4 ms·
Let me put it this way. People tout WhatsApp as being secure, and yet when it's working allegedly as intended, people who have not been invited to join a group
by ColinWright 7y ago
Let me put it this way.
People tout WhatsApp as being secure, and yet when it's working allegedly as intended, people who have not been invited to join a group chat can nevertheless so so. Genuinely, do you not find that surprising?
You ask:
> How would you expect it to work?
I would expect it to work over secure channels, and not over links that can be discovered and indexed by Google.
Look, I don't have knowledge to debate this. I've mentioned it to several non-technical people I know who use WhatsApp and they genuinely are surprised. They thought it would be secure, they thought that creating private chat groups would be, you know, private.
As I've said repeatedly, I don't know how it works, I don't know where the muggles' expectations are deviating from those of the technically literate, but I do know that people are finding it surprising that their allegedly private groups chats are not, in fact, private.
Clearly your expectations are different.
But I'll stop now, since I'm failing so spectacularly to explain my concerns.
- Tomte 7y ago> I would expect it to work over secure channels, and not over links that can be discovered and indexed by Google. How on earth? The web and links are pretty much the only thing we have to point people towards internet services. And I just checked, in the app, directly under the link, there is the following sentence: "Every WhatsApp user can follow this link to enter the group. Share it only with people you trust" (my translation, English wording probably differs). > Look, I don't have time to debate this. So instead of finding out what's happening (it's still not clear!), you'd rather use your time to FUD your friends and acquaintances. > I've mentioned it to several non-technical people I know who use WhatsApp and they are surprised. Of course, if you coloured it with your opinion and speculation, like you did in this thread.
- ColinWright 7y ago>> I've mentioned it to several non-technical people I know who use WhatsApp and they are surprised. > Of course, if you coloured it with your opinion and speculation, like you did in this thread. So it's spreading FUD to tell them the exact thing that's there in the app? Pointing out that links to group chats have been found on Google searches is spreading FUD? Pretty sure we must be starting from different premises, and that it's unlikely this will go anywhere. You've made it clear that you think it's reasonable for it to work the way it days, I've tried to make it clear that people are surprised that links to group chats are being found via web searches. I've also tried to make it clear that I think their level of surprise is reasonable. Not sure there's much more to say.