4 ms·
I would have certainly taken this guy more seriously if I hadn't got a "won't you subscribe to my newsletter" popup in the middle of the article...
by nottorp 7y ago
I would have certainly taken this guy more seriously if I hadn't got a "won't you subscribe to my newsletter" popup in the middle of the article...
- dependenttypes 7y agoApparently ublock origin blocks this.
- xibalba 7y agoWhy? So this author wants to promote a newsletter. Is it so onerous to click an "X" that you would discredit the information in this article?
- dave_sullivan 7y agoOnerous? Meh. An annoying interruption and a dark pattern? Absolutely.
- freehunter 7y agoYes. If you want me to read your content, stop blocking me from reading your content while I am in the middle of reading your content.
- trevyn 7y agoIt shows that the author is incentivized by drawing traffic, which increases the likelihood of hyperbolized articles.
- tomnipotent 7y ago> author is incentivized by drawing traffic Of course he is, that's the whole point of writing.
- mwfunk 7y agoNo, that’s the whole point of advertising. Writing is about communicating ideas in good faith, otherwise I’m not interested.
- tomnipotent 7y ago> Writing is about communicating ideas in good faith Writing is a tool for whatever purpose the writer wants to use it for. To some that's advertising, for others it's writing online content and hoping to grow a newsletter list.
- mwfunk 7y agoEveryone has different priorities and motivations, for sure. I'm just saying that, if someone's priorities are growing a newsletter list first, and communicating ideas in good faith second, that's so much less interesting, and there's so much competition.
- choward 7y agoSometimes when I'm reading I'm just interested enough to keep reading. Then one of these pieces of garbage pop up and I immediate close the tab.
- privateSFacct 7y agoNo kidding - it's the sign too that you are kickbait junk usually!
- ubercow13 7y agoEven if you subscribe, what's the odds that this pops up again every time you open an article from the newsletter?
- tomnipotent 7y agoYou get free content and all it costs is clicking an "X"? Does no one realize how absurd it sounds, that we're whining over the cost of content being less than 1 second of our time.
- freehunter 7y agoThey owe us nothing but likewise we owe them nothing.
- Operyl 7y agoThe author's previous discussion on this matter: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22314168 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22314168 That said: totally agree, I hate modals like this.
- mumblemumble 7y agoThe reasoning rings so very hollow to me. This idea that the primary way to get people to come read what you have to say is to push it to them, and that this is such an important goal that it justifies nagging them for permission to be allowed to blast communiqués in their general direction, and that you can excuse yourself for annoying behavior like this by claiming that it's for the benefit of people who want the email but wouldn't be able to find a sign-up field in a sidebar - presumably a small minority of a small minority of total visitors - strikes me as being so very entitled. But then, I suppose that the basic idea of the attention economy is that you're supposed to be clawing at every scrap of Whuffie you can get. Granted, it's the author's website, and they get to do what they want with it. And we have apparently collectively decided that it's OK for any webpage, even one that contains only static content, to require JavaScript in order to function properly. A corollary to that would be that simply using the web is tacit consent to be pestered, since it's not really possible to have JavaScript enabled while also avoiding modern-day incarnations of the blink tag. So there's that. But still. . . I'd love to see RSS make a comeback, just to at least take away the "but RSS is dying" excuse.
- sneak 7y agoMy blog has a feed. If you’d like to see RSS make a comeback, perhaps you can subscribe to signal your support for decentralized tools. There is no javascript in the feed. :)
- samatman 7y agoHi sneak. Your reply on the Quora post basically says "if you browse the web like I do, you won't see the popup". If you reflect on that for a little bit, you'll realize you're doing something to your readers that you, yourself, won't tolerate. I'd encourage you not to. It detracts from your message.
- ddevault 7y agoAgree. I don't buy the author's explanation. This is user-hostile behavior, straight and simple. No one is going to use uBlock to fix your website - they're just going to close the tab. Which is what I did. I think he would get good results by putting an obvious signup form on his sidebar, underneath his contact details. Make it easy to notice, but don't make it an interruption.
- somehnguy 7y agoIt's a poorly implemented popup too. They're much less (but still) annoying if I can click anywhere outside it to dismiss instead of requiring the 'x' to be clicked.
- m-p-3 7y agoI despise email subscriptions, they add unnecessary noise in my mailbox. I believe RSS feeds are better suited for that kind of stuff, but I guess not everyone want or have an RSS reader.
- nottorp 7y agoTo those defending the newsletter popup... the main problem is it ruins the credibility of the article. Does he write like this because he has a strong opinion, or does he write like this because clickbait brings him subscribers? The ultra mega hyperbolized text and the needless association with open source (what, people not working on open source don't deserve privacy?) don't help either.