6 ms·
Business Is Booming
- zdw 16y agoFundamentally, the businesses (outside of technology focused firms) are nothing more than middlemen that add little value. I'm waiting for Foxconn or similar to start making their own commodity items and selling them directly - you can, for example, already buy SFF computers with the Foxconn label on them. It's just a matter of time for the profit engines that US corporations have created to be cloned and have the entire profit center go overseas.
- nickpinkston 16y agoThe businesses that "add little value" are envied in China because they have access to demand, and he who owns demand is key. The Chinese are making it a priority to advance their marketing, design, etc. abilities to compete in the West's consumer culture. While you may not like marketing, it brings in the money - and in our consumerist economy that's our GDP... I'd like to see Foxconn try to replace Apple - hell even Dell. Lenovo had to buy their business from IBM to get the marketing / brand support to be successful beyond their manufacturing capabilities. It's hard to market from a culture from the outside. VW made their German designers live with US families - which is when they figured out why we want cup holders so badly ;-)
- jdthomas 16y agoFoxconn (and similar) do design a lot of products already, they just are acting as an ODM and not slapping their own name on them. I suspect, though, they are happy with this arrangement as it allows them to make many more products in any segment than a single brand would get away with.
- davnola 16y ago> According to a survey this summer from the National Employment Law Project, only a third of the jobs lost in 2008-2009 were in industries paying less than $15 an hour, but fully three-quarters of the job growth in 2010 came in these same low-wage industries. Among the industries that grew in 2010, the top three occupations were retail sales clerks, cashiers, and food preparers with a median hourly wage of less than $10. So? It takes longer to hire higher waged staff. Hiring higher waged staff is ceteris paribus more of a risk so you'd expect it to pick up later in the recovery.
- yummyfajitas 16y agoThe author of this article has internalized some Keynesian assumptions so deeply that he doesn't realize the story he is writing directly falsifies one of them. A major assumption of Keynesian economics is that employment scales with production. Thus, if you stimulate aggregate demand, you will increase production, and thereby increase employment. This hasn't happened - aggregate demand and production have recovered, but employment has not. The fact is, our economy is a lot more complicated than it used to be. Workers are not interchangeable cogs and expanding profits does not necessarily involve expanding employment. Stimulating demand in retail will not raise the employment of construction workers or realtors. Many employees produce nothing directly, but merely improve the value of capital [1] - increased profits don't demand hiring more employees, and reduced profits don't demand firing them. Until economics catches up with the times, all we will get are silly ideas like "invest in infrastructure" and "stimulate demand". Really, you think jobs are moving to India because of their infrastructure? Lets get real here. I've done a little work for someone who created about 30 jobs in Pune. He drives for 2-4 hours on crappy roads to get from his house in Bombay to the office, only to discover that the power is out and no work can be done today. You think he'll come back to the US if you widen a few highways? [1] I'm a good example. My labor is directly worth nothing - all of my companies profits are directly attributable to capital (a trading system + money in the brokerage account). My employment is an investment - I have a significant probability of increasing the value of that capital.
- Lost_BiomedE 16y agoInvesting in infrastructure isn't silly if it is a large project that only government could afford, addresses a current or near future problem, and has favorable return on investment. Widening highways and filling potholes has been more about giving states a short-term bailout under the name of stimulating the economy.
- yummyfajitas 16y agoI'm not saying all infrastructure projects are a bad idea. I'm just pointing out that the thesis of the author is silly. Jobs are being created in India rather than in the US, and better infrastructure won't bring those jobs back. In the US, a single bridge collapse is a national outrage, and a sign of "crumbling infrastructure". India has had at least one major collapse per year for the past 5 years: http://www.theglobeandmail.com/sports/more-sports/bridge-collapse-brings-hurdles-facing-indias-games-into-focus/article1717615/ http://www.theglobeandmail.com/sports/more-sports/bridge-col... http://news.smh.com.au/breaking-news-world/india-bridge-collapse-kills-17-20091225-lewj.html http://news.smh.com.au/breaking-news-world/india-bridge-coll... http://articles.cnn.com/2008-10-19/world/india.bridge_1_metro-rail-system-slabs-bus-driver?_s=PM:WORLD http://articles.cnn.com/2008-10-19/world/india.bridge_1_metr... http://www.rupya.com/archives/2007/09/10/hyderabad-bridge-collapse-collapses-gammon-india.html http://www.rupya.com/archives/2007/09/10/hyderabad-bridge-co... http://www.indiadaily.org/entry/bridge-collapse-contractors-fault-railway-minister/ http://www.indiadaily.org/entry/bridge-collapse-contractors-... The NYC subways are crowded at rush hour. Here are Indian trains: http://www.google.com/images?q=india+train&um=1&ie=UTF-8&source=univ&sa=X&ei=HxpgTeS9LcLcgQfk9bWIAg&ved=0CEcQsAQ&biw=1198&bih=675 http://www.google.com/images?q=india+train&um=1&ie=U... Suffice it to say, jobs are being created in India rather than here in spite of infrastructure. If infrastructure mattered, the jobs would already be here. US infrastructure is top class - roughly the same as in all other first world countries (Japan, France, UK, etc), and is orders of magnitude better than that of India or China (no week-long traffic jams, for instance). (Not trying to single out India, I just know more about India than China, the Philippines, or other popular outsourcing sites.)
- fedd 16y agoin capitalism, if you own, you don't have to work with hands. the nation in general owns plants abroad, so everything okay :) in general :) (just don't stop to spend on military, or the ownership right could be questioned)
- fredBuddemeyer 16y agoits usually observers that keep such nationalistic score cards; participants just see people and markets.
- deleted 16y ago[deleted]
- bryanlarsen 16y agoLook on the bright side: if it is American companies who are making these huge profits overseas, then there is some chance of the jobs being created in America, whether forced to by government or voluntarily. Foreign companies making huge profits outside of America are not going to spend money or hire people in the U.S.
- muhfuhkuh 16y ago"there is some chance of the jobs being created in America" Wow, so we have to pin our hopes on a chance that American companies will throw us a couple pity jobs in America _maybe_? We need a term describing the labor equivalent of "regulatory capture"; something that describes our collective misguided hope that corporations will somehow give us back "our jobs". I think everyone should just try to start a business. Seriously, everyone who is out of work or underutilized in some job they are completely overqualified for should just start any kind of hare-brained scheme or hustle or side-somethingorother. Move if you have to, to some tax-advantaged or microscopic cost-of-living state. Anything has to be better than {un|under}employment or working under the thumb of an employer who not only knows but (perhaps) relishes in the workload they can continue to offload on you because they know you can't leave in this environment. To heck with getting "our country back", we need our individual (and collective) dignity back.
- csomar 16y agoAt Apple, the ratio of Foxconn employees at work on Apple products to U.S.-based Apple employees is 10-to-1: 250,000 Foxconn workers to 25,000 Apple workers. The same ratio exists at Dell. Huh, bullsh*t. I don't know what the average Apple worker gets paid but I'm assuming that most of them are developers (or related), so it's in the $100K/year. What about their Chinese counter part? I don't have any data but based on my country which has better wages in average it should be in the $10K/year ballpark if not less. And it's quite a lot different, the USA developer buys a nice car in his first year, while the poor Chinese worker may never figure out how to get an old one.
- davidmathers 16y agoThe amount of logical and economic fail in this article is overwhelming. The Atlantic version was better, probably because it didn't have an axe to grind: http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=2072200 http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=2072200 Disclaimer: I lean socialist but not nationalist which means I'm biased against the basic premises of the article. But it's not the premises that fail, it's the reasoning.
- thisisananth 16y agoThe article talks that Germany is able to export even after giving full wages in the workers. How is it possible?
- rdouble 16y agoGermany exports expensive stuff.
- thisisananth 16y agoThe article talks that Germany is able to export even after giving full wages in the workers. How is it that their products are competitive for exports even after paying good salaries compared to China or India?
- obxerve 16y agoDifferent product class and/or different product altogether. Think BMW or Merc and many other good quality brands that are well marketed. Different buyers. And yes there are a lot of rich buyers outside US.
- known 16y agoI think America is becoming a nation of products/services resellers