4 ms·
No, you are not punctual and respectful. You are the result of the de-humanizing alienation of people's natural time and daily cycles, that went full strong in
by coldtea 7y ago
No, you are not punctual and respectful.
You are the result of the de-humanizing alienation of people's natural time and daily cycles, that went full strong in the 18th and 19th century to train factory workers and other replaceable cogs to work "on time", and metastasised to all aspects of modern life...
>And I don’t care if I sound old-fashioned, because actually it’s nothing to do with ‘fashion’ or ‘generation’. It’s got everything to do with basic good manners and respect for other people.
Actually it very has much to do with both fashion and generation. It's not some innate aspect of human society, it was introduced (read: forced upon people) with the advent of the personal watch, factory shifts, mechanized production, etc. In fact, even up to today, outside of urban communities, the sense of pressure to be "on time" is much less present, as is in general (even in urban ares) in many societies (think of the idea of the more laid-back Southerners for example).
As uberman above notes, "Etiquette surrounding meeting start and end times turns out to be are very culturally subjective.".
If anything, more of humanity (Asia, Africa, Latin America, Mediterranean, Middle East, etc) is less against being punctual than in favor of it. So you [well, people with the author's mindset] are also racist, imposing your provincial protestant values [whether yours or adopted from migrating to some such place] upon the whole world.
- andrewzah 7y ago> If anything, more of humanity (Asia, Africa, Latin America, Mediterranean, Middle East, etc) is less against being punctual than in favor of it. [Citation Needed] This wasn’t exactly the case in Japan and S. Korea in my experience. Whether or not being late is a slight depends on the culture and the person, too.
- coldtea 7y ago>This wasn’t exactly the case in Japan and S. Korea in my experience. That's partly because Japan and South Korea were forcibly and heavily westernized and heavily stressed to achieve industrial success at all costs, after (different) traumatic war, occupation and colonization events. It's not however the typical characteristic of Asian culture (with spans 3 billion more people than South Korea/Japan), nor the traditional one... See also "Karoshi" et al...
- pnako 7y agoJapan was not colonized by the West. But it was itself a colonial power.
- coldtea 7y agoI didn't say it was. I said the two countries changed "after (different) traumatic war, occupation and colonization events". Japan was traumatized by its encounter with westerners, by being forced to open its borders for commerce (through force), and later by WWII defeat and subsequent nuclear obliteration of two of its cities, and occupation and supervision by the allies (or, well, the GIs).\ For South Korea, ironically, it was Japan itself who at some point was the colonizer and occupation force...
- SturgeonsLaw 7y agoThey are probably the two most highly strung societies in Asia. Outside of those examples, particularly in the more equatorial tropical regions, punctuality gets a whole lot looser.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- rognjen 7y agoSounds like a nerve has been struck to be honest.
- coldtea 7y agoYes, racist imposition of cultural norms to the world at large tends to strike some nerves...
- shijie 7y agoInvoking racism on someone who disagrees with you isn’t usually a hallmark of the intellectually honest.
- coldtea 7y agoStrawman arguments aren't "usually a hallmark of the intellectually honest" either. I didn't randomly invoke racism. I made an argument which you omit here: that the concept of punctuality is cultural and relative, and that the author's blanket "You Are Rude and Selfish" is thus racist. The same exact accusation has been used historically to create the "lazy" / "laid-back" black, middle eastern, latino, african, etc stereotype...
- slowmovintarget 7y agoCulture is not race. Imposing one's cultural norms on people of other cultures, while distasteful, is not racist, it is merely insensitive. Feeling offended doesn't mean racism is afoot.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- rognjen 7y agoIf you want to coordinate 10 people being at the same place at it's racist to expect everyone to be on time? Surely you see how that's a laughable argument.
- 7y ago
- bassman9000 7y agoI guess you never meet for work...
- pensatoio 7y agoDespite your best intentions, I think you're being very narrow minded by focusing on largely irrelevant (in this context) history and culture. The author of this article is right to point out that you're wasting everyone's time by not showing up on time, not due to an emergency, but due to your own laziness.
- ramblerman 7y agoI agree with everything you said, up until you had to play the race card. Someone expressing their cultural beliefs is not racist. Cultures can clash, we have differences, that in itself is not racist. This kind of discussion and disagreement is healthy, and again not racist. We (humans) have more backbone than that. If anything this over sensitivity is also a 'western' product of the last 20 odd years or so.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]