3 ms·
> Now, assuming the most generous interpretation of their 10% VAT proposal... which means a 10% VAT on things like rent, transportation, etc. CA has around 11.5
by AnthonyMouse 7y ago
> Now, assuming the most generous interpretation of their 10% VAT proposal... which means a 10% VAT on things like rent, transportation, etc. CA has around 11.5mil households with apx $40k/household of spending, which yields $460bil @ 10% => $46bil in additional tax revenue.
The median income in California is $75k, not $40k. On top of that, this is an alternative to existing assistance programs, so you either get to recover the money spent on those or you get to remove the people who continue to receive them from the population receiving the UBI. I'm not saying the numbers for this bill necessarily balance, but you're using the wrong ones.
> They would have to more than double the tax revenue for a state with already very high taxes.
Nominal tax rate with a UBI has to be discounted by the full amount of the UBI, because you're not paying it if you're getting it back. It obviously doesn't hurt you to pay $10,000 more in taxes if you're then receiving a $12,000 UBI.
This confuses the heck out of people because it means that a UBI costs "nothing" -- but that's how it works. It's purely redistributive. It doesn't cost anything on net, it only moves money around. At the individual level, it costs people above the median something, but still not the amount of the tax, only the difference between the UBI and the amount of the tax. The rest they get back.