4 ms·
Why does the BBC want to 'kill' Netflix? Why isn't it enough to provide their own service? Why do they want to 'kill' off independent competitors?
by chrisseaton 7y ago
Why does the BBC want to 'kill' Netflix? Why isn't it enough to provide their own service? Why do they want to 'kill' off independent competitors?
- phire 7y agoSensationalist headlines; "Netflix-killer" brings the clicks. This all happened years before Netflix even launched in the UK and was in development in parallel with the US version of on-demand streaming. But given how much of a lead the BBC streaming service had, it probably would have hampered Netflix's efforts to launch in the UK.
- hogFeast 7y agoThey didn't have a lead. Channel 4 was first by a considerable margin. I remember using 4OD back in 2006/07, it was great. Iirc, IPlayer existed but it was very limited in what it showed. It took them years to move off a 7-day window (as the article explains, there was massive hostility to streaming within the BBC). 4OD had rights issues but, iirc, they made full series available from day one. ITV was shit though (and still is)...although that is partly a function of the weird corporate structure. Also, Project Kangaroo was far more complicated than the article says. By the time that the parties had stopped arguing and BBC had got over their hostility to streaming, Netflix was already going and paying the BBC for stuff that was going to be in Kangaroo. The reason this is coming out now is the BBC lobbyists are going on the attack but this would have changed nothing. In fact, all it would have meant is that you pay for more streaming services, and one of them would be very shit largely consisting of old episodes of Dad's Army...you can already get the best parts of the back catalogue on Netflix (the BBC should be offering this to licence-payers for free...but this wasn't what Kangaroo was either, it was a money spinner so the Islington boys could fleece licence-payers a second time...Netflix helps them, it isn't competition).
- Mindwipe 7y ago> Channel 4 was first by a considerable margin. I remember using 4OD back in 2006/07, it was great. Channel 4 launched about six weeks before iPlayer in the end, but only because the BBC launch was held up by the regulator. It was ready (ish) about six months earlier. 4OD had the seven day window at launch, it didn't launch any box sets until about 2009, and it had lots of rights issues too. Indeed, they forgot to rights clear any of the advertising and had to blank all the commercial breaks with dead air on the online simulcast for the first week... I do agree that Kangaroo was a bit more complex than portrayed here, but your statement that the BBC are "fleecing" the public by trying to commercially fund the release of older material that is virtually never fully BBC owned and requires the payment of hefty royalties is false.
- hogFeast 7y agoRight, and what were 4OD's views? From what I remember, far fewer people used IPlayer until they moved to 30-day...which was 2014-ish. And your timeline isn't correct, as said I remember using it in 2007 which was before IPlayer launched (you can actually verify this for yourself if you Google, IPlayer launched Christmas Day 07...4OD launched over a year earlier). And 4OD opened back catalogue on launch. That is just factually incorrect too (again, if you deigned to do some Googling you could find this out for yourself). I also didn't say that was the fleece. Kangaroo was the fleece. But the fleece is also selling stuff to Netflix that people have already paid for...saying this is "false" is odd (do you work on the BBC's "fact-checking" service by any chance? They have a habit of not understanding the difference between true and false). Royalties make no difference, that is just economically incontinent...if I develop an oil field and I pay $10/barrel in royalties, it doesn't matter because I am making $50/barrel, and that is tied to my revenue. It makes zero difference. If royalties are prohibitive, don't develop it. ...amazing that you managed to compose a post that was almost entirely fiction but stated with utter authority. Why do you think you did this?
- throwGuardian 7y agoBecause BBC (and by proxy the ones that control it) want to have the last word on news and culture. What used to be a center left organization is now teeming with many in the far left, blatantly allied with the labor party [1]. Turning state funded media into a partisan propaganda agency typically doesn't end well in a democracy. [1]: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Criticism_of_the_BBC https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Criticism_of_the_BBC
- rayiner 7y ago> Turning state funded media into a partisan propaganda agency typically doesn't end well in a democracy. Some would say that’s the inevitable result of state funded media.
- pjc50 7y agoI think you missed the last decade of conservative government, their influence, and the persistent platforming of the extreme right by BBCQT.
- throwGuardian 7y ago> persistent platforming of .. First off, a journalist/news channel doesn't/shouldn't only hear from voices that affirm biases, especially state funded ones - in this case, it's healthy for the BBC to hear opposing views taken by their editorial staff. Secondly, de-platforming shouldn't be there normal. Your phrasing is indicative of a trend towards decimation of speech in western civilization. Your labels of "extreme right" are unsubstantiated and expectations of default deplatforming of anything right of "far left", dangerous to discourse. For the unfamiliar, here [1] is a recent example of the alleged "platforming" done by BBC QT as alleged by the op. These days, it's gotten all too common to label opposing opinions with extremely inaccurate strawman-able distasteful labels, just to censor them. [1]: https://youtu.be/re7K2SGMmHU https://youtu.be/re7K2SGMmHU
- sideshowb 7y agoCitation does not support argument, indeed contains many instances of right as well as left wing bias.