4 ms·
I don't use WhatsApp[0] so I don't know how these things work. But here is a summary from the article: > People can create a group chat in WhatsApp; > People
by ColinWright 7y ago
I don't use WhatsApp[0] so I don't know how these things work. But here is a summary from the article:
> People can create a group chat in WhatsApp;
> People can then be invited to join that;
> There is a reasonable expectation that only those invited can join;
> That turns out not to be the case;
> Group chats can be found via Google search;
> Random, uninvited people can then join;
> Those who were invited might find that surprising.
So the way WhatsApp is described, people might expect that their groups chats are invitation only and end-to-end encrypted. Personally, even though I don't use WhatsApp at all, I'd be deeply annoyed to discover that a "private" group chat, joined through being sent an invitation, was potentially discoverable via a Google search and could be joined by people other than those to whom an invitation was sent.
I think non-technical people, and some technical people, will find it very surprising.
================
[0] I don't use WhatsApp because the terms of service require that I permit them to slurp my address book, and I have contact details for people who really don't want their details leaked.
- Tomte 7y agoI'm still unclear about who is posting the link: WhatsApp itself, somewhere under whatsapp.com? Or random users on whatever web sites, Facebook etc.? If the latter (and that's how I understood it): if you give people an invite link, that link can be used to access the group. Obviously. Works as intended. If you don't want random people to show up, don't post the link publicly, give it only to trusted people you actually want in the group.
- ColinWright 7y agoAs I say, I don't use WhatsApp, so I don't know. However, quoting from another report on this: > If you want to comb through Google Search to find out if your private WhatsApp group is indexed, just start with a “chat.whatsapp.com” string and then enter in some information specific to your chat. Vice did this and was able to find several chat groups related to sharing porn as well as a chat that describes itself as being for NGOs accredited by the United Nations. These chat groups listed out members’ names as well as contact information, in some cases phone numbers. -- https://www.androidauthority.com/private-whatsapp-1085998/ https://www.androidauthority.com/private-whatsapp-1085998/ So I don't know who's sharing these links, or what the mechanism is for doing so, but I'm pretty sure people won't be expecting the groups to be found via a Google search. As such, whatever the mechanism may be, dismissing this as "Works as intended" seems to me to be breathtaking arrogance. Your opinion may differ, but I think muggles would be surprised by this, and potentially it's only being kept in the dark about it that's stopping them from being very angry.
- Tomte 7y ago> dismissing this as "Works as intended" seems to me to be breathtaking arrogance. I really don't like your arrogant dismissal. I've tried to understand the issue, after three articles it's still unclear. But let's step back for a second. How would you expect it to work? How could anyone else be at fault than the one posting the link on public web sites (and it doesn't look like it's WhatsApp). Say, I'm posting a link to your LinkedIn profile here on Hacker News. How do you propose that LinkedIn(!) stops following other people that link to your profile? Assuming you didn't want to have that posted, wouldn't you take umbrage with me? What mechanism do you expect WhatsApp to implement to make sure that (a) a link can be followed by the right people, after sharing it publically and (b) the link cannot be followed by the wrong people and (c) the link is enough to enter the group, so no password, because that#s the whole point of that feature – and a password would be shared just alongside the link anyway.
- ColinWright 7y agoLet me put it this way. People tout WhatsApp as being secure, and yet when it's working allegedly as intended, people who have not been invited to join a group chat can nevertheless so so. Genuinely, do you not find that surprising? You ask: > How would you expect it to work? I would expect it to work over secure channels, and not over links that can be discovered and indexed by Google. Look, I don't have knowledge to debate this. I've mentioned it to several non-technical people I know who use WhatsApp and they genuinely are surprised. They thought it would be secure, they thought that creating private chat groups would be, you know, private. As I've said repeatedly, I don't know how it works, I don't know where the muggles' expectations are deviating from those of the technically literate, but I do know that people are finding it surprising that their allegedly private groups chats are not, in fact, private. Clearly your expectations are different. But I'll stop now, since I'm failing so spectacularly to explain my concerns.
- Tomte 7y ago> I would expect it to work over secure channels, and not over links that can be discovered and indexed by Google. How on earth? The web and links are pretty much the only thing we have to point people towards internet services. And I just checked, in the app, directly under the link, there is the following sentence: "Every WhatsApp user can follow this link to enter the group. Share it only with people you trust" (my translation, English wording probably differs). > Look, I don't have time to debate this. So instead of finding out what's happening (it's still not clear!), you'd rather use your time to FUD your friends and acquaintances. > I've mentioned it to several non-technical people I know who use WhatsApp and they are surprised. Of course, if you coloured it with your opinion and speculation, like you did in this thread.