4 ms·
> Mathematicians are perfectly capable of doing all those self-care things, as monks do in every monastery Are they, though? In the pursuit of my PhD, I met p
by klyrs 7y ago
> Mathematicians are perfectly capable of doing all those self-care things, as monks do in every monastery
Are they, though? In the pursuit of my PhD, I met plenty of mathematicians who could barely wipe their own ass, let alone cook a meal or, god forbid, build a simple hut. Did you know that most mathematicians use computers? Do you expect these same people to manage the chemistry, physics, engineering, mining and logistics necessary to build their own computing devices?
> I think the downvoting of my "tirade" to -2 has shown that non-mathematicians hate and fear mathematicians, think that all those killings of mathematicians I listed were reasonable and justified, and would like to silence any criticism of them.
That's quite a chain of conjectures... you may be a mathematician, but you certainly aren't holding yourself to mathematical standards here.
Here's a counterexample. I downvoted you. I'm a mathematician. And fwiw Galois died in a duel, which is, by definition, a consensual affair. His killing was an unreasonable, unjustified tragedy, but he brought it on himself. Oded Schramm did himself on a mountain; by the way -- you're shit-talking "non-mathematicians" for taking senseless risks, but missing the obvious and playing victim while referring to non-mathematicians as "torch-wielding villagers."
I downvoted you for your insufferable superiority complex and mindboggling narrow-mindedness.
- kragen 7y agoYou seem to be under the misconception that I am a mathematician. I think that's a bit of a stretch of the term, although I do enjoy math; as far as I know, I've never published or discovered a single novel mathematical result, and I certainly don't have any academic mathematical credentials. Very few of the humans would call me a mathematician. Everyone is born incapable of carrying out self-care tasks. Some of us remain that way for our entire lives, but most don't. I haven't observed a strong correlation between mathematical ability and potty-training or cooking ability, so surely any community of mathematicians would have enough people who could cook a meal that they'd get along okay, in the improbable scenario where they were forced into strict autarky. Duels are not consensual except in the sense that it's consensual to surrender to the police when they tackle you. Struggling against the police, or fleeing the duel, is overwhelmingly likely to get you killed. I'm not sure where you're getting this idea that I'm "shit-talking non-mathematicians for taking senseless risks"; one mathematician I know went to Italy for a week to stay in the house of a man she'd just met in Argentina to dance in his tango show, while another juggled his baby to illustrate a lecture about siteswaps (and, perhaps more shockingly, gave up tenure for the baby's mother). I think mathematicians tend to take more long-term risks and less short-term risks than non-mathematicians. None of those examples is quite in the same category as "he grabbed the cop by her bulletproof vest", for example, which is something I saw a non-mathematician do as I helped the cops to arrest him. What I'm shit-talking non-mathematicians for is killing mathematicians, burning the Academy and the works of the Mohists, destroying the German universities in the service of a stupid self-congratulatory racist ideology, and destroying democracy in America for the same reason. None of those amount to "taking senseless risks"; their undesirable results were nearly guaranteed and indeed intended by the perpetrators. You're not wrong about the insufferable superiority complex, but you ought to consider the way in which my "tirade" is actually correct, even if my insufferable superiority complex annoys you. As a mathematician, you undoubtedly have a great deal of experience changing your mind after hearing arguments from people you don't particularly like. I suggest you try doing it in this case.
- jcranmer 7y ago> Duels are not consensual except in the sense that it's consensual to surrender to the police when they tackle you. Struggling against the police, or fleeing the duel, is overwhelmingly likely to get you killed. That's not how duels work. A challenge for a duel is usually issued in response to a perceived insult or injury to one's honor, and the request for a duel would often be delivered in writing. The only penalty for refusing a duel is the attendant impact on social standing--you could be seen as dishonorable or cowardly for refusing a duel. And even if you agreed to a duel, you might be able to get out of it simply by being disagreeable as to the actual conditions of a duel.
- kragen 7y agoListen, I don't know if you've ever lived in an honor society, but if you're a man in an honor society, "you could be seen as dishonorable or cowardly" (the word they used for me here was puto, which means "faggot") is pretty much a death sentence. Your understanding of comparative anthropology seems to be as weak as your understanding of ancient Egyptian mathematics.
- klyrs 7y ago> Duels are not consensual except in the sense that it's consensual to surrender to the police when they tackle you. Struggling against the police, or fleeing the duel, is overwhelmingly likely to get you killed. The history is quite unclear with regard to the fateful duel of Galois, and historical record suggests that it's quite possible he was the one who laid the challenge! > As a mathematician, you undoubtedly have a great deal of experience changing your mind after hearing arguments from people you don't particularly like. I suggest you try doing it in this case. I admit that I'm wrong when it's demonstrated that I'm wrong. This is common among mathematicians, and makes me insufferable in my own way. I would suggest you reconsider your characterization of the downvotes you've received -- multiple mathematicians are responding to you, and there's lots of us here on HN: your audience is not comprised of torch-wielding villagers. And yet you continue to dig in -- this sort of conversation is undesirable here, and I'd recommend you to consider the site guidelines and your fellow conversational partners' opinions before continuing. (I'll desist after this comment, and bid you farewell)