2 ms·
Category theory is fine but won't give you "anything new". I wasted a lot of time and money as plenty of big names were praising it (e.g. John Baez) so I follow
by moralestapia 7y ago
Category theory is fine but won't give you "anything new". I wasted a lot of time and money as plenty of big names were praising it (e.g. John Baez) so I followed them on a few conferences/talks. In the end, it's a nice theoretical framework to think about how to structure your code but that's it. If you do want to get involved (and, like me, are coming from a computational background) the book from Bartosz (i.e. the guy from the post) tells you enough to get a good overview of the thing; it's also available for free online.
A second recommendation, a bit odd maybe, do not waste your time trying to engage with that community as most people there are incredibly smug and toxic (but if you don't believe me feel free to try it, ymmv). They are now pushing this idea that they're 'opening' the field to everybody and would like as much people to jump on their bandwagon, but they are just trying to get some traction to keep leeching off grants, etc... they couldn't care less about you, I experienced this first-hand. You can learn most of these things on your own anyway, as it is usual with most mathy things.
I don't disagree with the premise of the post, when the time comes math will save your ass, for sure. Now, what works? As you mentioned linear algebra and some intermediate statistics would greatly improve your chances. I would drop some geometry as well, geometry has an inherent 'visual/spatial' feeling to it but try to learn it in such way that you become familiar of dealing with it in a completely abstract way. Regarding this, I have noticed a small surge in interest for clifford algebras, geometric algebras, etc... if you have the time pay attention to it, there are some greats talks about it on youtube and this one has an amazing community that I would definitely recommend to engage with.
Also interesting to read about, some other algebras that are defined mathematically and are at the foundation of CS, things like lambda calculus come to mind.
You don't have to become an expert on these fields to start seeing the benefits. Just build of the habit of reading about one or two topics per week, what they do, how they do it, and before you know a year has gone by and you will feel much more confident in your skills. Anything that requires more attention will naturally drag you to it.
Finally, this guy Robert Ghrist is amazing (really!) https://www.math.upenn.edu/~ghrist/ https://www.math.upenn.edu/~ghrist/, check him out as well, his talks and other content. He also wrote a book on applied topology (free online as well) which is amazing. Even if you don't understand anything about it, give it a quick skim to have an idea of all the incredible things math can you do for you that you could not have imagined existed!
- tobmlt 7y agoSeconded. Robert Ghrist’s Elementary Applied Topology is one of my favorite books. A real eye opener if you haven’t seen some of it before.
- bhewer 7y ago'Category theory is fine but won't give you "anything new"'. This is far from the truth and disregards a significant body of work in programming language theory (not to mention algebraic geometry and topology). Perhaps most famously, monads, which have been widely adopted in the Haskell and Scala communities, originated in the category theory literature. Eugenio Moggi famously described how monads could be used to structure the denotational semantics of a programming language. Monads are just the most obvious example of 'new' concepts which originate in the category theory literature and are practically realised by the study of categorical semantics of programming languages. A brief investigation of the literature will reveal a vast array of concepts such as initial algebras/final coalgebras (used to implement safe recursion schemes), adjunctions (giving rise to free constructions such as the infamous free monad), profunctor optics (bidirectional data accessors). This is just to give a few examples in PLT and does not even touch upon lesser-known constructions in type theory. ‘In the end, it's a nice theoretical framework to think about how to structure your code but that's it.’ This comes across as overly dismissive of the problem of ‘how to structure code’, which is in no way trivial. Formalising desirable properties of programs, and designing languages/constructs which restrict to programs exhibiting these desirable properties, is a general focus of programming language theory. ’A nice theoretical framework’ in which such problems can be formalised is very significant, and the comments that programming language theorists working on categorical semantics are “incredibly smug and toxic” and “are just trying to get some traction to keep leeching off grants” is especially insulting to many wonderful people working in this domain.