2 ms·
Command economies don’t work. The USSR experienced growth initially because Russia was an economic backwater. That ran out of steam by the 1960s. The USSR never
by rayiner 7y ago
Command economies don’t work. The USSR experienced growth initially because Russia was an economic backwater. That ran out of steam by the 1960s. The USSR never exceeded about 50% of US GDP, despite having a much larger population.
The USSR did some amazing things, for example in space. That just proves that a command economy can divert investment to specific ends. The USSR narrowly beat the US in several space milestones. We were close behind-such that we beat the USSR to the moon when their space program stumbled. But at the same time we developed advances in electronics, medicine, chemicals, etc., that weren’t even on the USSR’s radar. And we were doing all that while dedicating far less of our economy to investment (versus consumption).
Soviet industry was also breathtakingly inefficient. The USSR required five times as much energy to produce on unit of GNP than the US: http://pure.iiasa.ac.at/id/eprint/3500/1/RR-91-07.pdf http://pure.iiasa.ac.at/id/eprint/3500/1/RR-91-07.pdf. The Soviet Union had massive oil and gas reserves. But using vastly more concrete, steel, and energy to produce less durable goods than the US wasn’t sustainable.
- rafaelvasco 7y agoUSSR event went as far as researching the use of psychic abilities for espionage. US only started researching PSI later, fearing USSR would get the edge on that; It's very interesting to read CIA papers about remote viewing experiments; Funny to see so much people think these things are pure fabrications, fantasy etc, but the US has been researching this stuff for decades. If they bothered to expend the resources to do that it means something;
- UncleSlacky 7y agoCommand economies might work better now that we have the capability to transmit accurate market information in (near) real time.
- amylene 7y agoMy understanding is that it wasn’t the delays as much as the incentives to lie. Tech doesn’t fix what are essentially people problems.
- gallegojaime 7y agowe're probably way too clueless on that, but it would be interesting to try out. Chile's Project Cybersyn was coordinating productivity all the way back in the 70s, with Telex machines. Perhaps we can bottle some markets' behavior into computers and good C&C human structures.
- Barrin92 7y ago>Chile's Project Cybersyn was coordinating productivity should be pointed out that it was coordinating economic activity not in a 'command economy' sense. The project actually aimed to drastically decentralize economic decision making by applying cybernetic principles to factory work. The goal was for local managers to be able to respond to data in real time. De Beer's so called 'cybernetic factory' was even received positively by Hayek, who was not known for being a fan of command economies.