4 ms·
> That is the whole point of copyright Copyright was created centuries ago when people needed a literal printing press in order to create copies at scale. They
by matheusmoreira 7y ago
> That is the whole point of copyright
Copyright was created centuries ago when people needed a literal printing press in order to create copies at scale. They had to be a major industry player in order to infringe copyright. We're living in the 21st century: people infringe copyright without even realizing it and all but the worst offenders go unpunished.
Whatever the point of copyright was when it was conceived, it no longer applies. It's obviously incompatible with free computing as we know it today. In order for copyright to be enforceable, computers that run unauthorized software must be made illegal. Otherwise, people will always be able to copy whatever data they want and there's little anyone can do about it.
Part of the social contract behind copyright is giving the public free access to the works of humanity after the protection expires. It's clear now that the copyright industry has no intention of ever letting these protections ever expire. There's no reason for the public to recognize copyright as legitimate when the copyright holders refuse to keep up their end of the deal.
- unityByFreedom 7y agoGood luck with that argument. Sounds a lot like communism, where everything is free and you don't need to worry about working. Oops, now nobody is working and there is no stuff!
- simion314 7y ago>Sounds a lot like communism, where everything is free and you don't need to worry I think you are unaware of how stupid that sounds, maybe go and read what communism is/was or stop commenting when you have no idea and you learn things from Star Trek. FYI people were/are working in communism and things are not free (so 100% comment you had there)
- unityByFreedom 7y agoCheck out the movie Mr. Jones. We've all read about the results of communism. From Lenin/Stalin to Mao, it has catastrophically failed many times over. Giving up your property rights to the state results in famine when the state corrals all resources to the capital. Queue someone saying "what about the problems with capitalism?" Capitalism, the worst economic system, after all the others.
- matheusmoreira 7y ago> Sounds a lot like communism, where everything is free and you don't need to worry about working. Communism implies an economy. When it comes to data, there is nothing to economize. It's abundant, there's more than enough for everyone. The only reason the internet isn't a post-scarcity society is we still have laws like copyright holding us back. > Oops, now nobody is working and there is no stuff! Pretty weird seeing this argument on Hacker News of all places. Lots of developers work for no financial reward, myself included. Scratching one's own itch is a hacker tradition and it disproves the notion that nobody would create anything if it wasn't for copyright.