5 ms·
I really had a lot of hope for bootcamps in general and ISAs in specific. I thought the alignment of incentives might make for radically more effective educatio
by wpietri 7y ago
I really had a lot of hope for bootcamps in general and ISAs in specific. I thought the alignment of incentives might make for radically more effective education.
I was very wrong. The ISA incentive appears to be nothing to the VC/startup incentive to Show! Massive! Growth! as you chase ever-larger chunks of money. Somehow we've gone from "move fast and break things" (which is not a terrible slogan to encourage experimentation on non-consequential things) to "move fast and break people" (which horrifies me).
- _bxg1 7y agoI still think ISAs as a concept make a lot of sense. It seems like most of the problem is that the classes are often worthless, not the particular way in which you pay for them. There was the whole thing with the collections agencies but that can happen with any type of loan.
- wpietri 7y agoI was hoping that the ISAs would fix the worthless-classes problem. My theory was that if the institution's compensation was more directly tied to how much they helped the student, they'd be better at helping students. Unfortunately, there's still a fundamental broken feedback loop here: the people purchasing an education are definitionally unqualified to evaluate it. I don't see a way to fix that without significant regulation, which unfortunately acts as a brake on evolution of both program content and educational methods.
- _bxg1 7y agoYeah, that's part of why Lambda's ISAs came into the spotlight recently: they were turning around and selling them immediately, which broke that incentive alignment that students may have been counting on.
- lmeyerov 7y agoStuff like VC funding breaks the alignment between leadership and students: former is rewarded by pump and dump and maybe eventually good, not cohorts 10-50 doing well.
- austenallred 7y agoMake sure you read what is actually happening with the ISAs, because incentive alignment isn’t broken: https://lambdaschool.com/the-commons/announcing-our-new-isa-financing-blueprint-and-100m-in-new-financing https://lambdaschool.com/the-commons/announcing-our-new-isa-...
- ergocoder 7y agoA capped ISA seems superior than student loan. I wish gov would implement that instead of a non-bankruptable loan. I hope this doesn't make people discard the ISA idea altogether because of a bad implementation that is unrelated to the ISA itself. When talking about student debt forgiveness, I think it's too extremely. We can make it milder like forgiving interest or converting it to some sort of a capped ISA. This is a much less controversial idea than forgiving the whole debt that I'm not sure I agree with.
- alexhutcheson 7y ago> We can make it milder like forgiving interest or converting it to some sort of a capped ISA. That exists: https://studentaid.gov/manage-loans/repayment/plans/income-driven https://studentaid.gov/manage-loans/repayment/plans/income-d...
- ergocoder 7y agoWait, so why are there many complaints about student debt loop? A capped ISA (like what Lambda offers) would be livable and capped. Why does everyone not get onto this program?
- dnautics 7y agoMostly optics, I'd say, because it's more obviously fractional slavery than how nondischargeable debt is.
- alexhutcheson 7y agoThere are significant differences: - With the Lambda ISA, your remaining balance is forgiven after 2 years of payments, while the federal income-driven repayment plans require 20-25 years of payments. - Lambda ISA has a fixed dollar "cap" (currently $30k), but the "cap" for income-driven repayment plans is however much you borrowed + interest that accrues over the life of the loan. - Most importantly, the Lambda ISA is for a much smaller amount of money. Very few of the news articles about student debt profile students with a balance of only $30k. The horror stories tend to be students who borrowed >$100k, often for graduate study.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]