6 ms·
This misses the elephant in the room: How can they "find" anything in prison? The only answer is corruption of the prison staff. That has to be the root cause.
by mytailorisrich 7y ago
This misses the elephant in the room: How can they "find" anything in prison?
The only answer is corruption of the prison staff. That has to be the root cause.
[1] https://www.theguardian.com/society/2018/sep/01/rise-in-prison-officers-contraband-smuggling https://www.theguardian.com/society/2018/sep/01/rise-in-pris...
- tokamak-teapot 7y agoIt is indeed the root cause. But it’s not easy to tackle. If you consider the possible remedies, which seem viable?
- mytailorisrich 7y agoTo tackle corruption of staff and, granted, to enforce serious procedures, is the easiest and most effective route to solve drug issues in prison. As long as drugs can enter prisons they will. Clearly there does not seem to be much political will to do so. It's easier to pretend and, after all, the victims are only inmates.
- bananamerica 7y agoSpending more money would probably help. At least in the US, most people are not fond of the idea of spending more money with the prison system.
- DanBC 7y agoIt's very easy to smuggle things into English prisons and it doesn't require corrupt staff.
- majormajor 7y agoRoot cause is a vague term. What's the root cause of people being corruptible, and how do you fix that?
- irrational 7y agoPut them in prison?
- ilammy 7y agoThey did, even issued them uniforms.
- ghostbrainalpha 7y agoI know Hacker News isn't usually a fan of Humor, but that comment made my day.
- Nasrudith 7y agoThere are many technically correct answers. The fire triangle shows that a root cause is not a singleton. 1. Them being alive. Obvious fix but not useful or moral. 1a. The less omnicidal but potentially more niche in practice answer is "get humans out of the loop" - that worked quite successfully with automated phone switchboards. 2. Their incentives being misaligned with the nominal goal. The easiest fix there is a "sarcastic AI" goal of making the corruption the explicit legal goal aligning them. 3. Lack of effective oversight - they can only be corrupt if they can get away with it without sufficient negative consequences. Certainty and speed is more important than magnitude and not being enough to be worth doing anyway in spite of punishment. 3a. Enforcement in practice suffers from "turtles all the way down" with who watches the watchers. Transparency and multilateralism can help but well international law is only a series of guidelines because of it being multilateral between powers.
- save_ferris 7y agoNot necessarily. Smuggling contraband into prison has got to be as old as the existence of prison itself, and there are numerous examples of contraband being snuck in and traded without the knowledge of the staff. It’s errant to assume that all cases of contraband existing in prison is due to corrupt staff. In fact, this issue is becoming more and more of a challenge today as drone technology advances and decreases in price[0]. 0: https://www.npr.org/2017/11/15/564272346/prisons-work-to-keep-out-drug-smuggling-drones https://www.npr.org/2017/11/15/564272346/prisons-work-to-kee...
- mytailorisrich 7y agoSmuggling is impossible unless staff turn a blind eye, or procedures are sufficiently lax. Preventing visitors from passing things to inmates is not rocket science, if you allow visitors at all. As for drones, let me try to fly a drone over GCHQ or the Pentagon and let's see what happens... But over a prison and then actually drop something? "Oh well, what can we do? Can't even find what they drop..." The point in all of this is that no-one cares too much so it happens, but it is avoidable. I was expecting a bit more of a can-do attitude on HN instead of accepting this sorry state of affairs!
- mschuster91 7y ago> or procedures are sufficiently lax. ...or effective procedures would toss human rights into the bin. Client-Attorney communication secrecy and visitation rights are one point, body cavity searches and visitation rights for close relatives of inmates another.
- Traster 7y agoYeah and hacking is impossible unless software developers turn a blind eye or procedures are sufficiently lax.
- ozim 7y agoGood one. People just don't see how life in general is complicated. How much more details are hiding in someones else job. They don't see how their senses are limited. Prison guard - standing all day with rifle, anyone can do that. Nurse - giving pills and injections, what is so hard about it? Software dev - sitting behind computer all day lazy slob, he could get some real job :)
- rwmurrayVT 7y agoIn a minimum security facility there are often no fences. I was at Morgantown and you could get anything you wanted for approximately 4x the retail value. It was so fucking hot there guys would have their families buy a "prison" issue fan on Amazon and send it to someone who's family lived in Morgantown. Then they'd run out and bring it back in the middle of the night. Cigarettes were $2 each or $20 for a pack. Dip is like $12 a can for the Kayak brand with a 99c sticker on it. There were over 800 of us and around 10 staff on actual security detail at a time. There were maybe 40 searches a week and they were normally targeted on the people that they had suspicions about. It happened to me one time and they guy found my camel crush. Thankfully I had been there less than 3 weeks so he just assumed someone stashed it there since I moved into an empty bunk. After that I never had another issue. Spice is horrible. We'd have people vomiting regularly. They'd get "stuck" outside when we got called back into the units. It's really gnarly stuff that I would not willingly ingest. The most popular drug was definitely suboxone. The drug tests were not working for subs when I was still there. Supposedly they were just starting to come out with some for it that the BOP used. Every thing went in a cycle. One guy would run most of the smuggling for the white people. I'm not going to name names here, but his balance sheet showed about $75k in profit over a rolling 6 month period. Another ran it for most of the African Americans. Eventually runners would get caught or the ring leader would get busted with a cell phone. That gives you an immediate upgrade to the next highest level facility. Prices would jump until someone was crazy enough to start it all back up again. Right before I left the biggest person got caught with a sim card. Prices for cigarettes went up to nearly $15 each. That was if you were remotely lucky enough to find one. A guy came back on probation violation and luckily enough I was his bunk mate. Things went back to regular within a couple of weeks. He made more in Morgantown than he did on the street... Subs/meth/vape juices could be applied to paper inside of books or letters. Anything liquid and dried usually could come in that way, but in a minimum it's not even worth the hassle.
- ErikAugust 7y agoSounds strange maybe but, does everyone have to participate in black markets? Are there any penalties for just being without vices like you mentioned?
- coldtea 7y agoPeople have been able to find stuff in prison since the time of Julius Ceasar, in every country and every time. There's no avoiding that...
- mytailorisrich 7y ago> There's no avoiding that... Of course it's avoidable. But no-one cares enough: As long as it is hard enough to escape then the public does not care too much whether inmates use drugs, rape/fight each other, or what not, especially if stopping that would mean spending more on prisons. The fallacy (or hypocrisy) is to pass off lack of will as practical impossibility. The UK and the US are among the richest countries on Earth and they are democracies. There is no escaping that the state of their prisons represents the collective decision of society (us all).
- 8note 7y agothe key is to keep the prisoners naked at all times, with a plug in their rectum that alarms when taken out, resulting in a beating by the guards. a better option, and one more befiting of these rich democracies is to just let them have some of those affects and get on with it. controlling every inch of their lives is the opposite of the democratic ideal