4 ms·
Politics require social skills, being smart is detrimental because it lets you see thru all the bullshit.
by rasz 7y ago
Politics require social skills, being smart is detrimental because it lets you see thru all the bullshit.
- rimliu 7y agoHow is that detrimental in politics?
- unlinked_dll 7y agoIf you see the bullshit but don't deal with it, that doesn't make you smart. It makes you very, very stupid.
- AstralStorm 7y agoDealing with politics in an advantageous way takes serious time and practice. You might be well behind the curve vs professionals.
- ikeyany 7y agoIf you were smart, wouldn't you know how to optimally deal with bullshit?
- heavenlyblue 7y agoThis takes a whole different set of skills against e.g being good at programming. For example, how do you react to inherently unfair situations, someone taking advantage of someone else? If you start picking on people good politicians will quickly “plausibility deniability” you out of the equation. It’s much easier to accept (with a bit of anger) that you made a mistake in your program that bring defaced due to your “judgement being clouded by anger”. You may be smart enough to even understand what you have to do, but it will take practice to do it well even if you understand it conceptually.
- ikeyany 7y agoJust because you're a good programmer doesn't mean you're smart.
- redisman 7y agoThere are many different heuristics for what is "optimal". To many it is to be left alone to work on things they find interesting.
- lotsofpulp 7y agoPeople who succeed at politics are able to do so because they can see through the bullshit, but also because they can pretend it’s not bullshit. Politics is war without the violence. You need you be able to signal to potential allies what you’re willing to give and take with plausible deniability. Many smart, principled people aren’t able to sufficiently lie to themselves or feel comfortable using ambiguous terms and/or outright lying, and that hampers their ability to covertly send and receive signals to others, so others who are successful at politics would do well to stay away from them. You have to compromise in order to get things done, but it doesn’t behoove you to lay out all of your cards for everyone to see.
- Data_Junkie 7y agoThe Elephant in the room. When it's all politics, as it is in most of modern society, success really has much more to do with the ability to lie and deceive than most are comfortable admitting. There in lies the entire problem, and the solution is inchomphesible to polititions who owe their entire self worth to their abilities to decieve.
- mamon 7y agoSmart, nerdy people tend to spend a lot of time alone with books/computers/hobbies, so they simply do not spend enough time with other people to properly develop their social skills.
- Data_Junkie 7y agoThat is completely off track.