5 ms·
"Mainstream medicine" doesn't have "only one answer for almost all diseases." Think of the almost stereotypical statement from a doctor: "Stop smoking, eat less
by dalke 16y ago
"Mainstream medicine" doesn't have "only one answer for almost all diseases." Think of the almost stereotypical statement from a doctor: "Stop smoking, eat less, and exercise more." There's research in burn therapy and speech therapy and many other fields which has nothing to do with drugs. The push for mosquito netting is a prevention remedy for malaria. Go back in history and you'll find that garbage collection in large cities was often run by the public health department. Even the law that "all employees must wash hands before going back to work" is there for a medical reason.
Here's what the WHO says about cancer: http://www.who.int/mediacentre/news/releases/2003/pr27/en/ http://www.who.int/mediacentre/news/releases/2003/pr27/en/ . 1/3rd of the cases can be prevented by "Reduction of tobacco consumption", "A healthy lifestyle and diet", and "Early detection through screening". The first two of those have nothing to do with drugs.
Also: "The predicted sharp increase in new cases – from 10 million new cases globally in 2000, to 15 million in 2020 - will mainly be due to steadily ageing populations in both developed and developing countries and also to current trends in smoking prevalence and the growing adoption of unhealthy lifestyles." Feel free to download the full report.
As for "treatments to ANY major disease that are not monetizable as drugs"; vaccines are not drugs. Getting the shot for tetanus is much less profitable to a pharmaceutical company than going through treatment, but no one seriously argues for removing the vaccine so pharmas can make more profit.
Economically, if there is a major disease then people will pay to not have the disease. Therefore there's always going to be an issue of money involved, even if it's promoting a diet or exercise program. The flip side of your question is, do any major diseases have a remedy which can be done without monetization? Most of the historically big ones are solved (eg, by washing hands before assisting in a birth, or making sure children get vitamin D). Plus, the non "mainstream" medicines are also influenced by the money; look how big the homeopatic industry is.
"There are no other types of treatments out there besides pills?" I just listed a half-dozen.
"And that there aren't any cures to be found?" Pardon? Up until the 1980s the treatment for gastric ulcers was "rest, bland foods, and drink milk." Now we know most ulcers are caused by Helicobacter pylori and it's completely curable with drugs. How is this not a cure? Or what is it you want?
As for "a better way of organizing and verifying medical information about various drugs, research, conditions, etc." -- what is it you want? Go to http://cdc.gov/ http://cdc.gov/ . They've spent a lot of time compiling overview information. Want more information? Medical researchers have spent a lot of time providing exactly what you've asked for. What is it you want?
If anything, it's the paradox of choice. There's so much information that most people ignore what's available, because they would rather not have to wade through everything. Which is why drug ads, and dieting ads, and fitness ads, and so on work. Sad to say.
The statement that "most of the innovation comes from the independents" is just wrong. Read http://www.nature.com/nrd/journal/v9/n11/abs/nrd3251.html http://www.nature.com/nrd/journal/v9/n11/abs/nrd3251.html . During 1998-2007, 252 new drugs were approved by the FDA. 58% had their origin in pharmaceutical companies, 18% in biotech, and 24% from universities.
Besides, most of the university research _is_ published freely, although it can cost money to access the journals (or a visit to a research library). And just because a novel compound shows effectiveness in a research environment doesn't mean it will become a good drug, and there's a lot of research which needs to be done to get from "I have an idea which works in a test tube" to "here's a new treatment for a disease", and most of the intermediate steps are "doesn't work, try again."
- EGreg 16y agoThanks. I mostly posted my last message as a way to get informative responses, which I think this is :) I sometimes like to learn more about a subject matter I'm interested in, while discussing it, so it was late at night and I decided that was a good way to learn a little more -- by overstating my case in my ignorance and getting different viewpoints. Although I do want to ask one thing ... to answer whether there are treatments to ANYmajor disease that are not monetizable as drugs, you said that besides drugs, there are also vaccines. But aren't vaccines developed the same way -- basically patented by pharma companies? Also, is there a list somewhere of cures developed in the last 30 years? I just have this impression that the pharma company is a big "sponsor" of medicine and that alternative treatments or cures don't really take hold in the mainstream medical community (i.e. when you go to a doctor) ... and that there is very little "official" information about them. So it's hard to figure out what works and what doesn't when you have a disease that may be cured using alternative methods, like some forms of cancer etc.
- dalke 16y agoSo you want me (or others) to hand walk you through the field of medical research, instead of doing 10 minutes of Google research? Did you go to the FDA or NIH home pages to research your questions? FDA lists a number of other non-drug remedies on their home page including medical devices, radiation devices, xenotransplantation, and blood substitutes. "Cures developed in the last 30 years" is highly judgmental. Does LASIK surgery to correct nearsightedness count as a cure? Is being overweight a disease? And gastric bypass one possible cure? What about hepatitis C treatment which has a 90% likelihood of clearing the body of the disease, vs. 40% without the treatment? Do you count melanoma cures, by detecting the disease early and removing affected tissue? Diabetes used to be deadly. Now is isn't cured but it is easily treatable. Does that count? Cochlear implants so that once deaf people can now hear? Artificial corneas so the blind can see again? HIV treatments so that what was once a guaranteed death sentence within 5 years is now a manageable disease? Did you at all try searching for the answers to your question? Just about everything I listed here should be common knowledge. Yet when I look for pages that talk about useful treatments and remedies, they are overwhelmed by people like you who disbelieve all the successes, and are SURE that the pharmaceutical industry is hiding the real cures. Since you know, employees at pharmaceutical companies and their friends and family never get those major disease. The reason there is little "official" information about alternative treatments is that they've been tested over and over again, and not proven effective, and in cases harmful. Bear in mind that there's a big and mostly unregulated industry behind alternative medicines, so there's also strong political pressure to keep those so-called treatments available. The homeopathic industry in the US has revenues of around US$1 billion. The chiropractic industry makes about $18 billion in revenue, with $430 million by sales of "supplements." Traditional Chinese Medicine is about $5 billion and acupuncture about the same. This is at least $10 billion of industry - surely they can provide rigorous tests. Just how much of the alternative market is spent on research? Not much that I can tell. That gives a strong incentive to either castigate "mainstream" medicine or to promote itself as "complementary", and little incentive to verify claims. Since you overstate your case, I'll overstate mine - you are being brainwashed by snakeoil charlatans. There is no evidence other than anecdotal stories that alternative medicines cure any sort of cancer.