4 ms·
Not your project, not your choice. “Free” refers to the software license of the source code. That is it. The maintainers of a free software project don’t even
by dangus 7y ago
Not your project, not your choice.
“Free” refers to the software license of the source code. That is it.
The maintainers of a free software project don’t even have to accept contributions outside of their organization or club.
Private companies that use all kinds of proprietary communication tools regularly contribute to free software. Are all of Red Hat’s internal conversations about Fedora guaranteed to make it into the public?
People are also perfectly capable of having private conversations about contributions to free software projects. These conversations don’t ever have to be made public. Again, only the code license is what makes a piece of software free.
So if you don’t like a project’s method of communication, my advice would be to not contribute to it. It’s the project’s own risk of deterring potential contributors, not yours.
I find it hilarious that someone would find themselves feeling entitled enough to tell a bunch of unpaid open source developers how to communicate with one another as if that someone were their boss at a company. The only place where I’m told what communication tools to use is at work, where I’m paid to comply.
- orblivion 7y agoIf you're working on a project and just happen to choose a free software license, then fair enough. (perhaps you'd call yourself more of an "open source" contributor). If however you are acting due to the free software ethos, I think it's fair for others who share the ethos to chime in with their opinion on how well you're doing it. It doesn't have to be a witch hunt, but these things matter more than a zero amount.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- dangus 7y agoWhat’s the difference between “just happening” to choose a free license and “acting due to the free software ethos?” Hopefully the free software ethos police doesn’t come knocking on my door because I used GPL 3.0 without having the right mindset.
- orblivion 7y agoIf you as the maintainer said "hey, I don't really care about Free Software, I just think this is a fun/useful project and the GPL 3.0 meets my needs." and people still bugged you about Discord, I agree you should probably just tell them to fuck off. They might still try to get you on board with Free Software in the first place, but it wouldn't make sense to bother you about details like a chat program if/while you don't care about the cause. However if you said "I'm creating this project because I care about user freedom" someone might point out "Great. Well, since we're on the same page as far as user freedom, let's take a look at the tools we're using..."
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- zzo38computer 7y agoAll of that is correct, but, it does not mean that suggestions cannot be made. So, the article linked here mentions their suggestions, I mention my suggestion, etc. Yes, private conversions about contributions to free software projects are possible and are sometimes desirable. But, messages on the official channels for communications should normally be public; people can (and should) of course still use their own private communication as needed, too, but does not mean you cannot have a public one too.
- chrisseaton 7y agoSuggestions? Seems more like demands in the linked blog post.
- guerrilla 7y agoThere's no coercive power behind them. You're free to do what they say or not.
- kome 7y ago> “Free” refers to the software license of the source code. That is it. You might want to read this: https://www.gnu.org/philosophy/open-source-misses-the-point.html https://www.gnu.org/philosophy/open-source-misses-the-point....
- thiht 7y agoThat's one person's idea about what "free" means. GNU and Stallman don't own the concept of "free", nor do they claim it
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- sneak 7y agoI’m not telling anyone to do anything. I’m telling people what they should not do: that is, don’t discriminate against people who insist on privacy. Choosing to use Discord does that, so people who don’t want to discriminate should not choose to use Discord. I’m also offering them alternatives that don’t discriminate against those people, so that they can make better choices if they decide that they don’t want to be the kinds of projects that discriminate against segments of their userbase.
- chrisseaton 7y agoI think if you humbly said you’d prefer people to not use Discord you’d not get this backlash. But you’re making a demand - it’s rude and will instantly turn people against you before they really consider your arguments.
- lidHanteyk 7y agoThis is literally tone policing, though. Knock it off.
- zchrykng 7y agoCriticizing someone for making demands, or pointing out that not making demands is more likely to actually accomplish what they want, is not tone policing.
- chrisseaton 7y agoThe argument against tone policing in a social justice sense is that people who are being wronged by society are allowed to be angry. This person isn't being wronged. They just don't like the software other people chose to use in their projects which have nothing to do with the author of the blog post! If someone tells you they're suffering racism you should listen no matter how it sounds to you. If someone tells you they don't like that you're using Slack and that you should not use it, you're right to tell them to sod off until they can be polite.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- aidenn0 7y ago> I find it hilarious that someone would find themselves feeling entitled enough to tell a bunch of unpaid open source developers how to communicate with one another as if that someone were their boss at a company. The only place where I’m told what communication tools to use is at work, where I’m paid to comply. They are making a moral argument against discord. If they said it was not acceptable for free software projects to go around hitting people on the head with clubs would that be entitled?
- dangus 7y agoI didn’t find the moral arguments against Discord convincing. Tin foil hat paranoia isn’t enough for me. The author is assuming their door is gonna get busted down and they’re going to get arrested over their discussions about a bug fix for an open source widget.
- el_cujo 7y ago>Not your project, not your choice. I feel like this should be obvious to anyone who has ever read a blogpost or editorial, but the author isn't literally commanding all free software projects to stop using discord as if he has that kind of authority, he's making a recommendation and then goes into detail about why he thinks this way, ending with some alternatives. It's bizarre seeing someone react to an article like this with offense not because of any of the content or points, but for... not showing enough deference in their title?