6 ms·
I think we're approaching the peak of the hype cycle for psychedelics. Articles like this one glorify LSD as a wonder drug without exploring any of the associat
by PragmaticPulp 7y ago
I think we're approaching the peak of the hype cycle for psychedelics. Articles like this one glorify LSD as a wonder drug without exploring any of the associated risks.
Readers skim over the details of the associated intensive guided therapy sessions. They assume that they can get the same exaggerated results by dosing darknet-sourced LSD at home, alone, without the concomitant therapy sessions used in clinical research studies. The articles are so focused on the drug that the associated therapy sessions feel like a neglected footnote.
Meanwhile, journalists and internet commenters both ignore the very real risks of framing psychedelics as a DIY miracle cure for people with difficult to treat mental health issues. Before this current phase, the universally accepted advice for psychedelic experimenters was to never use psychedelics if you had underlying mental health issues and to always have a sitter present to monitor and guide your trip. The reframing of psychedelics as a miracle cure has triggered a wave of people ignoring that advice, dosing alone at home without any form of supporting therapy to frame their trips.
If you spend some time browsing Reddit, it's not hard to find bizarre stories of people triggering week, month, or even year long episodes of worsened depression, derealization, PTSD-like symptoms, or HPPD from psychedelic experimentation. If "big pharma" produced a drug with possible side effects like that, we'd be hearing a very different story. Yet LSD and other underground treatments get a free pass in the media at this point in the hype cycle.
Psychedelic research is very interesting and potentially promising, but I hope the current wave of one-sided glorification comes to an end soon. If we want to see proper psychedelic research continue and for the field to be taken seriously, it's important that we stay grounded in our reporting of the topic.
- pstuart 7y agoWhile all of this is true, there's an incredible amount of guesswork in other medications that impact mental health. Many drugs come with warnings of suicidal ideation and other dangers. In my own experience as a patient it was always a case of "let's see how this one works for you." My point is simply that every drug carries some risk and that every one of us can react differently to them (including ourselves as we age). I'm pro-psychedelics but agree that they should be treated with utmost respect.
- PragmaticPulp 7y ago> My point is simply that every drug carries some risk and that every one of us can react differently to them It's false equivalency to suggest that because all drugs have some risk, we should treat all drugs as equally risky. Yes, all drugs carry risk. But no, all drugs do not carry equivalent risk profiles. When we're discussing the risks of psychedelics, it's dishonest to try to dismiss them as equivalent to every other drug under the sun. We need to have an honest conversation about the potential risks and how they differ from other psychiatric medications. This was my point with the opening post: Everyone is so excited about the potential applications of psychedelic medicine that we're overlooking traditional logic. If we want to see the field of psychedelic research continue moving in the right direction, it's important that we stay rigorous with our logic and reporting. Can you imagine if a brand name drug was found to have a side effect of triggering psychotic episodes in vulnerable patients, and the drug company responded with "To be fair, all drugs have some risk". HN would be all over that faulty logic if it came from a corporation, but for some reason psychedelics get to play by a different set of rules.
- mistermann 7y agoI doubt this was your intent, but my reading of your words kind of leaves me thinking that someone with no background knowledge would leave thinking there is(!) great known danger with at home LSD use, and also that achieving results reasonably equivalent to some of the outcomes described in clinical studies requires(!) the counselling that accompanied it. As for now, the only evidence that can answer such questions is anecdotal user stories, of which we have lots, and from my reading in that realm, while there is undoubtedly very real risk involved the vast majority of feedback is positive. If someone who could benefit from these substances is in a position where they are unable to obtain professional services (most people I'd think at this stage), it would be unfortunate if they didn't bother looking into it because of reading overly protective risk assessments.
- kdmccormick 7y agoTo be fair, many antidepressants and stimulants can lead to psychotic episodes in vulnerable patients. This happens a non-trivial amount in Bipolar-I patients taking antidepressants. It's a stated side effect that psychiatrists take into account. However, I agree with the general sentiment of your comment, especially given that pharma drugs that trigger episodes would do over the course of months whereas a psychadelic can do it in an hour.
- TheOperator 7y ago>Before this current phase, the universally accepted advice for psychedelic experimenters was to never use psychedelics if you had underlying mental health issues That advice was an overly broad crock and some of the most promising applications of psychadelics are for treating things like treatment resistant depression. In regards to always having a sitter I do think there is a ton of temptation to forgo this step yet I think the drug is simultaneously less effective and more dangerous if you forgo this step. Still I rarely hear anybody fail to stress the importance of a sitter.
- PragmaticPulp 7y ago> some of the most promising applications of psychadelics are for treating things like treatment resistant depression. The most promising applications for psychedelics are studied in conjunction with intensive therapy sessions before, during, and after the psychedelic dose. The problem is that too many people read this articles and conclude that the drug is doing all the work, ignoring the rigorous therapy that surrounds the psychedelic dosing in all of the clinical studies. My point was that taking LSD in your basement alone is not 1:1 equivalent to the clinical research that uses LSD as an ingredient in a structured therapy program. Even this article explains LSD use in the context of therapy. Yet people read these articles and assume that LSD operates as a standalone wonder drug.
- TheOperator 7y agoI have a bit of a different take but reach a similar conclusion. I think the population of people trying these experimental treatments has already been though long periods of ineffectual therapy and self-help attempts. I believe being in such a state puts you in a prime position to benefit from the drug as I roughly see it as a sort of accelerant for the mind. It can make a lot of those lessons click. Which is part of why I'm very skeptical of the idea psychadelic are a drug for the mentally healthy... I suspect the outcomes might actually be worse on average and question the common wisdom. I'm unconvinced a therapists supervision is the "secret sauce". Yet there are many many reports even before recent studies that having a "sitter" or "shaman" type was essential and the presence of a therapist just seems like a medicalization of that principle.
- RankingMember 7y agoI think what we're seeing is similar to what we were seeing during the push for legalization of marijuana- a crowdsourced P.R. campaign that highlighted the positives and neglected the negatives in an effort to try and counterbalance the negative inertia that decades of "reefer madness" hysteria had wrought.
- _jal 7y agoI think this is mostly right, along with the sort of messy communications you get with anything else. The conventional wisdom - that LSD is only for Bad People Who Want To Hurt Themselves, or some variation - is being replaced. This doesn't happen by everyone sitting quietly to lectures and then calmly attempting to set each others' expectations to cautiously optimistic, after several more rounds of trials. No, people get interested, some more enthusiastically than others. Some will do stupid things, others will spread lots of nonsense. I'm sure some people will be hurt/end up dead through no fault of their own. And eventually we find a new normal. This is just how humans do things. Compare with robocars. Did we wait until level-whatever full autonomy was hit and fully tested? No, we are letting a few people die while getting the bugs worked out.
- saiya-jin 7y agoLSD/mushrooms are way more powerful, you can't compare those. What's next, mescalin or ayahuasca? I've done shrooms couple of times, it was profoundly mind-and-life-changing experience and in many ways the most intense and beautiful event in my life. But I wouldn't recommend it to maybe 1/3 to 1/2 of people I know, simply because I wouldn't be sure it wouldn't mess them up badly, like really badly. At least not under professional supervision and adequate gradual dosing. You make everybody smoke weed few times, not much bad can happen. You make everybody trippin', and consequences are unpredictable. Show some respect for the stuff, it very well deserves it.
- CodiePetersen 7y agoShrooms are not way more powerful. To put shrooms on lsd level is kind of ridiculous. They're all different from each other of course but most are very mild compared to LSD. The very common ones are just serotonin reuptake inhibitors. I've seen some people say they see shimmers of light or visuals but I've taken the same ones and all I get is super happy and motivated. It's great but it's not on lsd level. I'd say it's same level of weed. I know everyone acts different to everything but I've had trippier experiences with weed where my memory was so short I thought I was just appearing in places and forgot what my arms felt like. So I think the concerns of shrooms are greatly over exaggerated.
- refurb 7y agoIt's a repeat of what happened in the 1950's and 60's. New psychedelic drugs are discovered -> some people (e.g. Leary) claim it's a miracle cure for what ails you -> gets used extensively -> people have bad reaction -> gov't makes it illegal. Similar to what happened with opioids. Opioids are addictive, don't use them ever -> opioids aren't that addictive, give them to everyone -> Opioids are addictive, don't use them ever. I hope to live long enough to see another cycle.
- pmoriarty 7y ago"It's a repeat of what happened in the 1950's and 60's. New psychedelic drugs are discovered -> some people (e.g. Leary) claim it's a miracle cure for what ails you -> gets used extensively -> people have bad reaction -> gov't makes it illegal." There are some crucial aspects of what happened that are missing from your account. 1 - Not only did some people have bad reactions, but the media and politicians sensationalized the hell out those bad reactions, we're not seeing that now and the media attention has been extraordinarily positive.. so far. It could, of course, change on a dime if/when there's some juicy scandal that the media can whip people up in to a frenzy over. 2 - Psychedelics and cannabis were tied strongly in to the counterculture (including that new demonic music, Rock and Roll) of the time, which was a frightening bogeyman to politicians and mainstream culture. Mainstream culture has pretty much absorbed much of that counterculture since then. Rock and Roll is pretty blase, hippies are seen as quaint anachronisms, psychedelic/surreal art is commonplace and won't raise an eyebrow any longer. People have bigger things to worry about. 3 - Psychedelics and cannabis were tied strongly to the anti-war movement and various political issues that were threatening the status quo. There's hardly any anti-war movement to speak of any longer, and psychedelic users don't seem to be threatening the status quo except for wanting to get their drugs of choice legalized, and maybe "save the planet" by taking better care of the environment. It's hard to get people wound up in opposition to that any longer. Now, this could all change as psychedelics do have the potential to inspire art and music and maybe create a new counterculture, and to also inspire radical political action and seeking out of alternatives to the status quo, and I hope that does happen in some positive, constructive manner. And there could be a huge backlash against that once again, but there's not even a hint of it yet. Something else that's going on now is that there's a lot more education about safe use of psychedelics, the therapeutic/medical model and the shamanic/sacred approach seem to be taking off on a scale that wasn't there in the 50's and 60's. Ayahuasca tourism is huge, and MDMA-assisted and Psilocybin-assisted therapies are ramping up (with veterans of all people!) Talking about and getting help for mental health issues is also something that's much more widely accepted than it was in the 50's and 60's, when these things were pretty taboo. Psychedelic support and integration groups are also springing up all over the place. So people are much more likely to seek out help when they need it. That will hopefully have a positive effect to stem the flow of "acid casualties" this time around. There's also a mental health crisis, where traditional mental health treatments are widely recognized as having failed, and people are looking for alternatives that work. This is somewhat similar to the 60's and 70's, when alternative treatments were also fashionable, but it seems such alternatives are much more acceptable today. In addition to this, a lot of the people who were part of the youth culture and counterculture in the 60's are in positions of power now, and they're not as afraid of these substances as their parents were. We're definitely living in interesting times, and right now the future looks bright, though of course that could change if people continue to use these substances irresponsibly and the media manages to turn reports of bad experiences in to a circus.
- tayo42 7y ago> browsing Reddit, it's not hard to find bizarre stories of people triggering week, month, or even year long episodes of worsened depression, derealization, PTSD-like symptoms, or HPPD from psychedelic experimentation. I'm skeptical of this claim, every bad story seems to go along with some terrible decision making, "this was my first time doing lsd i was peaking hard and smoked a 1g blunt" or "i locked my self in my room so my parents wouldn't find me"
- pmoriarty 7y agoMany of the bad stories are of people mixing drugs with alcohol or with other non-psychedelic drugs like coke or speed.. that's almost always a really, really bad idea. Also a horrible idea is to go somewhere really hot (like a poorly ventilated dance club or concert in 100+ degree heat) and take a lot of Molly/Esctacy/MDMA (apparently most people don't even know that these are supposed to be the same thing, though what you actually get on the street is anyone's guess), dancing like crazy, then overheating as a result... and some people have died of this. Drinking too little water, or too much water without the proper amount of electrolytes while exerting yourself dancing on MDMA can also result in either dehydration or hyponatremia. Some people have died of this too. Finally, some of the worst ideas are to blindly try some new research chemicals without knowing what they are or what their long-term (or sometimes even short-term) effects are. Taking the classic psychedelics (LSD, psylocybin, mescaline, peyote, and properly identified psychedelic mushrooms) in a safe, quiet place, with people you like and trust and an experienced sitter is the optimally safe way to go. Do make sure to identify what you have, though. This is very, very important.