4 ms·
More inexcusable is the aesthetic choice to do this now, when you can afford to have decent graphics and let players do whatever they want but designers often i
by tialaramex 7y ago
More inexcusable is the aesthetic choice to do this now, when you can afford to have decent graphics and let players do whatever they want but designers often inexplicably decide to curate the experience to the point where you might as well just watch somebody else's play.
I wouldn't have built Myst because to me it seems pointless, why not just make a movie about this? Or a picture book? But clearly lots of people enjoyed it. Still, back then I could safely assume anything that looked that good had nothing behind the facade, today it's harder to guess.
It reminds me of a phenomenon which is broadly disliked in tabletop Role Playing. Some GMs like to plot out everything in great detail which necessarily means you can't go off piste, they need you to go into the tunnels under the castle with the torch because they've worked out exactly what will happen when you do. If their players try to instead simply leave the castle because it's boring, or divert a river into the tunnels and flood them to drive anything down there out the GM will either be angry and demand the players reconsider or will try to railroad the players into proceeding with the plan as they envisioned. Either way this is an unsatisfying experience for everybody.
- jfengel 7y agoThere wasn't enough story for a movie. It was pretty enough to be a picture book, but how big is the market for picture books? It was a puzzle game. The puzzles were pretty basic, but the market for basic puzzle games is significant. Especially if the puzzle is also attractive enough that the next batch of visuals feels like a decent reward for having solved the puzzle. Such a game won't attract people who want more interaction from their games -- though you do have to remember that at the time even a game like Doom was a huge advance in interactivity. Myst was relaxing rather than exciting, almost the way a game of solitaire or a crossword puzzle is.