5 ms·
>What exactly worries you about mass hysteria and panic? Why would that be worse than what is likely to happen as Covid-19 spreads outside of China? Because th
by simonh 7y ago
>What exactly worries you about mass hysteria and panic? Why would that be worse than what is likely to happen as Covid-19 spreads outside of China?
Because then in addition to the damage caused by the outbreak, we will also have the additional often useless and counterproductive damage caused by hysteria and panic.
- af0GRLoH 7y agoThat is just understood as the hypothesis and the framing of the question. What is the nature of the useless and counterproductive damage caused by hysteria and panic? (I could speculate that it changes economic flows that upsets long term planning and so on, but I would like to hear the opinion of experts on the matter anyway).
- marcinzm 7y ago>What is the nature of the useless and counterproductive damage caused by hysteria and panic? Of the top of my head. Hoarding of supplies causing shortages and harming people who actually need them right now. Progressing to health professionals lacking supplies (masks, etc.) due to shortages (and diverting of dedicated supplies). Unnecessary ER visits which stress the health system thus making it less able to react to an actual problem (as health professionals are tired and burned out). Stress and unnecessary interventions/ER visits increasing people's risk and exposure to existing diseases. edit: That's not counting real panic which involves mobs with metaphorical pitchforks and the military in streets enforcing some semblance of order (with bullets).
- fauigerzigerk 7y agoRight, but stressing the importance of avoiding "hysteria and panic" is also extremely popular with authoritarian regimes justifying censorship and trying to cover up their own incompetence. There was a window of opportunity during which this virus could have been contained. The Chinese dictatorship has squandered it in the name of "avoiding panic and hysteria". Panic and hysteria should be avoided by being transparent, not by playing down the dangers or praising the efforts of an intransparent self-serving regime as the WHO has done from very early on.
- simonh 7y ago'But' what? Would you characterise the OP as avoiding being transparent, or playing down the dangers? Is anyone here acting like an authoritarian regime, or is anyone here saying anything contrarian to your point?
- fauigerzigerk 7y ago>Would you characterise the OP as avoiding being transparent, or playing down the dangers? Yes, I would indeed. gzer0's original wording, which has now been edited out (without comment), was: "Stay vigilant, stay careful, but most importantly, do not spread mass hysteria and panic" Now the wording was changed to: "Stay vigilant, stay careful, but most importantly, do not spread false information." I welcome the change, because saying that the most important thing in the face of danger is to avoid panic and hysteria is wrong and characteristic of authoritarian language.
- tomp 7y agoThe West has also squandered its opportunity in the name of “non-discrimination” and “political correctness”. The right (with hindsight) response would have been to ban all flights / arrivals from China / Asia, but I guess that’s wrong-speak in the age of “open borders” as the only non-Nazi political option.
- fauigerzigerk 7y agoI would suggest that being in favour of open borders for some purposes whilst closing borders in completely different circumstances for completely different reasons should be permissible even in our very polarised political climate.
- danielg6 7y agoWhat does non-discrimination and political correctness have to do with the white Americans that were evacuated from Wuhan lmao? And the ones that returned from China in general? Or for that matter, American citizens in general? Also, the U.S. has banned flights to/from certain countries during certain times.