3 ms·
Ah, as a Korean who experienced all of this bullshit (in middle/high school), I have a few additional points I want to make: - Standardized test scores aren't
by lasagnaphil 7y ago
Ah, as a Korean who experienced all of this bullshit (in middle/high school), I have a few additional points I want to make:
- Standardized test scores aren't either the culprit or the panacea for the privatization of education. No matter what the process of selecting students is, there will always be cram schools willing to exploit that process to the maximum degree. Korea in fact has another way to enter college without that single exam (called _susi_, it's basically your GPA + portfolio + cover letter), which is less well known than the default route (called _jungsi_). And guess what, there are a shit-ton of crams schools for that too. There are cram schools solely for entering International Math/Physics Olympiads, because they are one of the several ways to enter Medical School, which are the hardest type of colleges you can try in Korea. There are cram schools for art college examimations, cram schools for your high school GPA, cram schools for entering science/writing contests (so you can lengthen your portfolio), cram schools for just anything you can imagine related to college admissions.
- It's becoming more and more of a lie in Korea that simply entering a good university will automatically land you a good job, especially in the non-STEM sectors. Humanities students in top universities are now scrambling to get good GPAs, TOEFL scores, and any activities that would lengthen their portfolio, simply because jobs are very scarce even for them. A lot of them are preparing for government administration jobs which would give them good job security. And guess what, those jobs are also determined by a single test, how tragic! Same goes for law schools, medical universities, etc... As a Korean, you'll almost never leave the perpetual requirement of nonsensical tests and competitions for quite some time even after high school, it's pretty harrowing.
- onceUponADime 7y agoSo the solution for this dilema would be to take more applicants into a job first and then weed out by measurable quality/output ?
- TuringNYC 7y agoFirstly - I’m sorry to hear about this experience and don’t want to undermine the pain here. I’ll note that some of the schools I graduated from in the US (NYC) are moving from exams to a “holistic” system of entrance, and my feeling is that is even worse in many cases. In the holistic system: - you don’t know what the criteria is - friendships and contacts matter - you can’t study to fully strengthen your chances - you don’t get feedback on what you are doing wrong - in the extreme cases is very open to bias and corruption (eg many “holistic” systems actively filter out Asian candidates)