11 ms·
I've mentioned this before. I have a portfolio that consists of six figures LoC of code, across dozens of open-source repos; most of which I am the 100% sole a
by ChrisMarshallNY 7y ago
I've mentioned this before.
I have a portfolio that consists of six figures LoC of code, across dozens of open-source repos; most of which I am the 100% sole author.
I've written a fairly large open-source system that is rapidly becoming the world standard for a specific (rather small) demographic. It deliberately uses old and rather primitive technology (which is a big reason for it becoming a standard).
I've written hundreds and hundreds (probably thousands) of pages of documentation and Web site entries, designed Web sites, and helped hundreds of people and organizations to develop online presence (all for free). I've run instructional courses on a number of different topics.
I speak Swift without an accent. I can write ship-ready applications for every Apple operating system. I've been writing shipping software for over thirty years.
I'm good with device control. I've written embedded operating systems (long ago -different beast from today's).
And, of course, I can PROVE it. It's all out there.
And no one bothers to look at my portfolio when I've been contacted to apply for engineering positions. I usually send a couple of links to repos and/or blog entries that apply directly to the position. My portfolio leaves absolutely no question at all about what I can and can't do, technically.
I once even had someone insinuate that I had somehow faked my portfolio. I'm not exactly sure how they thought I did it. Maybe I hired an Indian shop to write tens of thousands of lines of code, hundreds of blog entries, design multiple Web sites, and hack GitHub and BitBucket to fake a decade of commit history.
At least, that was the reason they gave for ignoring the links I sent, and instead, giving a binary tree "Draw Spunky" test (I don't do well on them; never have, never will. I spend exactly 0.0 hours on HackerRank, practicing).
I stopped trying to look for work. I don't need it, and I was getting tired of the grind.
I just set up my own gig, where I do the stuff I want to do. Maybe someone will want to work with me in the future; maybe not.
I don't really care, and I'm quite happy.
- jimthrow 7y agoWhen you get rejected, it’s not about you. There’s just too many high quality candidates and too few positions. It’s just the inevitable outcome of a vast oversupply of talent
- ChrisMarshallNY 7y agoI'm not so sure about that. The lobbying for more H1Bs seems to indicate otherwise. I am quite aware that most positions are for folks that don't have my level of expertise. I just love designing and writing software; especially software that connects to devices. I'll do it; whether or not anyone pays me.
- achievingApathy 7y agoNo one wants to buy the cow when they get the milk for free. :)
- ChrisMarshallNY 7y agoAs long as they are happy with MIT open-source, on my terms, no big deal. They are welcome to knock themselves out. If they want to own it, though, and have more of a say in what it does, that's another story.
- jimthrow 7y agoWell an H1b is basically like an indentured servant that works for a fraction of the cost and much longer hours. Some Companies want low cost labor.
- achievingApathy 7y agoBut then collectively as a labor force, where do we go from here? We can't all dumb ourselves down - or won't, and it seems to me that people understand what it is we do less and less.
- zimpenfish 7y ago> There’s just too many high quality candidates and too few positions. That would be believable if the same positions weren't being advertised for a year or more[1]; e.g. I've had one position[2] sent to me at least 5 times in the last year by different recruiters. [1] In London, at least. [2] Interesting work and a job I'd want but unfortunately the corporate culture is 100% no-go for me.
- perl4ever 7y ago"I just set up my own gig, where I do the stuff I want to do." I think maybe this is the unspoken issue with interviews - if a candidate was any good, they wouldn't need a job at all! So it's a given that all the people who apply are no good - the interviewer just needs to find the reason.
- tonyedgecombe 7y agoI suspect there is an element of truth in that. After all the people who are most likely to apply are those who are persistent but have been rejected by previous interviewers.
- perl4ever 7y agoBy not needing a job, I mean being your own boss, not just already having a job.
- tonyedgecombe 7y agoI see. I'm not sure I agree though. I haven't had a job for 22 years although I think that says more about my lack of ability to be a good employee than anything else.
- dahart 7y ago> no one bothers to look at my portfolio [...] I usually send a couple of links [...] My portfolio leaves absolutely no question at all about what I can and can't do, technically. I hear this a lot from software engineers, but it might be worth thinking about the underlying expectation that anyone should spend time poking through repos on the internet, why they would, and how hard it might be to standardize a hiring process that compares you to other candidates. Contrast your own opinion of HackerRank with the hope that hiring managers, who perhaps often don’t have the time, interest, or even ability to read someone’s portfolio to determine the quality of the code. As someone who’s done a lot of hiring, I often glance at an online portfolio briefly, but I find it to be a low-quality signal for whether I will want to hire the person, and even for the technical ability. If I don’t know you, I can’t tell from your online portfolio whether you’re the sole author and/or how much you’ve contributed to a project. I can’t easily tell if you get a lot of your code from StackOverflow, or write it yourself. I can’t tell what motivates you, whether you love programming or you are hoping for a high salary. While high technical ability is a requirement for someone I hire, it’s not actually the primary requirement. What I need to know is how adaptable people are, how well they’ll work in a team, how quick they are on their feet, whether they’re friendly under pressure, a whole bunch of things that you can’t learn from a github account. Communication, attitude, curiosity, optimism, and cooperativeness are incredibly important traits, as is technical potential vs existing technical ability. I seek out ways to hire people who can (and want to) learn quickly, regardless of current skill level. Personally, I’m totally convinced by your comment that your technical ability is high, where you say it is. You would easily pass my entry filter and make it to an interview. But after that, I’d want to talk to you, not sit at my computer looking through your portfolio.
- bambataa 7y agoBecause companies often ask for it! They ask for a link to your Github profile or portfolio, making people feel their GH needs to give the best version of them, and then completely disregard it. if you’re lucky it makes you pass some CV filter but you still need to jump through the rest of their hoops even though they have accepted the evidence that you can program.
- ChrisMarshallNY 7y ago
- Aunche 7y ago> And no one bothers to look at my portfolio when I've been contacted to apply for engineering positions. I think the root cause of all interview issues is that interviewers aren't incentivized to care. You're never going to get promoted or even a good performance review for reading a candidate's code or ask them meaningful questions. On the other hand, it takes little effort to pick a couple algo questions and use them for everybody, and they still provide some meaningful signal. With alternative interview methods, apathetic interviewers will just rely on their intuition, which is how a "good ole boy's club" is formed.
- neonate 7y agoYou mentioned that you've been writing shipping software for over thirty years. To what extent do you think ageism is the issue here?
- ChrisMarshallNY 7y agoHuge, but I have made it a point to reduce my bellyaching about it. A lot of the reason that I stopped looking for work, was because, almost instantly upon finding out that I am afflicted with eld, the microaggressions and veiled insults begin. It's kind of amazing. People contact me, telling me how awesome my résumé is, then quickly backtrack, as soon as they find out it comes with grey hair. I guess the industry is full of 30-year-olds with 35 years' worth of experience. It was really getting me steamed. I'm not rich, and could always use the income from more work, but not badly enough to put up with that stuff. I just make sure that people know that I'm "ancient," right up front, so we don't waste each others' time.
- neonate 7y agoThat's frustrating and unfortunately unsurprising.