7 ms·
Why Does College Cost So Much?
- larsberg 16y agoI wonder what role the diminished state of funding has had on increased college costs. In the 90s, the money from DARPA/ONR and even NSF flowed quite readily into schools, which take 50-55% of that as "overhead" costs. Now, military research funding is more commercially targeted, and the combination of competition and shrinking funding for the NSF has turned it into a dogfight over scraps (at least so it seems in CS).
- mcgillroy 16y agohow I love socialist europe: free world class college in germany and france, in holland and danmark, in austria and switzerland. that and world class health care for free too. yes taxes are high, insanely high by american standards - but in the end it more than evens out. plus life is less stressful.
- anonymoushn 16y agoI don't think they are insanely high by American standards. The marginal tax rate for Americans of almost all income levels is about 40%, until it drops to 15% or lower if you're extremely wealthy and able to route all your income through "investments."
- mode0 16y agoWhere do you get this figure?
- anonymoushn 16y agoMSN article: http://articles.moneycentral.msn.com/Taxes/Advice/YourRealTaxRate40.aspx http://articles.moneycentral.msn.com/Taxes/Advice/YourRealTa... Paper: http://www.kotlikoff.net/sites/default/files/Does%20It%20Pay,%20at%20the%20Margin,%20to%20Work%20and%20Save.pdf http://www.kotlikoff.net/sites/default/files/Does%20It%20Pay... HN discussion: http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=1656323 http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=1656323
- mode0 16y agoThanks for the links!
- danik 16y agoTaxes are higher, but you don't have to pay for private insurances, healthcare etc. to the same extent. I don't know why people keep bringing up the level of taxes, it's not important or interesting. What's important is how big part of your salary you need to spend on necessities like government, schools, roads, healthcare and pension. That's what should be measured.
- Vivtek 16y agoI don't know why people keep bringing up the level of taxes Because it wouldn't be profitable if people looked at service levels instead of an artificial number that made them think they were getting something other than the short end of every stick in their vicinity?
- danik 16y agoI know why politicians do that, but why do people do it here on ycombinator?
- Vivtek 16y agoThey really need to think they're not getting short ends of sticks, because if they thought they were being taken for fools by the powerful they'd have to downgrade their self-opinions. Tribal buy-in works on all primates.
- Vivtek 16y agoNot insanely high, once you add up what Americans pay for health insurance that won't actually pay out if they get sick, plus state and local taxes, and higher usage fees and so on. My daughter will probably be going to TU München instead of Purdue, actually. It's time to blow this popsicle stand.
- apl 16y agoGood university, and way better than 90% of what the American HE market has to offer. Unless, of course, you value the electives system a lot.
- Vivtek 16y agoShe wants to do Aerospace, and Purdue is pretty good there (4th in the US) and we are Indiana residents - and it would still cost $40,000 plus room and board. Tuition at TU München is 500 Euros a semester and you finish a degree in three years instead of four (because they don't have to spend a year at the outset on remedial courses). Student residences are subsidized, student meals are subsidized instead of being private buffets - I mean, financially it's a no-brainer. She'll get a comparable education and we can take the same money and buy her a house when she's done. Plus my wife is Hungarian and has been wanting to go back to Budapest for a while now. So ... it's time.
- mbesto 16y agoHey Michael! Sounds great. München is an awesome city. Much better than Lafayette (sorry Purdue fans). She'll learn German too! Question: As an American citizen how is it possible to take advantage of this?
- barry-cotter 16y agoCitizenship has no bearing on German university entrance requirements. For almost all Bachelor programmes you need German. As an English speaker it's not that hard to learn, I met a med student last month who was accepted provisionally, conditional on acceptable TestDaF results and went from no German to sufficient to study medicine in three months (of 8 hours a day, 5 days a week study.) Note that most US high school diplomas will not get you into a German university, you need APs or community college credits. I am guessing that it would get you into a Fachhochschule[1] (again, you would need German) which grants Bachelor degrees, but is more vocational than the Universities. [1]"University of Applied Sciences" is an abombinable translation, which tells you nothing, but it's the official translation.
- brudgers 16y agoFrom what I understand about the German education system , significant features of US education are missing [I cannot speak to the others] - primarily a pursuit of universal access to higher education and the opportunity for second, third, and fourth chances at a college degree. To put access in perspective, University of Phoenix has 400,000 students - the entire German higher education system issues about the same number of Abitur each year. In the US more than half the population [55%] has some college compared to 22% of the German population with post-secondary education. The percentage of the US population with Masters and PHD is almost as large [10.5%] as the percentage of German population with any type of University degree [13.6%]. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Educational_attainment_in_the_United_States http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Educational_attainment_in_the_U... http://www.destatis.de/jetspeed/portal/cms/Sites/destatis/Internet/EN/Content/Statistics/BildungForschungKultur/Bildungsstand/Tabellen/Content100/Bildungsabschluss,templateId=renderPrint.psml http://www.destatis.de/jetspeed/portal/cms/Sites/destatis/In... http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Abitur http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Abitur
- apl 16y ago> [...] and the opportunity for second, third, and > fourth chances at a college degree. Can you clarify what you mean by that?
- brudgers 16y agoIn the US it is easy for people to return to university after dropping out. Even doing so multiple times is not a consideration for admission, e.g. I had five different majors over 12 years at three different universities (plus a stint in vocational school) before earning a bachelor's degree. It is also common people to pursue a bachelor's degree in their 30's or 40's or later. Culturally, in large part this is a result of the changes to US higher education created by the GI bill following WWII - one of my grandfathers earned his bachelor's degree at the age of 40 following the war and my father in law his bachelor's at 43 after retiring from the navy in the 1970's. But pursuing a degree in later life is not just tied to the GI Bill. One of my brothers-in law earned his bachelor's online at 51, another has earned two Master's degrees after age 40 (bachelor's at 36) and a third earned his bachelor's at 46. None of my relatives would have been considered for the Gymnasium under the German system and my switching majors four times would have been frowned upon within German higher education(from Electrical Engineering to Chemistry to Geology to Chemistry Education to Philosophy)
- watchandwait 16y agoFrench universities are a disaster: http://www.nytimes.com/2006/05/12/world/europe/12france.html http://www.nytimes.com/2006/05/12/world/europe/12france.html
- barry-cotter 16y agoThey spend less per capita on university students than on high school students, have something verging on universal access, and, looking at their economy, get approximately similar value out of the education system as the USA for much, much lower expenditure, and that's a disaster? Sure, university is not as much fun or as luxurious as in the states, but what is actually wrong with the French system for French society? Note, I did not say for French students or French academics.
- anamax 16y ago> yes taxes are high, insanely high by american standards - but in the end it more than evens out. plus life is less stressful. The US tax revenue per person is about the same as the tax revenue per person in Western European countries. (The US collects more taxes per person than Canada.) That means that the US govt has the money to provide europe-class services. It doesn't, but that's not due to a lack of money. Note that US GDP per person is significantly higher than much of Western Europe.
- anonymoushn 16y agoI suspect that Peter Schiff is closer to the mark. http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=AIcfMMVcYZg#t=1m30s http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=AIcfMMVcYZg#t=1m30s His hypothesis is that increasing the capacity of students to pay (to almost arbitrarily high levels) by providing government guarantees of student loans allows allows schools to charge ridiculously high tuition. To some extent, this is correct, and there is no reason for the people involved not to want to increase tuitions. For the school, higher tuition will mean the school can improve itself and become more attractive to students. For the lenders, higher tuition means more loans returning 5% or more for which the government assumes all the risk. It isn't entirely accurate to say "the government assumes all the risk" either. Student debts are the most toxic debts around, and cannot be thrown off in bankruptcy. If you refuse to pay, the government is authorized to garnish your wages or raid your savings. This isn't to say that Schiff's hypothesis explains the entirety of the increase in the cost of tuition, but I think that it plays a much larger role than what is discussed in the article.
- Vivtek 16y agoThat is entirely plausible, though - the same reason house prices went through the roof.
- slavak 16y agoThis seems to be a much better explanation than the article provides, which seems to be along the lines of "the smart people teaching in college must be paid a lot." The answer to the question posed by the headline is: It isn't. The correct question would be "Why does College cost so much IN THE US?," which implies there's a fundamental difference between the higher education system of the United States vs. that of a large part of the world. You COULD claim that professors in other countries are being paid ridiculously low wages, but this sounds far fetched. A much more convincing explanation, in my opinion, would involve the difference in the way the economy of higher education works in the US versus other parts of the world.
- Duff 16y agoI think that it is one of the driving factors, and that the experience of the housing bubble confirms it. I live in sleepy Albany, NY, which as a state capital and small city it is a pretty stable place. No boom-bust cycles at all -- it's always "ok" in the region as a whole. House prices that were stable from the mid 80's to 1999 suddenly went mad, up to the median income in the area for the legions of state workers. If you tried to buy a $200k house, there would be a bidding war minutes after the sign went up... but not much above $250k.
- btipling 16y agoThe article links to this other article which I find to be a better summary of the book and answer to the question: http://www.insidehighered.com/views/2010/10/19/feldman http://www.insidehighered.com/views/2010/10/19/feldman
- nhangen 16y agoOn top of this, I'm amazed at the differences in cost between state and out of state tuition. Is this because of state funding, or is it because it's another income stream for colleges and universities?
- brudgers 16y agoTraditionally, the former. More frequently the latter as state universities increasingly strive to attract out of state students as a way to offset price controls set by state legislatures.
- bugsy 16y agoThe reason is that the colleges are subsidized by state property, income and sales taxes which are paid by residents over many decades, but not by out of state students.
- neutronicus 16y agoWhere I went to school, there was an "international programs in engineering office," a "minorities in engineering program office," a "engineering student entrepreneurship office", and many more that I can't remember, presumably duplicated on the liberal arts side, all populated by people earning salaries from the University. It seems like there are a lot of people earning livings off of the University system who aren't educators or researchers. Maybe there's been a lot of growth in this sort of thing since the cheap-college days of yore?
- yummyfajitas 16y agoBut they need to meet the "evolving standard of care in education that is set externally." One of the most revealing pieces of this interview: ...the dark little secret about these [merit] grants. They do not create access to higher education for students who otherwise could not go. Interesting - merit grants are not helpful for people who can't afford college? Doesn't that imply that people who can't afford college (mostly) lack merit? Oops, politically incorrect thought.
- _delirium 16y agoThe high-level administration has multiplied also, in addition to the more peripheral administrative initiatives growing. Where there might have once been a Chancellor and perhaps a Vice Chancellor, there's now a whole Office of the Chancellor, a slew of Vice-Chancellors and Executive Vice Chancellors and Provosts and Deans and Associate Deans, all with staff, etc. Their pay has also increased, even relative to other university pay; the salary multiple of top-level administrators relative to a median professor in 2010 versus 1960 is much larger. It seems to largely be a result of the professionalization of the administration; in ye olden days universities were largely self-run by the faculty, with Deans and Vice-Deans just being professors who moved up into that position, sometimes rotating in temporarily. Now there's a whole category of professional career administrators who jump school-to-school, roughly parallel to the executive-management class in private-sector organizations (and they expect salaries in the $200k-$600k range).
- cletus 16y agoInevitably the comparison will be made to those countries that provide free higher education as being superior. I strongly disagree, for several reasons: 1. Anything that's free but is limited gets abused. You need look no further than the NHS in the UK were most GPs are employees of the NHS. Office hours of 9-4 (ie no incentive to provide a better service) are typical, the system clogged up with people who either don't need to see a doctor or, in the case with many old age pensioners, they simply go to the doctor for someone to talk to. 2. I would love to see some study in this but it is my belief that reducing the cost of higher education increases the earning potential of college graduates. When I went to university (in Australia) it certainly seemed to be the case that the earning potential difference between graduates and non-graduates wasn't anywhere as near as the difference in the US; 3. Free systems create extra demand from people who don't really want to be there and are simply going for the lifestyle, which may in turn keep others who really want to go out; 4. Governments may pay per college student but those funds aren't distributed equally. When I went almost nothing was spent on first-year students. Most of that money was diverted to research activities, which brings into question the quality of education the government was paying for; 5. If you accept the premise that paid college leads to higher earning potential, countries that have free higher education will lose people to those countries where you pay as the labour mobility is high and only getting higher. I believe this at least in part explains the brain drain from Eastern Europe to the US in the 90s; and 6. Demand will be increased by other countries. In Germany, for example, you have a lot of Brazilians who go there for free university, typically going there for 6-12 months prior to learn German. One of the reasons that college costs so much is probably the same reason health care (in the US) costs so much: it's a protected market of sorts. In the US, IP laws mean drugs in Canada and elsewhere cost a fraction of what they do in the US (and most of the cost basis for drugs in the US goes on marketing not research). If you want to be a doctor (of cours) you need to go to college. But what about a computer programmer? Many of the best companies will require a college degree. A computer science education is obviously useful but not a prerequisite to learning to program. Most programmers I know learnt to program before or outside college. So what you have a captive market. It would be reasonable to assume that competition between colleges would sort this out but that doesn't seem to be the case. Sure there is competition for students and teaching/research talent but that's not the same thing. For example, a friend of mine believes (rightly or wrongly) she'll probably never get a great teaching job because her PhD (in history) isn't from a top school like Harvard or Princeton (IIRC). So you can choose to make a purely economic decision and go to a cheaper school but the cheaper and more expensive schools aren't necessarily equivalent, either in fact or in perception (which can be far more important). I suspect this won't change until something disrupts the higher education system itself.
- reader5000 16y agoCollege is how the older generation exploits the younger generation, in addition to ss and medicare. The demand for work is inelastic (and purchasing a college degree is roughly purchasing a necessary license to work), there is no competitive market in colleges (colleges do not compete for students on price), and basically there is no way the system could NOT financially destroy the upcoming generation. The bastion of hope is that as old people die off and young people take political power, student indebtedness will be erased.
- watchandwait 16y agoThis pattern is more common than you realize. Anytime the government introduces a subsidy, from farm bills to mortgage deductions to limits on the number of doctors, it hugely benefits those with an existing stake in that market. The value of the subsidy is quickly capitalized into the market-- farmland prices escalate with the subsidies, for example. As a result, new entrants get none of the benefit of the subsidy, but instead get to pay higher, distorted prices to enter the market to provide or buy that good or service. Government subsidies not only cheat the public at large, but even in a specific industry they reward the current stakeholders and punish the next generation of stakeholders.
- timdellinger 16y agoA year in college (tuition + room and board) is still cheaper than a year in prison (tuition + room and board). Both have price pressures that are similar in some respects, including both state-funded and for-profit versions. Both systems have mediocre performance at their primary missions (rehabilitation, education). There are significant start-up costs in both systems that make starting a new facility difficult. Decisions are made by leadership in both systems to optimize for things other than customer benefit.
- tastybites 16y agoCollege costs a lot for the same reason that houses do: you can either be rich and buy in cash, or leverage up and amortize a huge payment into relatively small monthly payments, making it seem affordable. Once purchasers start leveraging to purchase a good or service, price elasticity goes way up. Not to mention both are part of the classical 'American dream'.