5 ms·
Discussion on the fact that over half of the population doesn't vote is always built upon a number of assumptions. To name a few: - a democratic system in whic
by keiferski 7y ago
Discussion on the fact that over half of the population doesn't vote is always built upon a number of assumptions. To name a few:
- a democratic system in which everyone is "required" to participate in the political process is desirable state of affairs
- the voting process is the best way of choosing these democratic representatives, as opposed to a civil servant exam, selection by lot (randomness, like jury duty), or some other type of system. Personally I like the idea of combining the two: pass an exam to be placed into a "potentials" pool, from which representatives are selected randomly. Then have a background check after that, etc.
- That the best solution is to figure out why people aren't voting and change their mind, and not to develop a different method of selecting government officials
It would be much more interesting (to me, at least) to explore other forms of government that maintain the benefits of civil liberties, open society, etc. without relying on the flawed media popularity contest that is voting. There is plenty of political and philosophical writing on this - we simply need to be willing to try it out.
- SamReidHughes 7y agoIt depends on who it's desirable to. You can see this electoral system manipulation quite a bit in Singapore. They introduced mandatory voting to help the PAP win an election. Their system of group constituencies was introduced to stop competing parties from focusing on one race, or to make it harder for them to get their foot in the door, depending on who you ask. The system of presidential elections, and the requirements to be a presidential candidate (which includes things like having been in charge of a big organization), was designed to limit the damage if some opposition party wins an election. Not to mention all the restrictions on speech...
- iamaelephant 7y agoThere is absolutely no way to prepare such an exam without (justified) accusations of bias.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- keiferski 7y agoPossibly true, but we also haven’t really attempted it on a society-wide scale. Clearly some government agencies are capable of creating fair tests (NASA, for example.) In any case, the question isn’t whether an exam would be perfect, but whether it would be better than voting. There are certainly plenty of biases involved in the voting process: appearance, public speaking ability, etc. These biases might already be greater than any which arise from an exam.
- RangerScience 7y agohttps://lmgtfy.com/?q=history+of+voter+tests https://lmgtfy.com/?q=history+of+voter+tests Has been tried on society-wide scales.
- dane-pgp 7y agoIn theory, different parties could put forward different proposed exams before an election, and then citizens could vote on which exam would be used to filter the candidates. (There would probably have to be a "null exam" option on the ballot, to allow people to oppose the use of this filter, and perhaps all non-voters should be counted as having voted for that option). Arguably, though, this process would just move the problem of voter apathy back a step, unless there is some reason to expect that voting for exams is more motivating (or more reasonable to make mandatory) than voting for candidates. Also, it's not clear that the exam would be testing anything other than candidates' memory, as presumably the correct answers would have to be published in advance for the citizens to check.
- grandmczeb 7y agoAre you aware of the historical abuse of “literacy requirements”[1] for voting? It’s hard to understand how your proposed system would not have similar problems; whoever has control of the test effectively has complete power over who can become an elected official. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Literacy_test https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Literacy_test
- keiferski 7y agoThis is not the same thing as I am proposing. These were restrictions on voters, not on elected officials. There have always been some restrictions on elected officials (age, for example) and I think it’s obvious that you’d want competent literate people in positions. As to your second point - there could certainly be ways to address that. But the exam is a minor filter - the real selection would be via randomness, as I mentioned. If anything, the test makers would have less control over the officials than our current lobbyist system.
- grandmczeb 7y agoYou're not proposing the same system, but the system you're proposing has same problem. Step 1: Make the test extremely difficult so essentially nobody passes. Step 2: Allow a de facto exemption for some group based on an arbitrary qualification you can control (e.g. automatic pass to those deemed to have "good community standing.") Step 3: One of your pre-chosen candidates wins the random selection since they make up the entire candidate pool.
- keiferski 7y agoOf course if you just arbitrarily add rules, the idea will collapse. I don’t see how that is relevant. The basic concept I am proposing is that representatives are not selected via voting (which is deeply flawed and ineffective) but via a more fair and effective system. Ideally this would be both random and meritocratic. You’d simply design the system in a way in which the test is chosen by the population and/or by an entity separate from the representatives. At worst, you’d get the current three-part division of power system which most democratic countries are based on.
- hhas01 7y ago“a democratic system in which everyone is "required" to participate in the political process is desirable state of affairs” Citizens of a democratic nation have one job to do. If they’re not doing it, the question must be Why?
- remarkEon 7y ago>Citizens of a democratic nation have one job to do. This seems circular, and makes it sound like citizens exist to serve the government rather than the other way around.
- krapp 7y agoOptimally it should be a mutually beneficial relationship.
- artfulhippo 7y agoThe idea that a government could benefit sounds weird to me. I think of benefiting as requiring a subjective personal experience. When you fix your car, does your car benefit? When you remodel your house, does your house benefit? In my mind, government functions, and ideally it functions in service of the people.
- craftinator 7y agoBecause expecting everyone to vote without incentive is stupid. Voting is NOT a job, by definition. You aren't paid for it. The common argument here is that the incentive to vote is to "take control of your future", or some similar marketing schlock. There must be a reason so many people feel that voting does not give them control of their future! I submit that the electoral process has become so flawed and gamed, that the average person has NO control.
- codegladiator 7y ago> Citizens of a democratic nation have one job to do. And they are doing their job. Voting was never a job.
- mnm1 7y agoWhat you propose would require a constitutional congress and a rewriting of the constitution. That's why we're not trying out things like this. In the current political atmosphere, calling a constitutional congress would be suicide for our nation. I cannot see anything positive coming out of it or any type of government that isn't authoritarian and dictatorial. The reality is that we don't have a choice and fantasizing about alternative power structures instead of voting does no one any good. Of course, if you feel strongly about this, we're only a couple of states away from calling a constitutional congress and the national suicide and likely civil war that would usher in. But you have the right to work towards that and legally bring about the demise of the US. I will certainly not stick around for that shitshow.
- keiferski 7y agoThis is silly. Suggesting a change to the way democratic representatives are selected is not tantamount to wishing for civil war. I remind you that “democratic system” is not the same thing as “voting system.”
- mnm1 7y agoMaybe so but what the parent comment is suggesting is that we do not have a democratic process. Maybe it's possible to do this as just a constitutional amendment instead of a constitutional convention. I think that's even less likely to succeed.
- keiferski 7y agoI think it would have to start as a smaller movement on the local level, which (assuming it had positive outcomes) would eventually grow into a nationwide idea.