3 ms·
point 1: Yes, except that I've had comments downvoted to 0 and then upvoted to 2... you shouldn't be penalized for an unfair downvote. Point 4 will eliminat
by rms 20y ago
point 1: Yes, except that I've had comments downvoted to 0 and then upvoted to 2... you shouldn't be penalized for an unfair downvote. Point 4 will eliminate some unfair downvotes. No one (except me, maybe) will admit to downvoting someone because of an ideological disagreement.
Point 2: OK, except it will sometimes be annoying.
Point 3: Yes, but it will be tricky to optimize this algorithm.
Point 4: This is the best suggestion to implement immediately.
- ralph 20y agoNo one (except me, maybe) will admit to downvoting someone because of an ideological disagreement. I vote up a comment if I strongly agree with it. Conversely, I vote down a comment if I strongly disagree with it. Those in between, which I don't feel strongly about, I leave. Isn't that what the down vote is intended for?