7 ms·
I agree that Discord is not a good choice, perhaps not even an acceptable choice. But. Discord (not to mention Slack) will simply continue to be the lowest fr
by falcolas 7y ago
I agree that Discord is not a good choice, perhaps not even an acceptable choice.
But.
Discord (not to mention Slack) will simply continue to be the lowest friction choice until a FOSS alternative comes along that is free to use, comes with rich moderation tools, supports fine-grained notification settings, supports offline history without additional effort, supports rich bots, has a mobile client that shares state with the desktop clients, and already exists on most people's desktops.
So to impact the open source communication landscape, the standard that needs to be exceeded is Slack and Discord, not IRC.
- jayfk 7y agoThere is Mattermost, Rocketchat and Zulip.
- dmead 7y agoall of which are high friction yes?
- dependenttypes 7y agoNo mention of Riot/Matrix?
- falcolas 7y agoDoes the matrix spec offer moderation tools? I don't see anything off the top of my head. It's also a bit of a chore to even identify how to get a server. Matrix.org points you towards other implementers, Riot.im pushes you back to matrix.org for a login, and to "Modular" for a server. This is kind of the opposite of low friction and ease of use. It seems pretty slick from a technological point of view, but a bit of a mess from an implementation point of view.
- Arathorn 7y agohttps://matrix.org/docs/guides/moderation https://matrix.org/docs/guides/moderation http://exple.tive.org/blarg/2020/02/20/synchronous-messaging-were-live/ http://exple.tive.org/blarg/2020/02/20/synchronous-messaging...
- falcolas 7y agoRespectfully, I've only heard of one of those before, and none of them are installed on any of my devices. Now, I looked up each of them, and found that they all rely on hosting your own server, or some kind of strictly limited "community" plan. The managed (and for Mattermost even self-hosted) servers all hide features (such as message history, rich moderation tools, or support tickets) behind a paywall. These are solutions aimed at enterprises, and they use open source (or open core) licenses as the foot in the door. It's commendable that they offer to let you host the server yourself, but I would not call it "simple" to do so. I believe that this high friction and low install base will make them effective non-starters in the open source development space.
- price 7y ago> they all rely on hosting your own server, or some kind of strictly limited "community" plan Happily this is not true of Zulip! Open-source projects get free hosting on zulipchat.com, with the exact same features as our corporate customers. Quoting from https://zulipchat.com/for/open-source/ https://zulipchat.com/for/open-source/ : > The hosting is supported by (and is identical to) zulipchat.com's commercial offerings. This offer extends to any community involved in supporting free and open source software: development projects, foundations, meetups, hackathons, conference committees, and more. (I work on Zulip.)
- andrewshadura 7y ago> The managed (and for Mattermost even self-hosted) servers all hide features (such as message history, rich moderation tools, or support tickets) behind a paywall. I know nothing about the other systems but this isn't true for Mattermost. We run Mattermost ourselves and it does indeed offer message history and moderation tools, they're part of the open source Mattermost version. I can't think of any feature that I miss from it, to be honest.
- gsich 7y agoWith no or terrible voice support.
- rand8462838 7y agoIts extremely high friction for the many developers who are not willing to sacrifice their freedom in order to contribute.
- jbob2000 7y agoThen pick a project to contribute to that doesn’t use discord. But don’t try to change the world to suit your needs.
- cycloptic 7y agoIf anyone is trying to change the world to suit their needs, it's Discord Inc, who ban any attempt at trying to integrate a client with their platform in a freedom-respecting way. It's a classic walled garden: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17462138 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17462138
- jbob2000 7y agoThen don’t use discord.
- cycloptic 7y agoI already don't use discord. My point is that it seems hypocritical to wall yourself off in a platform that bans third party software and tries to pressure everyone into using their client, while complaining that someone else is trying to change you to suit their needs.
- zchrykng 7y agoUmm how does that make sense? The project owner(s) picked a platform for their communication and presumably all current contributors are fine with the choice, and then some third party is coming along and demanding that the entire project change their entire communication system to accommodate this one person? How in the world is it hypocritical to tell said person to take a hike?
- buboard 7y agothe standard we need is IRC. just with encryption, ability to store messages, and notifications. we should stop reinventing things that work
- gothroach 7y agoSounds a bit like what you'd get with an IRC BNC, plus the encryption.
- ironmagma 7y agoWe need IRC with a few tweaks. There’s quite a few holes in IRC’s spec including lack of a scrollback support. But yes, there is no need to be making everything its own proprietary system.
- walrus01 7y agoThe old school solution to lack of scrollback support in IRC, and similar, is to run a persistent irc client (bitchx or irssi) inside screen or similar software, on a linux or bsd shell system, which has 24x7x365 uptime and network connectivity. And then to connect and disconnect to the screen session as needed. Properly implemented, I've had much better availability with this sort of solution than with Slack. I've seen multiple hour outages of Slack services just within the past 6 months, it's well below four or five nines reliability.
- hombre_fatal 7y agoThe problem is, that only fixes IRC for you, not the other 99.9% of users who you are presumably there to communicate with. Slack/Discord/etc. fix the problem for everyone. Trying to community-build on IRC just seems like an exercise in masochism. I think most projects and their users deserve better than that, and it's hard to do worse than IRC.
- walrus01 7y agoI absolutely agree that a semi-public or public community built on irc would not be the way to go in 2020. In my use case it's for much smaller groups of individuals who all know and work with each other, within private companies and small work groups.