6 ms·
I think high deductibles are an excellent choice for those of us who do well financially. I do that myself. But I should note that 40% of Americans can't handle
by wpietri 7y ago
I think high deductibles are an excellent choice for those of us who do well financially. I do that myself. But I should note that 40% of Americans can't handle sudden a $400 expense, so it doesn't work well for everybody: https://www.cbsnews.com/news/nearly-40-of-americans-cant-cover-a-surprise-400-expense/ https://www.cbsnews.com/news/nearly-40-of-americans-cant-cov...
- exabrial 7y agoOddly enough, high deductibles also work well for those people who maintain their health and prioritize it financially.
- Johnny555 7y agoBut the penalties for deferring maintenance/repairs on your car are less severe than deferring maintenance for your body. No matter what happens to your car, you can throw enough money at it to fix it, or at the very least, replace it with something comparable. If you get into an accident you can tape the bumper back on until you get it repaired (or never repair it) But if you decide "I can't really afford this $1500 colonoscopy this year, and honey if we defer that $3000 MRI for your abdominal pain to next year too, then we can do them both in one year and hit our deductible"... if you wait too long, something that would have been easy to treat may no longer be easy... or even possible to treat. People shouldn't need to prioritize health care due to financial reasons.
- rebuilder 7y agoAnd don't have freak accidents, children with disabilities or other unforeseeable health-related issues.
- zrobotics 7y agoBut for people on lower incomes, why would they be better served with low-deductible (and expensive) policies? If they can't afford a sudden $400 expense, why is spending additional money each month for a more comprehensive policy a good idea? Remember, auto insurance doesn't cover mechanical failures. A perfectly valid option is to have a higher deductible, and use offset that with putting the funds that would have been needed for the more expensive policy into a general savings account. However, that does require some financial discipline and planning. And for people who make little enough money where saving that money every month isn't a viable option, they really have no business buying any sort of comprehensive auto insurance anyway. Liability only insurance is far cheaper, and provides all the protection necessary to prevent a car accident from being financially world-ending.
- mcherm 7y ago> And for people who make little enough money where saving that money every month isn't a viable option, they really have no business buying any sort of comprehensive auto insurance anyway. Liability only insurance is far cheaper, and provides all the protection necessary to prevent a car accident from being financially world-ending. You might want to consider this from a different perspective. For the well-paid like myself who has invested well and has substantial savings, a liability insurance claim that could potentially cost several hundred thousand dollars is "financially world-ending", while having to pay for repairs on my car after an accident is not. But for someone with no savings, being unable to drive their car because they cannot afford to pay for repairs after an accident may mean losing their job (public transportation isn't so great where they live) and definitely qualifies as "financially world-ending" for them. Whereas several hundred thousand dollars of liability is actually LESS of a threat -- the lawyers can quickly discover that they don't own anything worth collecting and may not even go after their assets, but even if they do, at worst it empties their bank account (which we presumed has less than 400 dollars in it).
- wpietri 7y agoThis sounds painfully like somebody who is not and never has been poor.
- aaronchall 7y ago
- SamReidHughes 7y agoAt low income, what makes sense is to get a cheaper used car. Bam, you've got $1k for an emergency car expense. That $400 stat, if it can be believed, spans from no income up nearly to median income.
- perl4ever 7y agoLook at the bar graph. It's hard to tell exactly what the numbers are, if people chose multiple answers, but 40% has to be based on the idea that using a credit card even if you pay it off at the next statement means you "can't handle" an expense. That's crazy. It's basically prepper/goldbug logic. Consumer credit is the devil, so anyone who uses it has failed at life.