Perhaps in some cases it approaches the linguists' approach, but the Requirement Elicitation I have actually witnessed looks more like a group of stakeholders i

Perhaps in some cases it approaches the linguists' approach, but the Requirement Elicitation I have actually witnessed looks more like a group of stakeholders in a room, writing on a whiteboard or something similar. Better is to make an MTP (minimum testable product), and put it in front of the user and have them tell you all the ways it's wrong.