4 ms·
I think that "apparently very few people actually know how to program a computer" part is more about how many people have "fake it till you make it" attitude or
by watwut 7y ago
I think that "apparently very few people actually know how to program a computer" part is more about how many people have "fake it till you make it" attitude or how large ego they have. Or how much they dont bother how they look like during interview and keep trying until they get lucky scoring position. And that actually is how many get to start programming. As in, one of common advice is to be self-learner and absent reasonable guidelines on when you know enough, you get a lot of these - and few people who learn enough to get junior position and are lucky enough to find company that happen to have junior positions.
We tend to praise people who take the risk, fake it till they make it are go getters etc. And possibly these are trying for that.
And maybe it would be pretty cool to see a sociological study about who these people are. What demographic they belong to, what background they have, what kind of personalities and value they have.
- ozim 7y agoIt is not only about people who try to get lucky for junior positions. I have seen people who think of themselves as "super senior developers" who were more "business bullshit specialists" who knew names of things but when faced with technical challenges were lost right away. Those people could maybe configure WiFi router with web interface but if you get them to work on industrial grade router with stripped down Linux it is not something they can jump over.
- watwut 7y agoI think these are in the "fake it till you make it" or "large ego" groups. And it is even very likely they have been employed at senior positions - senior by definition of managers that employed and kept them. And often even senior by needs of those companies. One issue is that average management is not good and management of software projects is not solved problem. That badly affects hiring and promoting in many teams. But another issue is that tech is wide range of jobs that require completely different aptitudes and skillsets. We are not even starting to classify it all enough to be able to reasonably communicate what position is.
- rm445 7y agoIt doesn't seem to be all fakers. The situation as described by advocates of FizzBuzz and the like, is that large minority proportions of people who have already held down jobs in the software development field, actually can barely do things that we think of as basic programming, like implement a very straightforward function. The implication seems to be that there's just too many to all be actual liars; that they're doing some kind of cargo-cult, cut-and-paste, stack-overflow based work to keep themselves in a job, changing things by tweaking them but not actually capable of anything else. It seems implausible. It's counter-intuitive. But the idea seems pretty persistent. It's an interesting question for me personally. I'm a mechanical engineer who likes to program a little and I've sometimes wondered whether I could work as a programmer. I haven't got the right qualifications or experience with enough popular technologies, so moving fields would be tough. But I know I can implement basic things from scratch. It doesn't seem like much (and clearly it wouldn't be enough for the prestigious places with really tough computer science interviews) but it would be interesting to know if that actually was enough to clear a certain low bar of competence.
- wutbrodo 7y ago> It seems implausible. It's counter-intuitive. But the idea seems pretty persistent. Some of us have direct experience with exactly this situation (see my previous comment). Hell, Jeff Atwood wrote a whole piece on it a long time ago.
- karatestomp 7y agoAs a programmer who is for-sure well past "fizzbuzz" quality and has been for a while now, I can just about guarantee I've left interviewers with the impression they dodged a can't-actually-program bullet when they rejected me, a couple times.
- watwut 7y agoHow it happened?
- 7y ago
- hinkley 7y agoThe thing is we want to be surrounded by people who see development as a calling, and not just a safe career. That cycle has been going on for years. Now, there are so many companies that are essentially writing variants on the same software over and over again that demand is dictating the shape of the field. The shape of the industry. “We” are all industrial designers in a world that just isn’t that enthused. If we wanted this other world that we keep interviewing for, then it’s not a matter of not enough programmers, but way too many. They’re cheap enough that people everywhere are reinventing wheels instead of assembling off the shelf components designed for that purpose.
- watwut 7y agoI think that the idea that people who see development as safe career are the most incapable is just wrong. Someone stable that does what needs to be done even when it is not fun sounds good to me. Large parts of projects are not fun nor challenging - they are work that needs to be done with good quality. People who see their jobs as safe careers are routinely good at those jobs. And conversely, I have met people who talked about passion and seemed passionate and had all the right opinions. And they were not good simply because they would loose interest when it stopped to be fun or somehow never finished anything that was medium sized, were disorganized or demotivated easily.
- hinkley 7y agoI don't think we are necessarily in disagreement. What we want and what we need are often at odds, perhaps nowhere more clearly than in the way we select new team members. I speculated on why our interviews are so insane, and just kept pulling that thread. What I omitted from GP was this thought: I don't know if we are right to want this, or if the world could have ever let us have it anyway. There are other measures of 'contributor' that we weed out with our interview processes. Some of those are qualities that working programmers are more likely to have. For instance, work-a-day developers tend to be less susceptible to hubris. Sometimes when you have a problem to solve, you want the no-bullshit person to do it. It's way easier for me to talk someone out of Imposter Syndrome or at least convince their boss to ignore it than it is for me to dial in the degree of Kruger-Dunning my faster-talking coworkers are covering up.
- taurath 7y agoI’m self taught, and have kicked ass at every position I’ve ever had, and rise quickly. Alg interviews suck the very life out of me - nothing is ever relevant to to actually building working software in 2020.
- karatestomp 7y agoI often look like I have no idea what I'm doing with computers when someone is watching. I also find it almost impossible to practice an instrument with someone watching. Performing is another matter. To do well at interview coding I'd having to drill relevant questions to the point that I was performing rather than practicing in the interview, and I'd probably still be freaked out and unable to do it unless I knew the questions I'd face in advance. Luckily actually working in software development is a hell of a lot more like practicing than performing, and there's usually no-one watching you, so I'm fine at that part.
- zach_garwood 7y agoI think the whole phenomenon is s Boogeyman. I've only been in the industry for a decade, so maybe I haven't been all the way around the block, but I've never met the mythical "senior Dev who can't code fizzbuzz." I think it's just a scary story we tell hiring managers do they stay on their guard.