5 ms·
Myst: the Drawbacks to Success
- pcunite 7y agoMyst was captivating. Visually so "immersive" with just enough graphics to really stimulate what "might" be around the corner. I truly could sense that I was somewhere else, another planet or whatever, abandoned, with me to explore.
- markdeloura 7y agoThat's exactly what hooked me - I worked in a VR research lab while an undergrad and then grad student, and Myst came out just as VR was fizzling out. It was the most immersive thing I'd ever experienced without a headset - I would turn off all the lights and crank up the audio, and lose myself for hours.
- aidenn0 7y agoI felt that way for about 10 minutes, after which it felt like visiting a Hollywood set; looks great but it's just a facade. The level of interactivity was just too little to be convincing. As TFA says, a lot of people blame Myst for the death of the adventure game, but it was already trending that way in '93 as graphics improved. Most of the random actions that you could take to interact with the world in the Sierra games resulted in a fairly generic animation and a wall of text. This meant anything the designer anticipated could be interacted with, because the cost of writing that text was low (particularly with Sierra's near lack of editing and playtesting). Once a generic animation and a wall of text was no longer acceptable from a production-value stance, these games were stripped of their charm, and all you were left with were charmless puzzle games with some window-dressing. Myst got there first and did it better than everyone else, so it gets the blame for something that was inevitable.
- tialaramex 7y agoMore inexcusable is the aesthetic choice to do this now, when you can afford to have decent graphics and let players do whatever they want but designers often inexplicably decide to curate the experience to the point where you might as well just watch somebody else's play. I wouldn't have built Myst because to me it seems pointless, why not just make a movie about this? Or a picture book? But clearly lots of people enjoyed it. Still, back then I could safely assume anything that looked that good had nothing behind the facade, today it's harder to guess. It reminds me of a phenomenon which is broadly disliked in tabletop Role Playing. Some GMs like to plot out everything in great detail which necessarily means you can't go off piste, they need you to go into the tunnels under the castle with the torch because they've worked out exactly what will happen when you do. If their players try to instead simply leave the castle because it's boring, or divert a river into the tunnels and flood them to drive anything down there out the GM will either be angry and demand the players reconsider or will try to railroad the players into proceeding with the plan as they envisioned. Either way this is an unsatisfying experience for everybody.
- jfengel 7y agoThere wasn't enough story for a movie. It was pretty enough to be a picture book, but how big is the market for picture books? It was a puzzle game. The puzzles were pretty basic, but the market for basic puzzle games is significant. Especially if the puzzle is also attractive enough that the next batch of visuals feels like a decent reward for having solved the puzzle. Such a game won't attract people who want more interaction from their games -- though you do have to remember that at the time even a game like Doom was a huge advance in interactivity. Myst was relaxing rather than exciting, almost the way a game of solitaire or a crossword puzzle is.
- makapuf 7y agoI remembered Sierra games (loom, leisure suit Larry, monkey island) with mostly animations and only a bit of text for dialogues ? (Edit: clarify)
- aidenn0 7y ago1. 2 out of 3 of those games are from Lucas Arts not Sierra 2. Many of the deaths had animations and a bit of text, but see all the non-death things you could do that KQ1 had[1] and it did not have anywhere near the most. 1: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-TB_IYQ-GJ0 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-TB_IYQ-GJ0
- makapuf 7y agoMy bad of course those are Lucasfilm. However, I was referring to late adventure point and clicks, unlike kq1 from 84: let's take lucasfilm games post 93, including grim fandango or full throttle, those do not seem to fit your description.
- aidenn0 7y agoMy point exactly, the genre was already trending in that direction, with higer production values.
- danso 7y agoFor some reason I vaguely remember 1993 as having a 7th Guest vs Myst marketing theme. To this day I still haven’t played Myst but my memories of 7th Guest have not grown fonder with time.
- mattbillenstein 7y agoPlay realMyst - it's a fun experience.
- james_s_tayler 7y agoReplayed it a couple of years back. Can confirm.
- thewebcount 7y agoJust note that if you play it on iOS there is a bug that makes one really useful clue not show up, and can leave you scratching your head as to what to do. (Hint: When you see the map in the library, the tower should be blinking. It's not.)
- arminiusreturns 7y agoI loved 7th Guest! I mean yes looking back it seems a bit cringe-worthy, but the merging of video into a game that had a decent creepy factor made me want more and set me on a course of enjoying creepy/scary video games.
- SlowRobotAhead 7y agoI can’t remember if I liked 7th guest or 11th hour better. But I distinctly remember playing both and myst and thinking the graphics in video games were amazing :)
- a_e_k 7y agoThe linked article had a picture of the Windows-version box cover for Myst: https://www.filfre.net/2020/02/myst-or-the-drawbacks-to-success/11855-myst-windows-front-cover/ https://www.filfre.net/2020/02/myst-or-the-drawbacks-to-succ... Look more closely at the last review quote in the upper left. :-)
- mdonahoe 7y ago“ the overlap between players of games like Doom and those like Myst is inevitably limited. (The surprising thing is that an overlap exists at all…)” Really? Is it that rare to like both? I find this hard to believe.
- eps 7y agoYeah, that's a pretty odd statement to put it mildly. Probably an over-extrapolation from an insufficient sample set.
- vitaflo 7y agoI do too, especially because when you combine the two you basically end up with Metroid Prime, another very popular well made game.
- lostgame 7y agoFor years I’ve (often unsuccessfully) tried to pitch people Metroid Prime, calling it ‘Myst with a gun’, to which my friends responses often include ‘what’s Myst?’. Doesn’t quite capture the platforming awesomeness, though. First good first person platformer I’ve played.
- tkahnoski 7y agoThis is one of those things that are obvious once stated, but for some reason never made the connection. I fell out of gaming shortly after Wii was released (adulting?). Did the later installments of the franchise deliver the same experience?
- jhbadger 7y agoAs the article mentions, a bigger anti-Myst sentiment was from the traditional inventory-NPC based adventure fandom, which was annoyed that this game eliminated inventory and NPC-based puzzles. And arguably killed the traditional adventure games, except for fan works.
- jhbadger 7y ago
- eps 7y agoAlso, a 2 hour (!) interview with Rand Miller by Arstechnica, which has been absolutely killing it lately with their in-depth gamedev coverage - https://arstechnica.com/gaming/2020/02/an-extended-interview-with-atrus-himself-myst-creator-rand-miller/ https://arstechnica.com/gaming/2020/02/an-extended-interview...
- thorum 7y agoMyst’s style of gameplay (user jumps from environment to environment by clicking) seems like it would be a great fit for the current generation of virtual reality headsets.
- theresistor 7y agoCyan’s latest game, Obduction, is quite good in VR.
- james_s_tayler 7y agoIt's epic.
- scroot 7y agoCyan's upcoming latest game is a VR title called Firmament: https://www.kickstarter.com/projects/1252280491/firmament https://www.kickstarter.com/projects/1252280491/firmament
- pavlov 7y agoI’m fascinated by the “outsider” profile of the Myst creators. Per the article, they didn’t play contemporary games and only used off-the-shelf GUI tools on the niche Mac platform — this in an era where “real games” used handcoded x86 assembly. Yet their creation outsold practically everyone in the industry by an order of magnitude. Where are the tools today for someone like this to be successful? Unity is of course impressive but seems very tightly bound to gaming industry thinking — not that approachable or interesting to an outsider. Around 2000-2005, the Flash GUI had lots of potential here... But then Adobe turned Flash into a programmer-oriented sprawling mini-Java and eventually Apple threw it under the iPhone bus.
- Waterluvian 7y agoLook up "Dreams" on the PS4. This is absolutely today's version of that.
- pavlov 7y agoThat’s very cool. I remember an excellent Siggraph presentation about the still in-development Dreams engine a few years ago. Nice to see it shipping. There’s a difference in distribution freedom though. HyperCard and Flash were conceived as production tools. You could interface with other tools and APIs. For the finished work, you could put it in a box and sell 6 million copies (like Myst), or host a game on your own server (like everything in the Flash golden era). The Dreams runtime is a console game — a prerequisite investment, and limited audience compared to desktop / web platforms. Hopefully they’ll offer some kind of player-only licensing program for creators eventually?
- Waterluvian 7y agoIndeed that is a very important difference. But in the absence of something truly open and free, Dreams is still incredibly empowering. I suspect that a truly open platform/distribution would never realistically exist alongside something of this quality. It's a nice idea but it just wouldn't happen. Something simple enough to be good and free is probably also not going to catch the attention of this generation of budding creatives.
- abruzzi 7y agoMyst was really the last game I played. As the article mentions, Doom was released at about the same time, and really became the blueprint for the future of gaming. My problem was I couldn’t play a FPS for more than 10 minutes or so before bad headaches kicked in. Sometimes I wonder if Myst was like Angry Birds. A game that gamers hated because it didn’t conform to their expectations, but something that found mor purchase with people that didn’t game heavily.
- karatestomp 7y agoHow could you hate Angry Birds unless you also hate the classic series Lemmings and Worms?
- RugnirViking 7y agoI was introduced to Myst as a youth in high school, which was probably the only time where I truly enjoyed writing. I'm not much of an author, but we we played through the first two worlds in myst together as a class and then had to write fiction set in those worlds, which really caught my imagination.
- jaredcwhite 7y agoAs a teen, Myst was my first rabid geek fandom. I spent hours, days, weeks, playing and replaying Myst, and its sequel Riven which is like Lord of the Rings to Myst's Hobbit. I was accepted into the early beta test program for URU, the MMORPG spinoff of the Myst franchise. It consumed the better part of a year…I helped run fan forums and organize in-game events. I made friends. For a time, it was an incredible community. A visual art reference and "making of" book about Myst and Riven became my bible as I pursued 3D graphics art and almost went to art school to become a game designer. I ended up dropping that idea and went into web/software space instead. (good career move!) All that to say, Myst is to me what, say, Star Wars is to many others. Its impact was gargantuan in my life and it shaped the person I am today. I will always be grateful to Cyan for that.
- mercer 7y agoSimilar for me. I was really into Star Wars too, but the Cyan worlds were on par with that. I never felt clever enough to actually finish the games without walkthroughs, but the world was one that I was fully invested in, and in a way equalled only by Star Wars, Star Trek, and Lord of the Rings.
- scroot 7y agoMy first website was a Geopages Myst fan site. I spent weeks trying to "debug" why I couldn't get a picture of Atrus to be the tiled background on my page using the eponymous tag. 12 year old me realized -- eventually -- that there is a "g" in the word "bacGround" ...
- joshuaellinger 7y agoI recently played Gorogoa, first game that reminded me of Myst in ages. Although it was much easier than I remember Myst being, it has that artistic flair that I loved about Myst. http://gorogoa.com/ http://gorogoa.com/
- AstralStorm 7y agoHmm. Gorogoa. Its puzzles are trivial in comparison. Byeing visual puzzles with only a few simple order of operations additions, they're hard to make harder. The game does not force exploration either. It's more like a puzzle visual novel than adventure game. (And you have no agency in it really.) But it is pretty.
- nsxwolf 7y agoAs someone who loved the adventure games of the 80s and 90s but somehow never played Myst, do you think it would be worth my time in 2020 to give it a play through?
- Rury 7y agoAll a matter of what you like to do with your time. Myst was a great adventure/puzzle game for its time. Although IMO, Riven and Myst III were better, with Riven being the pinnacle of the series. I would replay these if I were to play any of the games in the series again. Otherwise, if you're looking for something more modern, I'd recommend Quern.
- grogenaut 7y agoIt'll probably run a lot better on modern hardware.
- bambataa 7y agoI started playing realMyst recently (for the first time). Must admit I found it a bit unfun. Perhaps I just didn’t get into it enough but I found the puzzles sometimes quite unintuitive. I’ve also started The Witness and enjoying it more.
- Baeocystin 7y agoI know many people have very fond memories of it, and I don't want to disparage that, but I remember finding it dreadfully dull. And I liked the slower-paced games of the time, like the Infocom text adventures, or SimCity. But Myst just didn't engage me at all. I felt like I was looking at movie set posters with marginally-designed minigames attached, and it just didn't do it for me.
- scroot 7y agoMaybe play realMyst to get through it. But Riven is the real masterpiece, because the brothers took all of the lessons they learned and made something really amazing
- pmarreck 7y agoWe got our first Mac in 1984 when I was 12 (and we were seemingly the last people to get a computer in the fairly affluent neighborhood we moved to not long before). I've always loved Macs, and games. Myst was the last great Mac-only game. When it got ported to Windows, I was very sad, because I knew it meant the Mac was "dead man walking" as far as being a viable gaming platform was concerned. Oh, it floundered for a number of years later (shout-out to Oni https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ggC6kfJJE_w https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ggC6kfJJE_w , Myth II: Soulblighter https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=s84pODz7ATs https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=s84pODz7ATs and the Marathon series, all of which were made by a barely-known-at-the-time Bungie Software primarily (at first only) for Macs) but... anyway. Myst was magical and inspiring because Macs were magical and inspiring.
- scroot 7y agoMarathon Infinity was the absolute jam. It came with its own software for making levels/scenarios, and there were all these community-made Marathon games online. No one ever talks about it!
- pmarreck 7y agoAt the time (I was enlisted in the USAF for 4 years) I had PC gamers using my Mac just to play Marathon. Probably one of the last times that's happened, lol. (And I just realized one of the guys who did that often, Paul Voss, was killed recently in a crash, sigh: https://www.stripes.com/news/middle-east/air-force-aviators-killed-in-afghanistan-crash-were-lieutenant-colonel-with-25-years-of-service-and-b-1-bomber-pilot-1.616815 https://www.stripes.com/news/middle-east/air-force-aviators-... He also liked Escape Velocity, which was another Mac-only game at the time)
- thewebcount 7y agoEscape Velocity was so much fun! Someone recently did a remake (or copy is maybe a better term) of it called Endless Sky.
- 7y ago
- m12k 7y agoFor any Myst fans wondering if there are any recent games they might like, I'd highly recommend The Witness and Outer Wilds (not to be confused with Outer Worlds). The Witness is a gorgeous puzzle-solver where you learn a sort of 'puzzle language' while walking around a beautiful island and Outer Wilds is genre-defying, but blends physics, space-travel, exploration, puzzle solving and much more to become the most unique and captivating gaming experience I've had in many years.
- AstralStorm 7y agoUnfortunately Witness is different genre because the puzzles are mostly self-contained and exploration is not as necessary. Myst and Riven are adventure-puzzle games, while Witness is almost pure puzzle game. (Likewise Talos Principle, but it has some story.) Outer Wilds is action-adventure in that order. It does not allow the slow pace like Myst.
- m12k 7y agoI respectfully disagree on both counts. The puzzles in the Witness are linked - but instead of e.g. picking pushing a lever to help with another puzzle, you learn a new rule that will allow you to solve more advanced puzzles that combine the rules of several other puzzles. And the primary focus in Outer Wilds is not on action, but on exploration. And the way you learn about the history and technology of a previous civilization is quite similar to Myst.