.
- DoreenMichele 7y agoWhen I had a class on Homelessness and Public Policy, the professor said something like "I'd drink too if I were homeless. The sidewalk is cold and hard." While I appreciate you bringing up that element, I actually think it's more complicated than that. In a nutshell, I think addiction generally arises out of other problems, a la the phrase "driven to drink." Blaming everything on "You drink" fails to address the underlying problems concerning why you drink. But I don't think elaborating at length while being described as having an entitled attitude because I think I should be able to get compensation for work I can do that other people clearly do value to some degree is likely to be constructive.
- lostmsu 7y ago> people clearly do value There's a difference in valuing something 10$ vs under 1¢. 100 of one can feed a person for a month, and a 100 of the other can buy you a single gum.
- icebraining 7y agoHow did you meet those individuals? Have you considered that the mentally ill and drug addicts are more likely to require medical assistance, hence skewing your perception?
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- derp_dee_derp 7y ago> I was homeless with my adult sons for nearly six years. None of us has a mental health diagnosis and none of us does drugs or drinks. We are all tea-totallers. 3 or more able bodied adults and none of you could scrape together enough cash to afford rent on a studio apartment. I call bullshit. Either you are lying or you are a shit parent. > My blogging mostly doesn't pay my bills. I occasionally get tips and I have a little Patreon support, but I've been told for years "Get a real job. Writing just doesn't pay, you slacker you." and it's like "Writing is something I can do without it creating high medical bills and making me unable to work at all. I do it well enough to sometimes hit the front page of Hacker News. Why the hell shouldn't this be a means to support myself?" Oh. I see. Well, no wonder you're homeless: you're living in fantasy world. If you're blogging isn't enough to pay the bills, try something else!
- chaostheory 7y agoLike you, I’ve also been homeless myself in the past. I’m in the 80%. Using a combination of public and private help, I was able to pull myself out of homelessness after several months. I was eventually able to graduate with a degree, enabling me to become a software engineer. My experience matches the research. I’ve also volunteered at soup kitchens for a while. That personal experience also matches the research concerning the chronically homeless.
- DoreenMichele 7y agoPerception and reality don't always align and our existing point of view shapes our perception. While homeless, I was throwing up my lunch one day in the bushes because of my medical condition and someone driving past in a car yelled out their window "Drink too much last night?" taking glee in what they were all too happy to assume was evidence that their prejudice against the homeless and hatred of them was justified. I will also note that I'm quite nonplussed by the people showing up here to insist in writing in public that they were part of "the good homeless," the deserving homeless, the folks in need of a small break and not like those people. My father was mixed race and routinely told racist jokes. I've recently realized he probably looked a lot more mixed race than I understood growing up because of photos I've seen of a full-blooded Native that bear an uncanny resemblance to my father. So I strongly suspect that my father told racist jokes to implicitly signal he was white and "not one of them" in a racist world that does terrible, horrible things to non-whites on a routine basis. To me, that reads as an expression of fear and an act of self preservation in an ugly, hostile classist world. But it's an act of self preservation that preserves the status quo. I blog to try to present the data and point of view I'm aware of that conflicts with the accepted narrative that I believe keeps these problems entrenched. Perhaps it won't make any difference. But perhaps it will.
- chaostheory 7y agoResearch data tends to trump personal anecdotes, both yours and mine included. Several separate studies on the homeless have consensus. I did not say I was part of the “good homeless”. What I said was that the vast majority of the homeless aren’t chronically homeless and I was part of that non-chronic population. I’m also saying that for the chronically homeless, homelessness is just the symptom of the underlying problem of mental illness. This is another way of saying, “they didn’t get the right kind of help that they needed”. When people still can’t be high functioning with all the social safety nets available, we have to re-examine the strategy that isn’t working for them. I don’t feel the half measures you’ve described is enough for the mentally ill We’ve had this discussion before months ago. We can just agree to disagree.