3 ms·
> some sort of meritocracy What definition of merit are you using that it's not? > most people don't describe themselves as racist, but a surprisingly high nu
by taneq 7y ago
> some sort of meritocracy
What definition of merit are you using that it's not?
> most people don't describe themselves as racist, but a surprisingly high number of people are
Calling people racist for preferring to date a particular race is just silly, you might as well call people sexist for preferring to date a particular gender.
- chillacy 7y agoIt really depends on the reason to prefer to date a particular race. A: If it's aesthetic, sure (though one might ponder to what extent euro-centric beauty standards are indicative of inherent attractiveness vs a desire to fit into the current dominant culture: fair skin is now very popular world-wide, skin lightening is a big thing in Asia, the most popular plastic surgery tends to try to replicate european features, etc) B: if it's because you think someone else's genes are inferior to yours... that might be the actual definition of racism. In his final book Where Do We Go From Here, MLK calls this out: > Often white liberals are unaware of their latent prejudices. A while ago I ran into a white woman who was anxious to discuss the race problem with me. She said: “I am very liberal. I have no prejudices toward Negroes. I believe Negroes should have the right to vote, the right to a good job, the right to a decent home and the right to have access to public accommodations. Of course, I must confess that I would not want my daughter to marry a Negro.” This lady could not see that her failure to accept intermarriage negated her claim to genuine liberalism. She failed to see that implicit in her rejection was the feeling that her daughter had some pure, superior nature that should not be contaminated by the impure, inferior nature of the Negro. It is the Teutonic Origins theory warmed over. The question of intermarriage is never raised in a society cured of the disease of racism.
- naasking 7y ago> This lady could not see that her failure to accept intermarriage negated her claim to genuine liberalism. No true Scotsman. Also, maybe she didn't want her daughter to suffer the cost of how society treated mixed race couples at the time. That's society's racism on display, not hers. I think we should all just be a little more charitable.
- taneq 7y agoI originally didn't respond to this because you had a pretty good point and I didn't really have anything to add to it. You're apparently getting hammered, though, so I feel like I should say something, so... you're spot on here. In defense of humankinds' innate fairness, though, I feel I should point out that all the reasoning about genetics and demographics and 'those people' in the world will not overrule someone's intrinsic assessment of a potential partner's attractiveness. The young lads and lasses will go out and shack up with whoever tickles their fancy. The older generation will tut-tut and justify their disapproval, but who ever listens to them?
- zeveb 7y ago> you might as well call people sexist for preferring to date a particular gender. Just give it a few years. I know that Slate (a mainstream publication) a few years ago published an article which mentioned in an aside that it is bigotry for a heterosexual man to refuse to date a male who identifies as a woman. I will be completely unsurprised if in a decade or two the same argument is applied to gender preference, period.
- streb-lo 7y agoCurrently someone who has transitioned is noticeably different than someone who was born that way. I think it's not far-fetched to imagine that in the future there will no longer be any 'uncanny valley' and the stigma will disappear.
- apta 7y agoIt won't happen. A man who pretends to be a woman still carries XY chromosomes. This is a fundamental reality with no way around it.
- DavidVoid 7y agoThey don't pretend to be women, transwomen are women (and transmen are men). There's a lot more to people and gender than chromosomes. And with your line of reasoning can an intersex person (such as someone with XXY chromosomes) never be considered a man nor a woman?
- apta 7y agoIntersex is a physical condition at the chromosome level. Gender dysphoria is a mental condition, so it follows that no, "transwomen" are not women, and "transmen" are not men, just how someone who believes that he's a dog doesn't make him a dog.
- streb-lo 7y agoA man can't go in space, can't fly, can't trick rocks into thinking, and can't do many things. But we do anways. Your understanding of reality is flawed. XY chromosomes provide the instructions for the human organism to construct a male body -- they do nothing to prevent the altering of it later on. Also, is this not 'hacker' news? Chromosomes are just the source code -- eventually we we will hack the souce or the binary all we want.