5 ms·
The Dutch government is also often terrible at managing IT projects. It seems an industry has evolved to game the public procurement rules required by the EU. T
by mcv 7y ago
The Dutch government is also often terrible at managing IT projects. It seems an industry has evolved to game the public procurement rules required by the EU. Those companies just leech money for never-ending IT projects that tend to be over budget, over time, and working poorly.
- tomatocracy 7y agoI think it's more that one of the consequences of painful public procurement processes is that they incentivise public officials to avoid procurement as much as possible. This leads to larger/maximalist projects being specified and a proliferation of "framework agreements" under which small projects are undertaken, both of which seem to benefit the large incumbents disproportionately.
- jeltz 7y agoHaving worked at a company in public procurement I would say that matches my experience. I would say we were relatively honest compared to some of our competitors, but there were almost no incentives for us developers to do a good job other than our personal morals and everyone including us were more or less gaming the system. I hated working there because I felt like a parasite just making the world worse. The in-hosue IT of our customer would probably have done a better job if they had just been allowed to hire some guys instead of having to go through an easily gameable procurement procedure. Not because they would have been more competent, but because they would have not have had perverse incentives.
- j7ake 7y agoThis story is fascinating, do you know where I can read more about public procurement?
- iudqnolq 7y agoFor a semi-fictional humorous take on American military procurement watch the movie The Pentagon Wars
- MrMorden 7y agoIs that one more accurate than "Joint Session" (Veep S4E1)?
- iudqnolq 7y agoNever saw that Veep episode. It's based on a book with the same title by a whistleblower, and my understanding is they dramatize the specifics but the fundamentals gist is true if a little more complicated. For example, in the movie the main character thinks for a while and then decides to use the military rules against his opponents so he asks his secretary to get him the rulebook and figures out a rule with a loophole. I think in reality he used a generally similar loophole to get the word out in combination with a lot of other strategies, but he didn't figure it out from staring at "the rulebook" for a few hours one night.
- minusf 7y agoat least the Dutch sites work. try a post communist country gov site and you'll start appreciating it right away.
- mcv 7y agoI don't doubt there are countries that are worse at it, but "the Dutch sites work" is not always true, or sometimes true for questionable definitions of "work". I mean, we've got this nice secure login system for government sites: DigiD, which works fine. So you need that to submit your taxes. A few years ago, it turned out you needed any valid DigiD to submit your taxes, not necessarily your own. There are tons of other sites that cost many millions, and resulted in an atrocious user experience. And some projects simply failed after going way over budget.
- Avamander 7y agoI wouldn't really call DigiD secure, it doesn't seem to be open-source. Plus, rolling some own protocol/crypto instead of using PKI, that has immense effort behind it to keep secure, is not a good thing. Estonia has a similar solution, but "Smart-ID" was created after PKI was fully rolled out, it's terrible compared to that. Centralized, unverifiable, stores secrets insecurely, does some cryptographic bullshit. The two solutions somehow seem very related.
- mcv 7y agoPossibly. I'm giving it the benefit of the doubt because I haven't heard of any problems with DigiD itself, but you could certainly question whether that benefit is deserved here. But my point is that even if DigiD is secure, that's still not going to help you when the tax service uses it incorrectly.
- skeletal88 7y agoCan you explain why Smart-ID is bad? It is terrible compared to what, PKI, our ID card, the mobile-id system? What kind of bullshit does it do? I haven't heard any such criticism about that system before, so it would be interesting to hear. I've been using it for years, it's easy to use and there haven't been any security problems with it. The company that developed it is trying to export it to other countries as well.
- mattrp 7y agos/Dutch/all/g
- ptsneves 7y agoIn Portugal there is this thing called viactt which is a crappy reinvention of email. The issue is that it is mandated that official communications with the state be done like through it. It emulates the conventional mail so much that the "letter" contains a picture of the stamps. If you are a company it is the official way of communication. It was done as part of a modernization initiative but now everybody just hates it due to its general uselessness and rare usage.