3 ms·
Here's a concrete example where I think it goes wrong. You say something, and two people respond. There's one thing to say in response to both people - maybe th
by chrisseaton 7y ago
Here's a concrete example where I think it goes wrong. You say something, and two people respond. There's one thing to say in response to both people - maybe they both misunderstood part of your point. Which comment do you respond to? On places like HN people seem to feel the need to respond to both branches, which causes exponential growth if it continues, compared to if you could respond to the two comments as one. Maybe we need a comment DAG instead? Responding to an arbitrary number of comments? Maybe comments that aren't even siblings?
- bmn__ 7y ago> Maybe we need a comment DAG instead? Internet messages (Usenet, email) already work that way. If you want to reply to multiple messages, this is easily possible. Most users are not familiar with it because the widely implemented threading algorithm prunes the graph into a tree for display purposes. https://ddg.gg/?q=jwz+email+threading https://ddg.gg/?q=jwz+email+threading
- clarry 7y ago> Maybe we need a comment DAG instead? HN comments are a DAG. DAGs are branchy, which is the problem. It seems like you want to merge or rebase the two comments and then reply with a new node pointing to the last of them.
- doubleunplussed 7y agoHacker news comments are a restricted DAG where a node can't have multiple parents. Obviously they're referring to that property. The branches could come back together again.
- chrisseaton 7y ago> HN comments are a DAG. Come on don’t be pedantic you know what I mean - I mean a DAG that is not also a tree - so using the merging property of a DAG. If HN were a DAG then I could make this reply to your comment and someone else’s on another part of the discussion at the same time. > merge or rebase These are source control terms - I’m not sure how they apply here.
- icebraining 7y ago> These are source control terms - I’m not sure how they apply here. Git is a DAG too.