4 ms·
How can the public take informed decisions if the reasoned debate is always assumed to be held in secret? OK, national security and foreign negotiation is a sp
by tsimionescu 7y ago
How can the public take informed decisions if the reasoned debate is always assumed to be held in secret?
OK, national security and foreign negotiation is a special topic where secrecy can be warranted. But if the government of a country or union of countries is considering, say, pay cuts, why on earth would the population not be entitled to hearing all sides of the argument?
- tgv 7y agoHow can politicians take responsible measures if they can be called out on any nonsensical thing? Not that I'm against transparency, but there really are two sides to this. In the best case, politicians act in the interest of the people, which makes publication of their private dealings unwanted. In the worst case, they act against the interest of the people, which can only be dealt with by complete openness and independent justice. In practice, there's a balance between the two. And it's worse if the decision makers are judged by people that are only partially affected, such as in EU decisions.
- tsimionescu 7y agoI disagree completely. If there were real transparency, the public can also, in time, grow together with their politicians, and understand why certain decisions must be taken, and can help the public take a more active and measured role in their own government. Controlling the actions of politicians who explicitly act against the public interest is at best a minor win. Open and honest dialog is the much more important aspect of this. And the best case of this is - a politician working for the public interest convinces people to be mindful of their long term goals even when it contradicts their short term goals.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- koolba 7y ago> But if the government of a country or union of countries is considering, say, pay cuts, why on earth would the population not be entitled to hearing all sides of the argument? Deliberations are not arguments. Arguments are delivered after deliberation is complete. If you consider a group of advisors acting as an extension of the chief executive, it’s no different than asking for the chief executives private thoughts which is ludicrous.
- tsimionescu 7y agoPer your argument, parliament discussions should also be secret, because otherwise it would be like asking for the private thoughts of the head of parliament. But being more serious, deliberation is normally done between friendly parties before a negotiation, and perhaps it is usually fair to keep it private, especially before the actual negotiation has taken place. But the actual negotiation is an excersie in arguments and offers and counter offers, it is no longer a private affair. If the negotiation is over, you can no longer trust the parties to accurately tell a story of the real arguments that took place, since the arguments they tell everyone may well have been a result of the negotiation.