3 ms·
In the Iowa caucuses, Sanders won a plurality, but tellingly he did terribly in second alignments. (I.e. when other candidates were not viable, those candidates
by rayiner 7y ago
In the Iowa caucuses, Sanders won a plurality, but tellingly he did terribly in second alignments. (I.e. when other candidates were not viable, those candidates’ supporters avoided Sanders.) That strongly indicates that his support is strong, but has a low ceiling—confined to a plurality of the party.
That’s not surprising. The Democratic Party as currently constructed is a third-way coalition including traditional progressives, labor, neo-liberals, and minorities. Sanders might have a plurality of the support in the party, but he threatens to blow up that coalition.
A successful Presidential candidate has to win 95% of their own party. But only 76% of Democrats say that they would vote for a socialist: https://news.gallup.com/poll/285563/socialism-atheism-political-liabilities.aspx https://news.gallup.com/poll/285563/socialism-atheism-politi.... A successful Presidential candidate has to evenly split independents—who comprise 30% of the electorate—with the other party’s candidate. But independents’ views of socialism are much closer to those of Republicans than to those of Democrats: https://www.npr.org/2020/02/19/807047941/poll-sanders-rises-but-socialism-isnt-popular-with-most-americans https://www.npr.org/2020/02/19/807047941/poll-sanders-rises-.... Any successful democratic candidate must win super-majorities of non-white people (90% of African Americans, and 75% of Hispanics and Asians.) But just 33% of non whites have a favorable view of socialism.
Bloomberg isn’t “buying” the support of “media outlets, think tanks, and state party leaders.” These are the people who established the third way coalition after devastating losses in the 1980s. These people are already looking for an alternative to Sanders. Bloomberg’s money is just getting his candidacy out there to help coalesce the “not Sanders” majority of the party.
- chishaku 7y agoYour analysis is certainly plausible but I think recent history, especially 2016, has shown that it's hard to trust any analysis that seems to have it all figured out. "Never Trump" seemed to be a bipartisan certainty and we all know how that went.
- claudeganon 7y agoIt’s telling that you try and pull the whole socialism card and not Sanders’ actual numbers, where he does things like beat Trump with independents by 18 points: https://fingfx.thomsonreuters.com/gfx/mkt/13/1950/1919/Topline%20Reuters%202020%20Election%20Tracker%2002%2010%202020.pdf https://fingfx.thomsonreuters.com/gfx/mkt/13/1950/1919/Topli... Leads with Latino voters, is first or second with African American voters, depending on the polling, and is literally the most popular senator in the country: https://morningconsult.com/senator-rankings/ https://morningconsult.com/senator-rankings/ You’re supposition that there’s going to be some outbreak of pearl clutching about “socialism” is about as plausible that Bloomberg isn’t buying the election.
- rayiner 7y agoI don’t think the national polling at this stage is elucidating. It’s like Biden’s numbers in the Democratic primary. Once the campaigning and debates started, and people became familiar with the candidate, his poll numbers collapsed. That’s why I’m pointing to the polling for socialism. My projection is that Trump will be very effective at making the election a referendum on socialism. It’s going to be wall to wall ads of Sanders’ praise of the USSR, Venezuela, etc. When that starts, I think Sanders’ poll numbers are going to collapse.
- claudeganon 7y agoRespectfully, this is as much unfounded speculation as any other questioning of national polling. You’re free to your skepticism of it, but you can’t base arguments on a cherry picking of that skepticism. I think Sanders will have an uphill battle against Trump (as would any of the primary candidates), but the Democrats are guaranteed to lose if he wins a plurality, they broker the convention, pick someone else, and disenfranchise Sanders’ massive base of support. And that is the documented outcome Bloomberg is pursuing: https://www.politico.com/news/2020/02/20/bloomberg-brokered-convention-strategy-116407 https://www.politico.com/news/2020/02/20/bloomberg-brokered-...
- pen2l 7y agorayiner, you cite poll numbers a lot -- "x% of y say they do|do not support z" -- which is good, it says a lot, but I want to bring something else to your attention, which I'm increasingly realizing is vitally important: personality, likability. I think pg has talked about this before too, one of great tests has been "is this person charismatic?" And further, that charismatic, assertive personalities can do wonders in changing and winning people's minds. No doubt Hillary would have won had she been more likable (or a man, America is still lagging behind when it comes to having a woman in charge). Sanders is more charismatic than Trump so he'll probably win, whatever the labels.
- blast 7y agoOh hey, you raise a good point here. When it was Trump vs. Hillary I remember thinking this was a great test of pg's charisma theory, since it predicted Trump while nearly everything and everyone else was predicting Hillary. (Alan Lichtman's "keys" test also predicted Trump: https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/the-fix/wp/2016/09/23/trump-is-headed-for-a-win-says-professor-whos-predicted-30-years-of-presidential-outcomes-correctly/ https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/the-fix/wp/2016/09/23/tr...) But what would the charisma test say about Trump vs. Sanders? I hadn't thought about that one. If it's Trump vs. Bloomberg, that's as much a no-brainer as last time. But Trump vs. Sanders? Not so clear. You say Sanders is more charismatic than Trump, but many people would disagree. In an all-American context, I think Trump is probably more charismatic than Sanders, though by a smaller margin than with Hillary or Bloomberg. To really decide that, though, we'd have to get into definitions of charisma. Lichtman's system is interesting since, like pg's theory, it depends on fundamentals and ignores polls. Lichtman also includes charisma as one of his keys. https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/the-fix/wp/2016/05/12/this-professor-has-predicted-every-presidential-election-since-1984-hes-still-trying-to-figure-out-2016/ https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/the-fix/wp/2016/05/12/th.... A quick look at his "13 keys" list suggests to me that Lichtman will probably predict a Trump win this year (even though he despises Trump), whether or not the challenger is charismatic. That's mostly because of economic indicators. If those change, the prediction probably changes. It will be interesting to see how Lichtman interprets his list this year.
- 7y ago
- trophycase 7y agoLol, literally nobody supports Bloomberg. He's only riding on name recognition alone.
- danenania 7y agoWhy would you try to extrapolate from results in Iowa? It's a.) a caucus, which has weird effects on turnout, and b.) not at all representative of Democrat voters. And if you are going to extrapolate from Iowa, you can't simply ignore Sanders' dramatic over-performance with the few minorities that do live there. You're also referencing polls on who would vote for a Democratic socialist, while ignoring polls of who would vote for Sanders specifically, overall approval ratings of Sanders (consistently near the top for any politician in the country), and head-to-head polls of Sanders vs. Trump. It's pretty clear that you're just cherrypicking to fit a narrative. You're entitled to your opinion, but don't pretend it's supported by data in any sort of definitive way when that's plainly not the case.
- rayiner 7y agoI’m extrapolating from Iowa because it provides concrete data about the nature of Sander’s plurality support. He’s clearly the #1 choice of a significant minority of democrats. But is he the #2 choice of a sufficient number of others? Or is he only winning a plurality because the anti-Sanders candidates can’t pick an alternative? (On this front, it’s critical to note that Biden was leading Sanders by large margins until he fell apart in Iowa.) Matchups against Trump this far out are not helpful. In the months before the nomination, Clinton had up to a 10 point lead on Trump. That closed significantly once the campaigning started. The nomination is when the rubber hits the road. That’s when the attack ads will start, going into Sanders’ lengthy record of anti-Amrrican, communist sympathizing statements. That’s not baked into the poll numbers for Sanders yet. (Meanwhile, all of Trump’s bad statements are already baked into his poll numbers.)
- danenania 7y ago"He’s clearly the #1 choice of a significant minority of democrats. But is he the #2 choice of a sufficient number of others? Or is he only winning a plurality because the anti-Sanders candidates can’t pick an alternative?" He's also winning handily in national head-to-head polls vs. others in the primary, which seem a lot more relevant to me than Iowa caucus realignment numbers: https://today.yougov.com/topics/politics/articles-reports/2020/02/18/democrat-head-to-head-poll https://today.yougov.com/topics/politics/articles-reports/20... "Matchups against Trump this far out are not helpful." Ah, so we can base all kinds of conclusions on a poll asking "would you vote for a Democratic socialist?", but one taken at the same time asking "would you vote for Bernie Sanders or Donald Trump?" is not helpful? :-/
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- iron0013 7y ago"Sanders won a plurality, but tellingly he did terribly in second alignments." <-- This is a lie, by the way. Second alignments benefited Sanders more than almost any other candidate: https://www.npr.org/2020/02/08/803953713/graphics-how-iowas-vote-totals-shifted-from-the-1st-alignment-to-the-2nd https://www.npr.org/2020/02/08/803953713/graphics-how-iowas-... The poster I'm replying to often sneaks lies into his wall-of-text posts when he thinks no one will notice or call him on it.
- rayiner 7y agoYour own link shows that people went to Buttigieg more than 2:1 over Sanders in the second alignment. Apart from that, the movement in vote total between the first and second rounds combines two effects, but we’re interested in just one of those. Your analysis of the second round data marks a positive count for a candidate where someone moves to that candidate in the second round from a candidate that didn’t hit the 15% threshold in the first round. (That’s the only way for someone to switch.) But it also marks a negative count where a candidate doesn’t meet the 15% threshold in a precinct and his or her supporters have to move to another candidate. We don’t really care about that second effect, because that just measures whether a candidate is able to consistently get above 15%. What we want to predict is, as you knock out Biden, Warren, etc., where do their supporters go? You can find that out directly from the released caucus data, by looking at where supporters of those candidates go in precincts where those candidates don’t hit the 15% threshold. Most of those supporters don’t go to Bernie, which means Bernie is not their first choice or their second choice. Polling backs that up: https://civiqs.com/documents/Civiqs_ISU_banner_book_2020_01_cg3q62ypb43uz6bb.pdf https://civiqs.com/documents/Civiqs_ISU_banner_book_2020_01_.... Right before the Iowa caucuses, Sanders was the first or second choice of 37% of eligible Iowa primary voters. That means for 2/3 of the party, Sanders was neither the first nor the second choice.
- claudeganon 7y agoBernie just won 70%+ of the Hispanic vote in Nevada, and came in second to Biden with African Americans, so please adjust your caucus extrapolations accordingly: https://twitter.com/UCLAlatino/status/1231622727808610304 https://twitter.com/UCLAlatino/status/1231622727808610304