4 ms·
> If you don't like Google you can use Duck Duck Go This is not true. Sure, you can stop searching with Google. But Google, being a surveillance company, colle
by mindslight 7y ago
> If you don't like Google you can use Duck Duck Go
This is not true. Sure, you can stop searching with Google. But Google, being a surveillance company, collects data from many sources besides search. They have gotten most websites to implement their bugs (Analytics and Recaptcha), and buy troves of data from other surveillance companies (Experian, LexisNexis, etc), so it is impossible to just "stop" being abused by them.
I personally believe that the best way is to fix the longstanding security problems in web browsers that leak all of this personal information in the first place. But as long as we're talking about legalistic approaches, then it seems eminently reasonable to condemn all surveillance companies for unilaterally snooping (including the faux consent of purported "contracts"), the same way that if I leave my curtains open and someone snaps a picture of me naked, they're not free to openly sell it.
- AnthonyMouse 7y ago> Sure, you can stop searching with Google. But Google, being a surveillance company, collects data from many sources besides search. So choose alternatives to the other things too and/or install a browser plugin that blocks their tracking bugs. > and buy troves of data from other surveillance companies (Experian, LexisNexis, etc) The perpetrators in that case are the other surveillance companies. But now we're getting into the real trouble here -- there are places you can get a loan without credit reporting, but you won't get the same interest rate, because the lower interest rate from the places that use credit reporting is a direct result of the way in which credit reporting affects likelihood to repay the loan. So what do you expect to happen to loan interest rates if you make it illegal to set the interest rate based on whether the user consents to credit reporting? It's problems like that which make privacy regulations hard, and justify applying them primarily to companies that lack effective competition.
- mindslight 7y ago> So choose alternatives to the other things too It's only appropriate to say this in the context of what one can possibly try doing, not as a justification based on failing to have done this. The amount of websites deploying surveillance is the sheer majority of all websites, especially for many specific sectors. > and/or install a browser plugin that blocks their tracking bugs I did say that I have the highest hope in technical solutions, but once again this eventual hope is not a justification for writing off legalistic approaches. > So what do you expect to happen to loan interest rates if you make it illegal to set the interest rate based on whether the user consents to credit reporting? For one, secured interest rates wouldn't changed appreciably because there is collateral to foreclose. Even so, any increase would make asset prices drop such that more people would be able to own things rather than renting them from banks. Surveillance and financialization are both centralizing forces, and I am generally opposed to both. As for the general idea of legitimate interests for consumer surveillance, these records should ultimately be under the control of the surveillance subjects ourselves rather than unaccountable hostile parties. At the very least, a surveillance subject should be able to request a copy of all records, request that they be deleted, and request that they be reinstated from a signed export (and ideally only processed for a very narrow purpose).