3 ms·
That's not quite right. Rigor means not hand-waving about things that a skeptic might doubt, not skipping corner cases, etc. Formal means doing things like a
by lonelappde 7y ago
That's not quite right.
Rigor means not hand-waving about things that a skeptic might doubt, not skipping corner cases, etc.
Formal means doing things like a computer -- strictly symbolic analysis that doesn't claim to do the impossible task accurately map back to our informal ideas of what things mean.
Formality is across a chasm -- it's the most accurate kind of math we can do, but it can't be trusted to say that a formal proof about say complex numbers actually applies to what you are thinking about when you day "complex numbers".
As is said, "It is impossible to pass from the informal by purely formal means."
Here's a better explanation:
https://www.quora.com/What-is-difference-between-rigorous-and-formal-mathematics https://www.quora.com/What-is-difference-between-rigorous-an...
- prox 7y agoThank you, that clears it up further. I recently saw the movie “the man who knew infinity” and so it got me thinking about this meta questions.
- kragen 7y agoThis is in accordance with my understanding, but since you seem to think I was saying something different, I think your expression of it is clearer than mine was.