4 ms·

Assuming good faith I invite you to try and learn more about the CAA (law in question). I don’t know why people keep saying it takes away citizenship of Indian

Assuming good faith I invite you to try and learn more about the CAA (law in question). I don’t know why people keep saying it takes away citizenship of Indian Muslims when it only provides citizenship to persecuted non muslim minorities from neighbouring countries because of the promise made when the partition on the basis of religion was done. The minorities are living in hell in Pakistan (girl kidnapped from her marriage ceremony to be forcefully “wedded” to a Muslim guy) and to a lesser extent in Bangladesh. Minorities dropped from 20% to less than 2%. While in India it rose from 14M to 200M. It also doesn’t give citizenship to people who have already not entered India before 2014. On the issue of non inclusion of Muslims, it’s just practically not possible when you have more than 30,000,000 illegal immigrants from Bangladesh according to 90s figures, unless you want to just give citizenship to everybody. India has extremists of every religion like everywhere else. Some people only ever see Hindu extremism. They are either removed from reality or have an agenda.

dharmach 7y ago
India shouldn't discriminate her citizens based on religion that is understandable but to expect that she must also treat Muslim and non-Muslim citizens of Islamic countries as equally suffering refugees would be a discrimination.
ak1234 7y ago
Radical Hinduism is more dangerous than radical Islam. The harmless looking vegetarian upper caste Hindus who work in the next cubicle is nothing but a cauldron of hate and bigotry. After all they started practicing un-touchability and casteism before Westerners knew a continent called Africa existed.
- legolas2412 7y ago
  Radical Hinduism more dangerous than radical Islam? No way. Have you lost all critical thinking? We are protesting this because india is a secular country that is on its way to become a theocratic Hindu nationalist country. We say that modi is making India a Hindu Pakistan. You see, we consider that derogatory. Pakistan is derogatory. It's because Pakistan is already a theocratic country, and even with CAA and NRC, India is better for its religious minorities.
  - ak1234 7y ago
    Yes, radical Hinduism is more dangerous. Radical Islam is on the wane...hit its peak with Osama, ISIS etc. Even an idiot like Muhammed Bin Salman helps to defeat radical Islam (if not he will be gone.) What remains is Iran led Shia groups. They are not as vicious as Sunni groups financed by Saudis. Radical Hinduism is what you see in India right now. And the biggest enablers are the suit-boot wearing Hindu upper castes in USA, the original inventors of bigotry and racism.
foolinaround 7y ago
> when it only provides citizenship to persecuted non muslim minorities from neighbouring countries Does it provide citizenship to non-muslim Tamils from SriLanka? Are'nt they persecuted too? If not, why not?

dharmach 7y ago

India shouldn't discriminate her citizens based on religion that is understandable but to expect that she must also treat Muslim and non-Muslim citizens of Islamic countries as equally suffering refugees would be a discrimination.

ak1234 7y ago

Radical Hinduism is more dangerous than radical Islam. The harmless looking vegetarian upper caste Hindus who work in the next cubicle is nothing but a cauldron of hate and bigotry. After all they started practicing un-touchability and casteism before Westerners knew a continent called Africa existed.

legolas2412 7y ago
Radical Hinduism more dangerous than radical Islam? No way. Have you lost all critical thinking? We are protesting this because india is a secular country that is on its way to become a theocratic Hindu nationalist country. We say that modi is making India a Hindu Pakistan. You see, we consider that derogatory. Pakistan is derogatory. It's because Pakistan is already a theocratic country, and even with CAA and NRC, India is better for its religious minorities.
- ak1234 7y ago
  Yes, radical Hinduism is more dangerous. Radical Islam is on the wane...hit its peak with Osama, ISIS etc. Even an idiot like Muhammed Bin Salman helps to defeat radical Islam (if not he will be gone.) What remains is Iran led Shia groups. They are not as vicious as Sunni groups financed by Saudis. Radical Hinduism is what you see in India right now. And the biggest enablers are the suit-boot wearing Hindu upper castes in USA, the original inventors of bigotry and racism.

foolinaround 7y ago

> when it only provides citizenship to persecuted non muslim minorities from neighbouring countries Does it provide citizenship to non-muslim Tamils from SriLanka? Are'nt they persecuted too? If not, why not?