7 ms·
I have a very simple solution to this problem. It frequently evokes an instinctual negative reaction, for understandable reasons, but I truly believe it would b
by Wowfunhappy 7y ago
I have a very simple solution to this problem. It frequently evokes an instinctual negative reaction, for understandable reasons, but I truly believe it would be both equitable and effective. Ready?
You want your company to be 50% women? Tell your teams that at least 50% of their hires must be women. That's it.
To me, formalizing the quota but keeping the overall hiring process looser makes a lot more sense than the other way around. A quota is dead easy, and a formal process is hard for all of the reasons discussed.
A quota is not "hiring people just because they're female/black/gay/etc"—it's a way to make us more effective by preventing us from overlooking good people. If we're naturally inclined to skip people who are black, then we need a process to counterbalance our natural tendencies. And of course, recognizing and taking advantage of an undervalued resource is good for business.
If there are legal issues with a quota (I'm legitimately not sure whether there are), then the law ought to be changed.
---
50% women may be the wrong number because of the demographics of computer science majors or what have you. It was just an example. Choose a number in good faith that you believe represents the potential population of good hires.
One simple solution might be to have your quota match the demographics of your job applicants. But this decision bares more thought than I'm qualified to provide.
- drunkpotato 7y agoI’ve proposed this as well and it went over like a lead balloon. As did the very idea that more diversity would be good for the team. Ah well.
- Wowfunhappy 7y ago> As did the very idea that more diversity would be good for the team. So, while I wholeheartedly agree that diversity inherently benefits teams and businesses (different experiences will lead to new and different approaches), it's just not a very convincing argument, because it feels "mushy". Here's one that I think is better: If it's true that e.g. women have a harder time getting engineering jobs due to unconscious bias (and I'd posit that this is clearly the case), then that means female engineers are, as a group, undervalued. You should be able to hire a better female engineer for the same amount of money. Harsh? Sure. But that's beside the point.
- missosoup 7y ago> If it's true that e.g. women have a harder time getting engineering jobs due to unconscious bias Cite this. For the tech sector, in developed nations, this is nonsense.
- BubRoss 7y agoIt should go over like a lead balloon since it is literally illegal discrimination.
- drunkpotato 7y agoPlease explain? I am not aware of such a law and have never encountered this response before.
- polishdude20 7y ago"If we're naturally inclined to skip people who are black.." The evidence for that is dubious
- mgsouth 7y agoI see some people are reacting negatively to what you're saying. DVs are terrible as a dialog. And I, too, agree the comment leaves kind of a bad taste, but I think because it baldly points out some unpleasant things. I only see these categories of downvotes: 1. I hit the wrong button :) 2. I'm a bigoted member of a majority, and am downvoting because I think minorities should be oppressed. 3. I don't think any questions of race/gender/etc. should ever be considered in a workplace, and and downvoting because I dislike the whole idea. 4. What I suspect is actually happening: Like (3) I think everyone should be considered on their own merits, and you can look at company-wide stats to see if bias is occurring. Its good for the company to act against it in sum, but acting on the basis of race/gender/etc. on an individual basis is shocking and unfair. The problem with (4) is that you're trying to have some kind of emergent effect that magically appears. It's a goal without being a goal. Worse, its a global goal you want to be actively worked against locally. Developers love to complain about clueless management that doesn't know what it wants. Guess what folks, it's a common trait. Our other favorite trope is to figure out a technical fix for a people problem. And the problem with that is of course a tech fix only takes care of specific situations and not the underlying problem. For example, as a tech fix we might decide that all interviews are done in a pitch-black room with vocoder voice synthesizers. Great, no question of race/gender/etc. Except, of course, for selection bias in our candidates. And even after they are hired there's biased reactions (unequal success for equal quality). People just naturally favor familiar attributes, even if those attributes don't contribute to a correct outcome. So to be consistent, there are really only three choices: a) don't care, let the chips fall where they may; b) have an actual goal to equally represent everyone; c) encourage playing nice, and hope the results aren't too far off. What actually happens, of course, is d) encourage playing nice, hope the results aren't too far off, then someone actually looks at the results and complains, so flail around trying to avoid doing anything too unpleasant to fix it.
- missosoup 7y ago> If there are legal issues with a quota (I'm legitimately not sure whether there are), then the law ought to be changed. That would be quite literally destroying the anti-discrimination laws which safeguard the exact thing that you think you're arguing in favour of. Quotas implemented the way you describe are the antithesis of equal opportunity. That 'instinctual negative reaction' you come across is people seeing the complete logical reversal going on in your claim.
- Wowfunhappy 7y agoI don't think we need to have the same rules for well-represented and underrepresented groups. A reasonable person is fully capable of determining which is which. "Reverse racism" is not a real phenomenon in 99% of cases.
- BubRoss 7y agoYou are making decisions based on arbitrary labels and demographics, not on the person. It is the definition of descrimination. Not only that, but it's blatantly hypocritical since you don't spend your money based on the demographics of a company, you spend it based on performance.
- joshuamorton 7y agoIt's discrimination, yes, but in what sense is a quota bigotry?
- tomp 7y agoIt can result in hiring of person B instead of more capable person A, just because person B satisfies some arbitrary immutable characteristics (skin color, sex, etc.) and person A does not. Texbook discrimination.
- joshuamorton 7y agoGP has since edited their post, it originally used the word "bigotry" where it now says "discrimination". Edit: This leads to a much more interesting line of discussion that can be summed up as "discrimination (and similarly bias) isn't always bad". They're useful tools and we should be careful about practicing them, but the idea that because discrimination is sometimes bad it is always bad doesn't follow. (or an alternative way of looking at this is that discrimination often includes the qualifier "unjust". Bias in favor of some group in the pursuit of greater justice therefore isn't discrimination).
- belorn 7y agoAs a social experiment, I would like to see a town/province/state attempt to ban gender segregation in the work place by imposing quotas on all professions, especially those where the government itself is the employer. If you want a government contract in that town, the company must have a minimum of 40% men and 40% women for every role of employee. I do not know what the costs, efficiency and employee happiness would be, but it would make for an amazing social experiment. Having 40% of the garbage men, sewer workers and construction workers being women, and 40% of the teachers, nurses, and social workers being men would make for a very different society than what we have today. There would be a lot of people trying to cheat the system in order to keep the work place gender segregated, but I wonder if that is a local maximum of happiness rather than a global one. Such study could shine some light and give us some final answers if quotas is a good idea or not.
- Wowfunhappy 7y agoJust to be clear, this is why I suggested normal companies not trying to reform society should base their quota on what they "believe represents the potential population of good hires", possibly based for example on their applicant pool. If only 10% of all engineers are women as of 2020, you need not mandate they they comprise at least 40% of your engineering team. (While there's a separate discussion to be had about why so few women choose to be engineers, that's not the company's problem to solve.)
- perl4ever 7y ago"If only 10% of all engineers are women as of 2020, you need not mandate they they comprise at least 40% of your engineering team" There's no logical reason why "10% of engineers are women" implies "10% of every engineering team should be women" instead of, for example, "10% of engineering teams should be all women". A number of teams could be 40% women even if the average were 10%, and there's also no reason why excess men have to be engineers just because they were educated as such. That's a thing that happens anyway, just like people without CS degrees go into programming.
- SomewhatLikely 7y agoI don't remember the source but I've heard anecdotes of women at companies with strong diversity pushes feeling that they get taken even less seriously because others assume they're "just a diversity hire". A lot more needs to be changed culturally than that single hire/no hire decision. An employee's peers and superiors are constantly making decisions that will impact that employee's career trajectory and each decision may only have a small even unconscious bias but cumulatively become extremely impactful. Between employee A and B, maybe A gets slightly more impactful project assignments, gets taken slightly more seriously, gets told more details about the goals of senior management, is given a bit more of a break when they miss deadlines, is mentored a little better by peers etc. If B is losing these little coin tosses even 10% more of the time, the effects add up. For some minorities the same process has been occurring their whole life and plays a big role in why the diversity is so low already at the career entry stage to begin with.