2 ms·
> And while it's easy to dismiss policy makers as doing it wrong, it's important to understand that they're not. Except when they are, which is more often than
by AnthonyMouse 7y ago
> And while it's easy to dismiss policy makers as doing it wrong, it's important to understand that they're not.
Except when they are, which is more often than not.
Creating good policies around anything is hard. It has taken centuries to fine tune the laws for things like physical theft and contracts and acts of violence, and even then examples of unjust outcomes are easy to find.
Using a process that takes a decade to modify rules for a system that changes every year is pretty hopeless. The rules are already stale by the time they're enacted and any mistake takes generations to fix.
More to the point, most of the "tech problems" are not novel. Essentially 100% of the legitimate "bad stuff" that the CFAA prohibits was already illegal under existing laws that have nothing specifically to do with computers. But because of the way it was drafted, it's so broad and ambiguous and draconian that it also imposes severe penalties on a wide variety of largely innocuous behavior. And so it is with the unintended consequences from DMCA anti-circumvention, the unintended consequences from SESTA, on and on.
Doing this well is hard. Most attempts have not succeeded. And doing it wrong is worse than not doing it at all. It's not as if the only alternative to SESTA was for sex trafficking to be legal -- the alternative would have just been the status quo ante. Which was better than SESTA.